thredUPReviews 6,178

First of all, I sent in a giant bag of nice clothes and thredUp did accept some items for sale, HOWEVER, what you receive in return for the items they do accept is chump change. They did put lots of my items on consignment though and some things have sold, so I'm happy about that. My real rub is that many of my pieces they did not take, even to put on consignment- 24 to be exact- and most of these pieces were in good or excellent condition. I sent in a size small designer suede jacket (that would retail new for $400+) with no stains, rips, holes or tears that wasn't even considered for consignment! I also sent in a designer top that I purchased new and had never worn. It was also not accepted as they told me had stains in the armpits. Don't you just love it when someone tells you something you know isn't true!? :(( ( I sent in a pair of Steve Madden size 6.5 nude/gold colored peep toe shoes that I had worn 2 times- same story... not in good condition- the leather was cracking- BS. Yet, they purchased and consigned many items that I was very surprised about. I am wondering if the employees just take what they want since there is no system in place to record what you're sending in on the customer end. Don't waste your time. I don't trust this company. They are CROOKS and SCAMMERS. I just cashed out what they have sold and HOPE that they actually mail me the money I'm due.

Thumbs way down for thredUp.

I was disappointed to find that I had the wrong item in my order. I had ordered a J. Jill skirt, but received Hunt Club. (The other two items were packed correctly.) I contacted customer service via the chat service. I was told that the issue had to be addressed offline; I would hear from customer service shortly. I was doubtful, but ThredUp came through - my payment had already been returned and the fee to ship the wrong item back to CA was credited. It cost me nothing!

Like most that have used their service, the first bag is "decent" on your resale items. Trust when I say, it is short lived. I had sent 2 bags within days of each other. The first was a tolerable return assessment. The ease of selling with free shipping made it very appealing. The second bag included major designer brand items including a very lightly used yves saint laurent bag. I had chosen the option to donate what they didn't sell given my bag had included shoes. Heels that were barely used (a pair of manolo blahnik's worn once) but shoes, none the less. I chose the option because shoes can always be a fickle resale item. ThredUp gave me nothing and "donated" a purse worth over 1k (new) that would have sold for at least $600 and the manolo's should have been offered for any amount. They were literally worn once. Instead, I was emailed that nothing in the second bag was worth selling and they had donated my items. They are crooks! Shady! Beware!

I sent a bunch of gently used clothes in to ThredUp as a seller. After 6 weeks of hearing nothing, I chased them twice and a few days later I received just 0.30c for the entire bag and worst of it was, I sent two brand name tops which were exactly the same and had been worn only few times so were in near perfect condition. They were different colors but other than that, exactly the same top and same condition. I received the 0.30c for one and nothing for the other. Total rip off. They might as well state they are a charity rather than a re-sale site because I essentially gave away half of my brand name wardrobe for nothing. You have to pay $12 for the 'privilege' to get a bag to send in your seller items. Their prices are not competitive as a buyer either. Avoid like the plague unless you just want to get rid of your clothes for nothing to make space. I'd have sooner given them to a homeless person than to be ripped off in this way. Their money grabbing, unfair practices are nothing like they claim. Plus I've taken a look on their site and seen clothes on there that I am certain were from me that I didn't get credit for and there are much worse clothes on there in terms of quality than what I sent in. Terrible terrible practice.

People, this is a for-profit company. I've seen people post things like, "Thanks for the initiative to help other," and "I continue to be impressed with your company's mission and work." Again, this is a FOR-PROFIT company. There is no "higher" initiative or mission other than to put money into their own pockets. I believe these 5-star reviews are either paid writers or written on behalf of their employees. In truth, yes, they do sell designer items (used) at prices that are competitive with Ebay, Mercari, and others, BUT they are making HUGE profits from those items sent in by their customers. You would be better off finding a consignment store in your area, selling on Ebay, or donating to a charity (help your local community) other than Goodwill (another rant for another time).

My experience:
Once my bag was processed (nearly two months), I was shocked and disappointed to see how little my payout was. I sent them 25 items (quality and in mint condition) and 10 were accepted. Nine of the items received an upfront payment of 5% - pennies. I was not offered an option for consignment nor a trade-in value. If you want to receive your payout payment versus using as store credit, you may have it sent via a visa gift card or Paypal, but not before paying the fees for those. After shipping and fees, I am left $3.01. Sickening.

I was initially impressed with ThredUp - no charge for the bag, quick processing and fair $ amount offered for what I sent. Now it is the complete opposite. The last bag I sent in contained about 8 items - including shoes, coats and brand new items with tags. I was paid just over $12 for all of it - subtract the processing fee I essentially made nothing. Kicker is that ThredUp charged close to $100 for all of it - nice profit for them - totally not worth it for me. I'm waiting for my final bag to be processed (which now takes around a month...) and will be cashing out my account and saying goodbye.

Do NOT UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES sell on this site

You will receive several dollars --if you are lucky- after they deduct their shipping fee. And can guarantee you----that is all It is about making THEM VERY wealthy ---- not to get anything into your pocket. This site is about THE OWNERS --- a group of guys who figured out a way to make a quick buck on a public who is out here trying to make a few dollars to help with the flat and declining income of most Americans. Don't do it. Do not make them wealthier than they are. They don't need your clothing. They will list a few pieces out of a full bag. And the rest ---- especially the better brands --- will disappear You will see between 2 and7 dollars and the remaining question will be---- where did the rest go. Believe me, we're all asking that question in chat rooms about the site. More than a few have filed formal complaints with the BBB in California---their district. And investigation is quietly underway. We suspect selling of the better items elsewhere. In other words, two women have now found rejected items of theirs on another site, bought them and not so amazing --- it was their items. Two j crew dresses So my advice.? Spread the word ------THIS IS A SCAM. STAY AWAY. There are other sites. Lots of them. And they're legitimate. Your items are listed and an explanation sent to u with reason if rejected Stay away from these guys. They're using their consignors and laughing all the way to the bank. I mean this very sincerely
DO NOT. UNDER ANY CIRCUMSTANCES USE THIS SELLING SITE. DO NOT LET THEM TAKE
ADVANTAGE OF YOUR DEsPERATION TO GET A FEW DOLLARS INTO YOUR HOUSEHOLD. THEY DO NOT CARE iN THE SLiGHTEST ABOUT YOUR LEGITIMATELY GENUINE FINANCIAL ISSUES tHIS IS A CON. AVOID THIS SITE LIKE iTS THE PLAGUE. IM WARNING YOU SO THAT YOU DONT GET BURNED LIKE SO MANY OF US HAVE. PLEASE. STAY AWAY. PLEASE. PLEASE. THESE ARE NOT VERY ADMIRABLE PEOPLE. NOT THE KIND of PEOPLE AnYONE WHO I S DOING THIS FOR THEIR FAMIlY SHOULD HAVE TO HAVE cONTACT WITH IN THEIR LIFE. YOU DESERVE BETTER. DONT GIVE THEM THE TIME OF DAY -----OR YOUR ENERGY EVER yOU DESERVE BETTER.

PLEASE. PLEASE. STAY. AWAY

I have ordered from Thredup several times and have been very happy with my purchases. The selection seems infinite, and I appreciate being able to see only items in my size. Everything arrives promptly and is as described. I feel like I have gotten some great bargains and have filled my closet with a bunch of new options for very little. I also love the convenience of being able to find a lot of different brands and stores all on one site. I think you have the best results when you pay attention to the sizing of specific brands (i. E., either buy brands you know what size you wear in, or track down brand-specific size charts). The measurements listed on the website are a little hit or miss. Returns are easy as they can be sent back in the same box within fourteen days and processed quickly. Returns are free if you opt for store credit, which I always do because I know I will use it.

If you are looking to make money, I do not necessarily recommend this site. Sellers can expect to make very little even on very nice items (dollars or even cents), but they are upfront about that, which I respect. Use the payout calculator and believe what it is telling you. Given the fee deducted to cover shipping and processing, you would probably be better off consigning locally or having a yard sale if your goal is to sell your clothes for money. However, when I sent in my bag, I considered it "paying it forward." The only reason I have been able to find so many bargains on nice things is that other people have sent in their clothes. If everyone stopped sending in cleanout bags, the site would not be what it is, and since I can't make it to a million yard sales all over the country, I appreciate that this exists. Considering how much I have gotten out of it as a buyer, I can live with the flipside disappointment of selling.

I'm not sure I've ever written a review about my experience with a company but I feel the need to warn you about this site. I sent in many high-quality items and after being charged $7 for the bag and $10 for "return assurance," I made $2. You will make much more money at your local consignment shop and you will find much better prices for items. I wish I looked at Thred Up reviews before I sent in my own clothing - I never would have sent my items here.