I had good experiences selling them bags a few times, but most recently, I got only $2 for a bag of spring/summer items. It took them forever to process my bag(I sent in March; they did not process the bag until May, but kept me updated via email) so I imagine they were swamped with merchandise and my stuff didn't make the cut. There are a lot of variables as to why they might select or reject clothing: the amount of inventory they have of particular items, the season they are stocking, the brands they're accepting (which change frequently). I won't go as far as to say they're running a scam, but I understand why sellers are dissatisfied. It beats ebay, and if you're willing to pay return postage (I think that's $12-13) they will send your stuff back.