We’re in this together! Stay safe with our COVID-19 guide

View
×
Developed in part with a grant from
the National Science Foundation

Top Engagement Ring Stores Online

Engagement Ring Stores Online: 135 businesses
Filter by:
Star rating
Service rating
Value rating
Shipping rating
Returns rating
Quality rating
Price
Clear All
Star rating
Service rating
Value rating
Shipping rating
Returns rating
Quality rating
Price

SuperJeweler

See All Reviews
14,845 reviews
superjeweler.com
Great Prices ...Good Looking Diamonds...I hate Retail Stores...the Mark Up is so darn High 200%..they say the Mark... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
6
Value
8
Shipping
8
Returns
0
Quality
7

SuperJeweler

Diamondere

See All Reviews
708 reviews
diamondere.com
I have been searching high and low for a band that will go with my unique garnet engagement ring. I saw the picture,... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
1
Returns
0
Quality
1

Diamondere

James Free Jewelers

See All Reviews
309 reviews
jamesfree.com
Bought some jewelry off their website and ended up having to return it. Was extremely smooth and the team at James... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
1

James Free Jewelers

Brilliance

See All Reviews
369 reviews
brilliance.com
I needed help in deciding the perfect gift for my girlfriend (because she has an extremely unique taste). When... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
38
Value
37
Shipping
39
Returns
15
Quality
38

Brilliance

Shane Co.

See All Reviews
203 reviews
shaneco.com
Ordered my wife a Morganite ring and it came out perfectly. It was brilliant clout of the box and the price was very... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
1

Shane Co.

Allurez

See All Reviews
447 reviews
allurez.com
Exceptional shopping experience with outstanding support and guidance from RACHEL (chat). My wife will be very... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
5
Value
5
Shipping
5
Returns
5
Quality
5

Allurez

Zales

See All Reviews
164 reviews
zales.com
Nice collection of rings, watches and other jewellery! Customer support could be better, otherwise a nice website and... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
1
Returns
2
Quality
2

Zales

Jeulia

See All Reviews
5,894 reviews
jeulia.com
Excellent product that I really enjoyed. Looks and feels like a real diamond and have received tons of compliments.... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
160
Value
153
Shipping
162
Returns
83
Quality
153

Jeulia

Costco

See All Reviews
1,201 reviews
costco.com
Susan in the Avon, Ohio Optical Department, could not have been better at her job. She was thorough, attentive, and... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
33
Value
27
Shipping
21
Returns
21
Quality
27

Costco

Blue Nile

See All Reviews
65 reviews
bluenile.com
I have purchased several items from Blue Nile, my favorite being a pair of peridot and diamond drop earrings set in... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
1
Shipping
1
Returns
1
Quality
1

Blue Nile

Tiffany & Co

See All Reviews
57 reviews
tiffany.com
Very beautiful jewelry in the shop. Quick delivery and pretty packaging. Someday will buy everything from this shop. read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
3
Value
3
Shipping
2
Returns
1
Quality
3

Tiffany & Co

PrimeStyle

See All Reviews
356 reviews
primestyle.com
My fiancé was reluctant to make such a big important purchase online as we were nervous about scams etc. He got in... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
5
Value
6
Shipping
6
Returns
4
Quality
6

PrimeStyle

James Allen

See All Reviews
23 reviews
jamesallen.com
I felt comfortable ordering my girlfriend's engagement ring on from here due to the awesome return policy. Free... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

James Allen

GemsNY

See All Reviews
85 reviews
gemsny.com
I've made two purchases now. GemsNY provides a wide selection of top quality gemstones at a very fair price. The... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
4
Value
4
Shipping
4
Returns
2
Quality
4

GemsNY

Charles & Colvard

See All Reviews
185 reviews
charlesandcolvard.com
Amazing product, super happy. Looks amazing. Don't waste and spend your money on a diamond when you don't need to.... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
13
Value
13
Shipping
13
Returns
6
Quality
13

Charles & Colvard

DiamondNexus

See All Reviews
32 reviews
diamondnexus.com
Never bought here anything (pricey) but i just love coming and looking some rings.. best therapy ever! read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

DiamondNexus

ForeverMetals

See All Reviews
39 reviews
forevermetals.com
I ordered rings from here for my kids and let's just say I'll be in good graces for a long time with my family.... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

ForeverMetals

Italo Jewelry

See All Reviews
378 reviews
italojewelry.com
The product is as beautiful as described; Stones sparkle like real diamonds, true to size, packaged in a very nice... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
17
Value
16
Shipping
18
Returns
12
Quality
17

Italo Jewelry

Brilliant Earth

See All Reviews
41 reviews
brilliantearth.com
I was trying to find a very specific look of bracelet for my wedding day. It's tough to find exactly what you're... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
3
Value
3
Shipping
3
Returns
3
Quality
3

Brilliant Earth

FascinatingDiamonds

See All Reviews
16 reviews
fascinatingdiamonds.com
Delivery is on time and stunning ring The ring is undeniably beautiful and innovative but the best surprise was,... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
1
Returns
1
Quality
1

FascinatingDiamonds

JewelryPoint

See All Reviews
16 reviews
jewelrypoint.com
they have good quality and good prices i totally recommend jeulia.com to others. Because me and my wife bought 3... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

JewelryPoint

Lajerrio

See All Reviews
72 reviews
lajerrio.com
This ring is more beautiful than words can describe. It is so unique. The craftsmanship, alone, is amazing. Moreover,... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
1
Returns
1
Quality
1

Lajerrio

Clean Origin

See All Reviews
15 reviews
cleanorigin.com
Those of you who are skeptical of purchasing engagement rings online, let me help ease your mind. I was also in the... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
3
Value
3
Shipping
3
Returns
2
Quality
3

Clean Origin

iCelticRings

See All Reviews
14 reviews
icelticrings.com
Well done. Celtic Rings store shipped my claddagh ring order on time. It's only need 4 days work. The ring itself was... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

iCelticRings

I Hate Steven Singer

See All Reviews
10 reviews
ihatestevensinger.com
Great prices, good product and shipping is quick if in stock. Definitely enjoy the unique items. Main things I like... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

I Hate Steven Singer

Select up to five businesses to compare

(1/5)