website thubmnail of Plenty of Fish
How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
New Jersey
9 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Chad W.
Unfollow Chad W.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Good
January 18, 2021

I found here a lot of interesting people to communicate with. With some of them I still meet and spend great time!
If you want to find friend, come to POF

Date of experience: November 25, 2016
New York
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Harold R.
Unfollow Harold R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Biggest piece of crap
April 29, 2019

All fakes or prostitutes full of people trying to scam you if you complain they will ban you for life they tell you your lying even though you show them proof

Date of experience: April 29, 2019
Michigan
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Michelle D.
Unfollow Michelle D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

A bunch of fake profiles who you can't trust. The real profiles end up paying for it with distrust of all. Shame on POF... And the low life's who abuse it.

Date of experience: April 8, 2018
California
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Shay b.
Unfollow Shay b.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I did not sign up under this site, but I'm getting notifications. I can't even see my own profile (I can't reset password). So, obviously this site is full of frauds.

Date of experience: September 30, 2016
India
4 reviews
45 helpful votes
Follow Eddard S.
Unfollow Eddard S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

A+
January 12, 2017

I have been using it for a few weeks and I think it is an A+ dating site. MANY members but many weirdos. I personally prefer Mingle2day or Match but this one works too.

Date of experience: January 12, 2017
New York
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Bunny B.
Unfollow Bunny B.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

So terrible. Scam.
July 4, 2015

It's not free. To read your emails from other potential people you have to pay. 40 dollars for two months. Robotic messages, emails from so called other people looking to hook up. The company don't respond to your emails nor do they return phone calls. & you will notice the numbers online are false. My bank had a number and I tried to call. All nonsense. It's horrible. Scary. I want them and every other scum bag out there to stay away from me and my family. Me and my son. It was a total scam for me. I do notice they have complaints online. I should have checked first. It's harassment from other alleged people. They canceled my picture after I paid. They won't let you cancel your account out until you pick one of their bull choices for leaving. The real reason not even listed. After you contact them to cancel because you find out it's nonsense they tell you no refunds online they send you an automatic response. Our country sucks. They don't help people. I had to cancel my bank card before the payment went thru to make sure I received my money back. This site is bull too. You shouldn't have to register... and it doesn't tell you until after you type this out.

Date of experience: July 4, 2015
Alabama
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Bernadette H.
Unfollow Bernadette H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

After awhile you can't get into your own profile & theres no one or no way of getting it removed. I have 2 profiles & cant get into either of them. It has to be a better way to find love.

Date of experience: October 1, 2016
Missouri
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Spuds M.
Unfollow Spuds M.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

They recently made changes. I don't much care for them. It used to be you could see users who viewed you. Now they show you 3. If you want to see more - upgrade. I've been on and off this site for a long time and it seems like most of the women "only accepts messages from upgraded users". Well... they'll miss out on me. I'm not willing to pay to message someone unless there is some mechanism that would force themn to reply to the user who upgraded so they could say hello. It would suck to pay money to be ignored. The search seems to ignore the criteria - I specified 57 to 65 and I am seeing women in their 40's and 70's. What I think they really need to do, and the software should be able to do it - if a person only wants messages from someone under a certain age, and you are over that age - don't show their profile as a match or in a search. If they only accept messages from upgraded users and you aren't upgraded - don't put them in the search or match results. Oh yes... the scammers are as busy as ever. "Age is just a number" or "love doesn't care about age" and it's a woman who says she is 64 but in reality is 35 because "I made a mistake on my birthdate and can't change it". It used to be an okay site, but not anymore.

Date of experience: September 25, 2020
Arizona
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Leslie K.
Unfollow Leslie K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Complete lack of profile validation. Limits on age range searches.

Pretty much the only good-looking people on the site are fake profiles that are trying to sext with you. There are a few decent-looking guys, if you can ever get through the hordes of fake profiles. By the time you are talking to a real man, you are completely cynical.

Also, you are pigeonholed by age group. So if you are a middle-aged woman (pretty much one of the target demographics), you can only search seven years below your age, but men twenty years older than you can view and like your profile. Meaning, lots of gross old dudes can look at you but you have a very limited inventory of decent men to look at... and most of the good-looking ones are fake profiles wanting to sext with you.

The POF messaging is this: If you are a very attractive, athletic, successful, intelligent middle-aged woman, you are out to pasture with men that can't get out of their Lazy Boy recliners.

Apparently, grown men and women need this company to dictate who they are allowed to be attracted to. Bumble is a million times better for women.

Date of experience: November 11, 2022
Alabama
1 review
10 helpful votes
Follow Julie S.
Unfollow Julie S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

So Irishlucky83 which is Craig Stevens in real life lies about his profile. He does not tell women that he has some severe mental illnesses that can make him very obsessive. He comes off saying he has a construction job when he has no job at all and lives off of SSDI. He also does not tell you that he has no manners, drinks non-stop and is very childish. My experience with this individual was he had some major issues, often drinking, smoking pot and cigarettes while taking mental meds, anti psychotic drugs, his behavior was very child like and he has no friends because he starts fights with all of them. I stayed for awhile because i thought i could help this person because he does come off likeable but once i saw how he watched me from his porch, got mad at me for having friends and thought i should spend every waking minute with him it all begin to be a little much so i let him go. Beware of this person he has bad issues with women due to he and his mothers relationship issues and he cannot let go of the past that is all he talks about all the time. He will come off nice then drain the hell out of you. I wish him well in life but i am serious beware. Pof is exactly where he found me and everything on that site is a lie.

Date of experience: June 4, 2015
Texas
1 review
11 helpful votes
Follow Barbara H.
Unfollow Barbara H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Not free at all
May 15, 2017

Pof advertise free dating site but if you don't upgrade to pay for it then you are blocked from logging in. Pof forces a person to upgrade or you can't use the site.

Date of experience: May 15, 2017
California
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow treacy e.
Unfollow treacy e.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I am so frustrated with Plenty of Fish. I cannot delete my account. It rejects my sign in then allows me to request password, then rejects my email address.
HELP!

Date of experience: May 4, 2011
Australia
2 reviews
21 helpful votes
Follow Matt L.
Unfollow Matt L.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I was on pof for two weeks.
I seen many fake profile with fake locations.
I was nice, I thought it was not to bad considering it's free but then my account was deleted with absolute no explanation.

Date of experience: June 30, 2014
Canada
3 reviews
8 helpful votes
Follow Shaz A.
Unfollow Shaz A.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I like POF as I have met some nice guys there. I like that they have socials in various places that one can attend and you don't have to be a paid member to go.

Date of experience: March 6, 2015
Canada
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Ronald S.
Unfollow Ronald S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Married
October 7, 2023

I just wanted to let everyone know that this site works great if you give it a chance I met my wife on POF 9 and a half years ago we got married after 3 and a half years after we met and were married for 6 years sadly she passed away July 19th of this year but because of this site i met my soulmate and there was a happy ending for both of us im crushed now but I would not be where i am today if it was not for POF

Date of experience: September 21, 2023
GB
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Malc s.
Unfollow Malc s.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

If you are expecting to find the woman of your dreams you will have a long wait

Just rammed full of single mums, women who are way past their best yet still want a guy who is way out their league. I just laughed when I saw women in their 40s say they only want someone is is 6'3 tall dark handsome and are willing to wait as they know their worth. Entitlement is off the charts

Even on the headline they are incredibly negative with things like are all men cheats? Either that or they are complaining they cant see likes and dont have meet me, they could pay to see but wont or they could easily find out who clicked like but either cant be bothered or are too dumb. I got so tired of reading cant see likes message me that I gave up

Most profiles are blank and say? Or fill in later, the rest are full of childish demands or toxic negativity just whining about how bad everything is and how all men are really terrible. It hasnt crossed their minds to try and be happy and cheerful in the profile

Date of experience: May 8, 2022
Wisconsin
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Laura S.
Unfollow Laura S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Scammed
April 23, 2021

Stay away from this website there are a lot of guys out there that wants money from you, especially the ladies that are looking for true love. These guys prey on the lonely, I know because it happened to me. The man I met on here took me for everything I had and left me in utter debt. If you see the name Joseph Durmus BEWARE! He will take you for everything you have. I DO NOT RECOMMEND THIS SITE FOR ANYONE LOOKING FOR TRUE LOVE.

Date of experience: April 23, 2021
Canada
3 reviews
22 helpful votes
Follow Shane P.
Unfollow Shane P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

It works
December 7, 2019

POF is a decent site though there are a lot of fakes that is almost unavoidable when it comes to dating sites. It still provides a decent service when trying to meet local women.

Date of experience: December 6, 2019
California
2 reviews
12 helpful votes
Follow Blueeyed G.
Unfollow Blueeyed G.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I'm a male. Being on here had taught me what to look out for when it comes to profile pics. If the camera angle is looking down on the face- they are fat whales. If they aren't smiling they are boring in life. If they have "just ask me" then they are bland.
You are going to find bad fish and good fish every where you go. Worse are found in a bar. At least here on PoF I have fun rambling on and making new connections. The trick to not having to pay is linking your email to send you notices when someone likes you. Then do a username search to see who it is. Otherwise, you have to pay to see who likes you or wants to meet you.
Tips. Use more than 1 pic. Be funny. Have different pics to show your personality. Treat it like a job resume. If you don't catch their attention in the first 30 seconds you are going to be on sitejabber complaining that pof is a scam. It's up to you to make it work.
I have used it for relationships in the Los Angeles area for over two years now. I have a fear of commitment... so the two years is my fault. Not PoFs.

Date of experience: May 9, 2015
Pennsylvania
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Alexander S.
Unfollow Alexander S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I talked to 15 different women all were fake all red but exact same script to me word for word and they also only asked me to send them money in the form of cryptocurrency

Date of experience: May 5, 2022

Overview

Plenty of Fish has a rating of 1.3 stars from 1,957 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with Plenty of Fish most frequently mention fake profiles, customer service and credit card. Plenty of Fish ranks 655th among Dating sites.

service
394
value
393
shipping
87
returns
98
quality
407