thredUPReviews 6,178

Seller and Buyer beware! SCAM!
I have purchased clothing and sent in clothing to resell through thredup on 2 separate occasions. NEVER AGAIN!
I gave them a second chance after my first experience, believing they were newer and could improve over time. The second experience is worse than the first. I sent in over $500 worth of new shoes, $500 worth of clothing, and 2 brand new bags worth over $300 together. They rejected almost everything, only keeping the lowest end things. For all this, they have offered me $60, and will not return any of the items stating, I didn't choose that option. I was NEVER given that option. Their response, "It is implied by the 'terms and conditions' of using our website."
I would much rather give those items to women in need.

They refuse to return anything I sent in because it "has been processed". There are pictures of it up on their website, so they could certainly go get them and return them to me. WHAT A SCAM! They have hard working women turn in clothes, which they resell at 500% markup from what they give the original owners. Retail has a 100% markup.

If you're looking for stylish clothing at an affordable price and don't want to leave your home--This is the right place for you! I was a bit skeptical about buying clothes online since I can't try them on first, but I picked my size, and ordered. Got my order in and it fit me perfectly, and I'm a plus sized lady. I am VERY happy with the pricing and the materials.

This site was great & now they're charging a restocking fee? And they didn't even inform me! I find out thru my account when I went to return some items. Lame! I liked this site for that very reason- I could return items either for store credit for free or pay a shipping fee & get my money back. They're even charging a fee if you received the item damaged! I know some places may charge a restocking fee but never on goods received damaged. And because I know these other companies charge a restocking fee, I don't buy from them. Thred up just sprung this on me. I have 2 of 3 shipments coming of an order. Funny how the first shipment isn't showing the restocking fee but the rest is. I don't even want to get store credit now because they're just gonna nickel & dime me to death with their restocking fee! And yes like others mentioned, don't sell your stuff on here. Not worth it. Sell it on eBay or some other platform. And also yes, why can't they wash items before sending out? Gross! It makes you feel like you shopped at a thrift store while paying department store prices. Thred up, I'm FED UP!

Please don't bother sending in anything of quality unless you would be donating it anyway or are happy with $1. Or so per item. You're better off trying Poshmark or selling at local consignment. The payout is truly shameful and I am not surprised to see a lot of complaints here.
On the other hand, the prices for purchasing are great... but in the Bay Area we have so many high end consignment shops that you are better off going to those instead. So... it's just a no for Thredup from me.

Nooooo! I loved ThredUp and have been using for two years, but I don't know that it will be worth it for me to continue to use thredup due to the new restocking fee. I usually can only keep about 25% of what I order due to size / things not looking like what I thought they would, and the restocking fee makes it almost not worth it to use the service. That would mean that on some orders my return would be 25 dollars and I would only end up keeping a few items. Might as well go to the store to try newer (albeit cheaper, like H&M) clothes on in person.

It seems like thredup's never been great for sellers... but as a buyer, I was so so happy with thredup for the past year+. Probably half of my everyday wardrobe is from thredup.

But, recently things have taken a bit of a turn:
- Like others have said, the $2 restocking fee makes it make way less sense to order from thredup. Not everything fits, so I end up returning about half of the items that I order for storecredit, which I use on my next order... but spending $2 to return a $15 shirt seems ridiculous. Would make way more sense if you had to keep a certain dollar value from your order, and pay shipping costs if you decided to keep less than that.
- I placed an order a couple of months ago, which was supposed to come in 3 boxes. Two came in a timely manner. The third still hadn't come a month later, with no update. I contacted them, they said "we'll look into it". A week later, still no response. I emailed them again, and they said oh actually, we never put the shipping label on it so it's not coming. They refunded me for the order, but it seems ridiculous to wait a month and a half with no updates from them -- and no sort of compensation for wasting my time.

I may still order from thredup occasionally, because I like their mission of reducing waste, and they do have a lot of reasonably priced decent items... but it doesn't make any sense now to make large frequent purchases, given the restock fee.

At first I thought I'd made a mistake, but after reading all the reviews, I realize it's not me, it's Thredup, listing a few of my items, paying me pennies, and disappearing with the rest without comment. But at least the buying side is great, right? NO. Prices up above what you'd pay new on sale, low end items or poor condition items clogging the site, sizing and descriptions off. And now a RESTOCKING FEE on "free shipping." Forget it. I used to love this site, but now I'll use up my credit and move on.

Sold some very nice items from brands such as eshakti and downeast basics that were in like-new condition, a huge bag full and my payoff was about $18.00. Really this is just a ripoff. Purchased a coat that was listed as a women's size 14 and the tag inside clearly states that it is a "M"--and I have to pay return shipping for their mistake? Really bad business to deal with. Never again.

I loved shopping on thredup because I could get whatever I wanted and just return the item if it didn't fit or I didn't like it once it arrived. I didn't have to worry about losing money because I'd just return for store credit. But now with this new restocking fee I'm afraid to add any items to my cart unless I'm fairly certain I'll like and keep the item. $2 to restock the item is a lot and will add up when I order 7-10 items per order and return more than half of them. I liked feeling confident I wouldn't lose my money and ordered whatever I wanted. Now I have to be careful of what I add to my cart. Once I use up my credit I will not be returning.

I ORDERED WHAT APPEARED TO BE A BEAUTIFUL DRESS ON THE WEBSITE. IT ARRIVED LIKE IT WAS USED AND ABUSED. THE DRESS CAME WITH AN ACCESSORY THAT WAS FALLING OFF. IT WAS NOTHING LIKE THE PICTURE ON THE WEBSITE. I WANTED TO SPEAK WITH A A CUSTOMER SERVICE REPRESENTATIVE TO SEE IF I COULD RETURN THE ITEM AS IT ARRIVED WHILE I WAS ON MY VACATION OVERSEAS. THERE WAS NO NUMBER TO CALL. THIS IS UPSETTING. I WILL NEVER BUY ANYTHING FROM THREDUP AGAIN. YOU BET I WILL LET ALL MY COWORKERS, FRIENDS AND FAMILY ABOUT THIS!

Im probably the only one who washes their clothes before they donate them.

I received one Cabi shirt Im great condition and one coat from White House/Black market als in great shape. Both of these items were shipped from the San Leandro, CA location.

My 2nd half of the order shipped from Mechanicsburg, PA. They were older Inc. brand shirts that appeared to be in okay shape. The one, however, reeked of either being kept in the basement or in somebodies multi home. It also had a slight hint of smoke, as in cigarette smoke to it. I washed both of the shirts and the stench still did not come out of this one shirt. Right now I have it outside in the sun hoping the fresh air will help. It may take many washings before the stench is out. Horrible. I dont think Ill ever buy from this company ever again. With their return policy, they make it too complicated.

Beware: My first order with thredUP was great - great price, quality item, true to size. 2nd order a women's size 10 blouse was a girls size 10,3rd order women's dress size 12, was size 12 girls or juniors, clearly stated on label - did not return items, don't have time for that, that is why I shop online. Disappointing!

Today I tried to order a paid of pants that I was really excited about and every time I tried to process the payment I got an error message saying that something was wrong with my payment information. I just moved so I thought maybe my new address was not updated in the system. So I tried changing my information and still got the same error message. I just got a fraud notice from my bank and learned that they changed me 6 times! To be clear not once did the payment say it went through and I got a error message every time I tried to process the payment and they are still in my basket! The cost of the pants and shipping was 22.61 but now a total of 135.05 was taken out of my bank account. I looked for a customer service number and there is not one so I emailed in and then called my bank. My bank went through everything with me and told me that there is not reason why my payment would not process and see's that unless they stop the payment they would go through. And asked me to contact the vendor as there is an issue with their system. While I was waiting to hear back form Thredup a message popped up on their web page asking if I need help. I told her what happened and she said, "your payment did not go through and I cannot tell you why. They should fall off your statement eventually." I explained to here what my bank had said and let her know that taking an additional $135.00 out of my bank account was a big deal to me. She just kept posting the same thing over and over to whatever I said or asked, ""your payment did not go through and I cannot tell you why. They should fall off your statement eventually." It got to the point to where I asked her if she was a robot or reading from a script. Not once did she show empathy, tell me she was sorry, or acknowledge that there might be an issue with their system. She was so rude. An hour and half later I still have not gotten a reply back from my email. Their customer service is the worst that I have ever experienced. I have worked in some form of customer service my entire life and know how challenging it can be, but no matter what I would never treat someone the way this company treated me.

***Update******

Since this site will not let me respond to thredup's response I will post here. As of 7/31 I still have not received a response to my email I sent into support. I have not received any kind of message initiated from thredup. So what they are saying is false and that is very disappointing. I also still have pending transactions in my bank account resulting in missing money.