Developed in part with a grant from
the National Science Foundation
Review of MyJewelryBox

MyJewelryBox reviews

Is this your business?
49 reviews
Categories: Diamond, Earrings, Jewelry
12 Nepco Way
Plattsburgh, NY 12903
Tel: (866) 443-8652
This business is not yet responding to reviews. If this is your business claim it and respond free.

49 Reviews From Our Community

Rating Distribution

Detailed Rating Summary


All Reviews

1 review
2 helpful votes

If you read this, it's apparent your business is closed and no longer there. For those interested, I google mapped this business when I ordered my 3Carat ring, which I really like and received, but thought I would order another piece to go with it.

I have a feeling this is not a store, but a warehouse? or some place in a remote area. Their website is not available, so I would consider this business out of business. Fortunately, my jewelry is ok, and doing fine and I have a private jeweler that can fix on it when it needs anything.

Im going back to the conventional stores where they stand behind their stuff. Went to ZXXXX and bought a 3 K ring, the whole head came off, they just gave me a new one right questions asked, since I had the receipt.

I liked jewelry box because the prices were affordable...but it's ok. business's come and go.

1 review
4 helpful votes

If I could give this company no stars, I would. My boyfriend bought me a $250 ring from this site for me. Not three months later, all the stones fell out. I contacted customer service over 7 times asking about a refund/exchange. They asked me for the order number. I gave it to them right away and never heard back. I tried contacting them over and over and never heard back. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY. Jewelry is poor and they do not stand behind any of their guarantees.

5 reviews
4 helpful votes

Bought a ring last month. It's pretty but has a defect; one of the prong holding a diamond in place is bend. The diamond is loose. For some reason, I cannot reach the company to resolve this issue. Their phone number is not in service, emails are not answered and web site "under construction". This company has questionable work ethics and I seriously doubt their legitimacy. Just lost 500$ to have a ring sit in "my jewelry box". Very disappointed.

1 review
2 helpful votes

100% satisfied with my purchase. The ring is beautiful... I know my daughter will love it. Customer service was great. They assured me on a date of delivery and came through. Thank you.

1 review
2 helpful votes

I ordered a 3 carat diamond engagement ring $2500. I sent emails, called ( customer service is always closed so you have to leave a voicemail) and no one ever returned my call or emails. Simply, I just needed to update my shipping address from a PO box to physical address for their shipping rules. Next thing, I get an notice that my order was cancelled and apparently my cc has been issued refund. No reason for cancellation. No contact whatsoever. This is absolutely the most awful terrible customer service in the world! For those of you that had a good experience, good for you. To all others, Do NOT BUY from this racket. To state this is poor customer experience is an understatement. Thank you myjewlerybox for ruining our engagement. You guys need to get some business ethics and a real customer service department.

1 review
2 helpful votes

My son ordered a necklace on Dec. 8, 2014 for $42.XX, latter found out the company charged his account 3 times. I have made 4 calls on his behalf (hes 16 years old) to get his money returned and yet again they tell me we just put it back it his account this morning. I called 10 days ago, THEY SAID IT WULD TAKE UP TO 3 DAYS TO POST, WE WILL NEVER DO BUSINESS WITH THEM AGAIN. POOR COMUNICATIONS, NEVER OFFERED ANYTHING TO REGAIN THERE GOOD STANDING

1 review
2 helpful votes

I've written Customer Service response and its been several days. I ordered and received Diamond Solitaire earrings for my wife's birthday. I tossed the empty box with the receipt when I was wrapping Christmas presents. The diamonds are terrible and were appraised at less than one half of what Jewelry Box said they were valued. Jewelry Box said they were valued at over $800...local Jewelers say $400 or less. I have my AMEX receipt and may try some pressure from them. Never will I ever order diamonds again on-line. JHN

1 review
3 helpful votes

"The website says '' Canadian order: 6 to 10 days '' and they also said '' Order before December 18th and receive your item for Christmas ''.

I ordered on December 11th, my order only got approved on December 17th ( 6 days ?! seriously ? ) and on December 22th it's still haven't been shipped, this is f*cking ridiculous, I even spoke to someone from their customer service on December 17th and he was telling me everything would be fine, it was normal, etc. I'm never buying there again, my worst online buying experience ever, now I have to find something else for my Christmas gift."

2 reviews
3 helpful votes

Great selection of men's jewelry. I ordered a necklace for my hubby and it came on time and in great condition.

Prices are bit higher than most sites, but overall I was very happy with my shopping experience.

1 review
1 helpful vote

Bought a three stone diamond ring last year. Took quite a while to get the purchase approved, resize the ring, and ship. Ring quality appeared to me to be OK for everyday wear. I was wrong - fast forward one year - one of the stones came loose and fell out, never to be seen again. Two jewelers told me the same thing - the stones were mounted poorly, and one fell out because a prong broke. The ring needs major repairs to strengthen the setting, not to mention replace the lost diamond. Nice job guys. No more internet jewelry for me - and especially from this site.

1 review
0 helpful votes

This is the easiest site I have ever used. Very easy to navigate and I was able to locate a ruby ring for my girlfriend in like 10 minutes and checkout.
I also like, that they provide a lot of informtation on each product. Its my second orders from them, the last one arrived quickly, and I am assuming this one will as well.

1 review
2 helpful votes

I bought a 3ct diamond bracelet and had it checked in Europe, the total is 2,1ct and the diamonds have a lot of inclusions(poor quality)

1 review
6 helpful votes

i purchased a 1.5 ctw princess cut wedding set for my fiancee on march 13th of this year. it was listed as in stock and to be delivered within 5 days. 1800$ was charged to my credit card that day. after about a week i became concerned and called the 1 800 number. i spoke with a female customer rep that informed me that the ring was back ordered and it would take 2 weeks from the time i ordered it to be delivered. after 3 weeks i called again. i spoke to "lee" and was told that he would look into it and call me right back. he never did. 4 days later i spoke with lee again. this time he informs me the manufacturer will ship it out at the end of the week and then they will over-nite it out. this will be over a month to deliver a ring that was listed as in stock. needless to say its the last time ill ever patronize this company

3 reviews
3 helpful votes

Ordered a wedding set (engagement and wedding ring) over the phone. Lee (customer service) helped explain the whole process and reassured me about ordering something online as I'm not much of an online shopper but I couldn't resist the great deals had to offer. All in all, I'm very happy with my purchase and would not hesitate to order something from them again. A happy wife is a happy life.

1 review
5 helpful votes

I ordered a ring for Valentine's Day. Order was placed on 2/7 and website says order by 2/10 for guaranteed delivery with standard shipping. On 2/12 I finally get an email that says the order was packed on 2/8 and shipped on 2/12. I called to find out what the problem was and they told me that they upgraded the shipping so I'll have it, but that I should be calling to THANK THEM!!!! I asked for a supervisor and was told he was the supervisor. He then threatened to cancel my order and recall the package. I called back and spoke to a woman who said she also was a supervisor, she was not quite as rude as the guy, but the is NO WAY i will EVER give this company any more business!

1 review
3 helpful votes

I have ordered two items from this site. Both items arrived in a timely manner, and the product was as expected (or exceeded expectations).
I will purchase from them again.

1 review
7 helpful votes

I bought a ring for my wife, came on time not a problem, no problem with customer service. Ring is way smaller than what's shown on the site. I was like WOW that's small.

Please be mindful that when they have sale/discounts, they actually raised the price 40 plus % and then give the discount from that. So basically you are paying a little more or regular their discount is a scam. You are NOT getting anything on sale. I know because the ring I bought for my wife and others went way way up then discount applies. After the sale is over, then they drop the price back to everyday price.

1 review
2 helpful votes

I ordered a necklace for my wife for Christmas, on Dec. 2, I would be happy to just get a tracking number. I have called last week and talk to customer service every day, and everyday they said tomorrow. Here it is Dec. 24, and NO tracking number yet. You guys really suck, you guys send me e-mail ads for my jewelry box, but cant send me a email heads up? With the Power of Facebook, people will know. Thanks Jewlery Box for nothing!

1 review
3 helpful votes

Do not buy anything from!!!! I have never experienced such rude and unprofessional customer service anywhere else. I placed a 1400.00 order on Nov. 30. I received an email from them on Dec. 2 confirming my order and saying it would be shipped. It never arrived. I called them on Dec. 18 to ask why I had not received it. I was told the warehouse was closed at that time and the customer service woman said she would call me by 10:00 the next morning. She never called. I called that afternoon and was told by a guy that he had no tracking number for it and could not guarantee shipment without a tracking number. He said he would look into it and call me back by 4:00 PM. He didn't call either. I called at 4:00 and a female told me that she had no tracking number but it was guaranteed to arrive on Monday. I tried to tell her that two other people told me the opposite and she kept interrupting and talking over me. It took 12 minutes to make her understand that two others told me the opposite but then she said she didn't care she was guaranteeing it. I asked to speak to a supervisor and she got extremely angry and rude and carrying on for two more minutes before putting me on hold for a supervisor. I told the supervisor the story and she said it was not guaranteed without a tracking number. I told her about the rude employee and the broken promises to return my calls and the initial failure to ship. She said "it's Christmas and we're busy. I'm going to cancel your order and wash my hands of you" and she hung up. My credit card was not credited back the 1400.00. This was my sixth and, of course, last order from these rude and unprofessional people. Beware, if place an order with them and have a problem with customer service you can expect not help and it appears they will defraud you of your money.

1 review
3 helpful votes

I ordered an item 8 days ago and have yet to receive it! My credit card has been charged but I received no confirmation email or notice of shipment even though I had 2-day shipping. My attempts to contact the company and get help with my problem has fallen on deaf ears. I have had no response (not even a form letter) after 3 email attempts! Prices maybe good but you may never receive what you ordered!

1 review
2 helpful votes

The web site is well made and the prices are lower than the local jewelers.
However, I ordered a ring, and the actual product did not look as shiny and dazzling as the picture and video on the web site. The size was almost a full size larger than what I had ordered. I emailed them and their response was that they confirmed with their manufacturer that they had sent the size I had ordered, and they mentioned that sizes may vary per manufacturer. Sizes do not vary to the extent of being almost a full size to large! It was clearly a mistake. They offered to re-size it for free, however I would have had to ship it back via insured shipment at my expense, which is expensive, almost as expensive as having the ring re-sized at a local jeweler, and there was still no guarantee that it would have been sized properly, so I could have had to re-send it again...
CONCLUSION: The prices may be lower, but please add $60 to $125 dollars to their prices in case you need to have the product re-sized. When you buy at a local jeweler, not only can you see the actual product in real life (not some embellished picture and video), but the jeweler will size it until it fits perfectly at no extra cost and no shipping fees.

1 review
6 helpful votes

I ordered a ring and ended up not liking it as much as I thought...My fault. I returned it with no problems. Customer service was amazing. I've reordered since and am waiting for that ring to come. Happy with the prices, site and their customer service.

5 reviews
16 helpful votes

Just use this site one time , products are nice, but their customer service are terrible. Make sure you will not contact the customer service when you use this site.

1 review
6 helpful votes

My husband purchased the wedding ring sets from this company. When I opened the box up,I realized that 3 side stones are missing on the both rings. It's utterly impossible, but it happened.
Immediately my husband visited their customer service page,got return number and returned the sets to fix.
We even have no idea how long it will take to get the ring back because it took almost 3 weeks to get them from his order. We are going to have a wedding party next month and we would feel embarrassed if we couldn't get it back by then.
We were so looking forward to get the rings and they ruined our happy and romantic moment of our marriage life.I don't recommend anyone to buy any jewelries from this company.

1 review
1 helpful vote

I ordered December 2 ,order approved(why?)December 4, paid for 4-6 day is December 23 and I have not yet received it. I tried cancelling it but was told it had been shipped so now I have to pay extra to send it back. This was ordered for Christmas gifts and had to be shipped by the 15th to get to the recipients on time.
Not impressed

6 Questions & Answers

Below are questions from consumers with answers from the MyJewelryBox staff and other consumers. Do not write reviews in this section - click here to write a review
Ask a question
Amy P.
on 5/13/16
Add your answer
Posting guidelines
Coleen M.
on 3/27/16
Add your answer
Posting guidelines
See 4 more questions
See more Q&A
Questions? Get answers from the MyJewelryBox staff and other customers.
Note: this is not for reviews - click here to write a review
Get notified about new answers to your questions.
Posting guidelines
Typical questions asked:
  • How long does shipping take?
  • What is the return policy?
  • Where is the company located?

Sites You Might Also Like

Business owners: What’s your side of the story?

Register now for free – get notified of new reviews, respond to consumer feedback, add new photos to your page and much more.

Manage your business
Have a question about
Post Review