How would you rate GunBroker?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
New York
3 reviews
11 helpful votes
Follow Lafemme F.
Unfollow Lafemme F.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I asked the site to change their serial number posting policy, it should be MANDATORY to list the serial number with the gun. There response was, " We don't list serial numbers do to fraud issues." Yeah, they can't properly screw you if they are forced to provide serial numbers! This must be a Bernie Madoff Company.

Date of experience: February 13, 2016
Illinois
0 reviews
3 helpful votes
Follow archer a.
Unfollow archer a.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I initially registered with them and it said that my account was under review, but it did give me a basic level of access to set up my profile and that sort.

Said it would be reviewed in 24-48 hours.

After 48 hours I logged into the system and went to the Support/Isses section where I sent a trouble ticket stating that I had not been approved and the problem had not been addressed.

Some 6 more days later I have not been contacted yet and the item that I wamted to bid on is gone.

I think this site is a sham or a cover for big brother to document your puchases.

Beware of this site

Date of experience: March 4, 2013
Washington
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Chip A.
Unfollow Chip A.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Buyer beware
March 22, 2024

An online marketplace needs 3 things to be legitimate: good tech, good reputation, and good customer service Gunbroker.com has none of these. Tech: Their system sent an address I did not designate for my purchase to the seller, costing me and extra $55 (big thanks to Crossroad Pawn for giving me back some of this, even though it wasn't his fault). Reputation: read reviews of this site. I didn't before shopping here, and had to endure the nightmare of figuring out how bad they were AFTER buying with them. Customer Service: their customer service was basically nonresponsive and provided useless FAQ answers which showed they didn't even read everything I sent them. I had to write a new email to them multiple times to get them to respond at above a 3rd grade level. Then they tried to BLAME me and the seller for a technical error on their part. This is their response: "The cause of the matter was two fold. Part of it was the buyers fault for not keeping the account defaults up to date before placing bids on items and the other part was the seller for creating the label before the buyer completed seller review. The seller has agreed to refund 25.00 for the transfer fee, we feel that is fair. We are closing out this matter. Have a great weekend." NEVER DO BUSINESS WITH GUNBROKER.COM

The ship-to address is in Austin, TX
The seller was given an address in Commerce, TX
Date of experience: March 22, 2024
Kansas
0 reviews
14 helpful votes
Follow mark s.
Unfollow mark s.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

This sight sucks bad review don't do anything non pay and they cancel your account. Then you can't leave bad feedback for the scammer. Will never buy from here ever again beware. Ripped off twice

Date of experience: July 21, 2014
Minnesota
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow Randy H.
Unfollow Randy H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I am a Licensed FFL DEALER That sells ESTATE gun exclusively, and I have sold almost 400 guns on GunBroker over the last year, and had three or four Bidders who didn't follow through with transaction, Yes, it is a pain to get the refund, but you have to ask yourself how else could you control claims fora few dollars. Overall they do a great Job, and no other site provides the capability to feature your items with Photography Like Gun Broker. We live in a world where ETHIC'S has just become a word for many. Do your research before you bid.

Date of experience: January 31, 2015
Illinois
0 reviews
10 helpful votes
Follow Steven L.
Unfollow Steven L.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I would never do business through this website. No one to talk to no matter what. Very poor with customer relations, many more sites that are much better. STEVE C.

Date of experience: July 9, 2015
Arizona
0 reviews
11 helpful votes
Follow fred l.
Unfollow fred l.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I can't imagine how this place stays in business. With the reviews it gets you would think potential buyers would learn from others bad experiences. CUSTOMER SERVICE FOR BUYERS OR SELLERS DOES NOT EXIST its that simple. Hope the local or federal fraud busters get to them soon, right now would be perfect. A sham of a business from the get go. Don't waste your time and do like i do tell all the readers on other gun related boards to stay away. One star is two to many for this bunch of wasters STAY OFF THEIR SITE AND TELL YOUR FRIENDS IN THE WHOLE GUN COMMUNITY TO DO THE SAME

Date of experience: June 20, 2015
Texas
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Craig P.
Unfollow Craig P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Collector's Look Out
October 29, 2016

I enjoy collecting historic military firearms. I take great care in reviewing all the information provided by the seller. I been seriously cheated about 20 % of the winning actions. Seller misrepresented items or fail to give complete information like serial numbers do not match. If I want an item I will bid a full market price. Most items sell for much more than I can find them at Gun Shows. This is not the place to find high grade collector firearms. The skill and attention to detail it takes to make sure one is getting what they want takes the fun out of it. May be OK for shooter guns but you will pay top dollar. Gunbroker does not allow retractions like eBay. They also do not provide you the bidders information that let you see if shill bidding is likely occurring. There is no customer support from my recent experience. I getting too old for the level of stress it takes to use Gunbroker. I do not think it is worth voting for Hillary to put Gunbroker out of business. I do wish eBay sold collector firearms.

Date of experience: October 29, 2016
Kansas
0 reviews
7 helpful votes
Follow Bruce S.
Unfollow Bruce S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Waste my time
December 28, 2015

Does anybody actually pay these prices for firearms. You would need your head examined to pay those prices when there are so many other options available on the Internet

Date of experience: December 28, 2015
Idaho
0 reviews
3 helpful votes
Follow Trever E.
Unfollow Trever E.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Horrible customer services. 1st email I sent in I never got a response regarding submitting documents to open account. I was charged a $1.00 fee for a account I can't use and. 50 for a late fee for a account I can't use. 2nd time I emailed this wonderful customer service this what sent in and there reply

I emailed months ago about not being able to provide the documents required to make an account and never got a reply. And I see you have billed me 1.50 for a account I could never use how can I get this all taken care of and get this account just deleted. Please someone email me back this time!

GBSupport1012. You dont have anything to prove that you are you? Really?

They are no help at all wouldn't use this site ever again even if they had the last gun or bullet left in the world.

Date of experience: July 30, 2013
South Dakota
0 reviews
9 helpful votes
Follow carl J.
Unfollow carl J.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Rude thugs run it
January 13, 2016

I've found their board mods/customer support to be rude and of no help what so ever. Not sure how that board manages to survive. My recommendation: stay away

Date of experience: January 13, 2016
North Carolina
13 reviews
105 helpful votes
Follow Steven M.
Unfollow Steven M.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I used Gunbroker as a registered FFL dealer for 13 years with hundreds of transactions but every time I needed customer support they treated me like I was stupid and were condescending finally in anger and frustration I dared to tell CS that I was sick of their "BS" and "all their asses should be fired" and CS immediately terminated a long time and faithful customer for "using inappropriate language." So they really appreciated my years of business. I wrote a letter to their CEO and he didn't care! Later I tried to get reinstated but they said I had 4 strikes and I said, not it was one issue where you improper credit card practices cost me money and you know it, and for that they simply deleted my profile with almost 300 positive transactions. The worst and most abusive Customer Service I have ever dealt with; EVER!

Date of experience: October 4, 2014
Wisconsin
0 reviews
5 helpful votes
Follow THOMAS L.
Unfollow THOMAS L.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

GUN BROKER SCAM
February 18, 2016

I PLACED ABOUT 60; 000 WORTH OF VARIOUS ITEMS. AND EVERY TIME A SCAMMER WOULD PLACE A BUY NOW THEY TOOK THEIR FEES IMMEDIATELY.THE SCAMMER ALSO GAVE ME A BAD RAP FOR NOT FALLING FOR HIS BULL$#*!. AND GUNBROKER REFUSED TO REFUND MY MONEY AND REMOVE THE BAD RAP ABOUT ME. STAY AWAY FROM GUN BROKER... AND NO WAY TO CONTACT THEM EITHER AND IT TAKES WEEKS TO RESPOND IF YOU GO THROUGH THEIR CHANNELS. I CLOSED ALL MY ADS AND THEY BAND ME FROM USING THERE SITE AND A YEAR AGO TO DATE THEY WANT THEIR MONEY. LUCKILY ENOUGH I LOST MY WALLET AND GOT A NEW CREDIT CARD NUMBER AND NEVER GAVE THEM THE NEW ONE. OR I WOULD BE OUT OF MORE MONEY. I CAN'T EMPHASIS THIS ENOUGH ''STAY AWAY''

Date of experience: February 18, 2016
California
0 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Scott F.
Unfollow Scott F.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Five years and only 1 bad transaction. Compared to ebay this site is heaven. Every minor problem involves a refund on ebay and tutorials if you use a trademark name. And listing fees car auctions run about 60.00 a week. Gunbroker is not perfect but if you use common sense and communicate their are no problems. People just like to hear themselves whine.
3% is fee after selling on Gunbroker NO LISTING FEES! NO HOLDS ON PAYPAL! NO RESTRICTIONS ON ITEMS NATIONALITY THAT you sell.

Date of experience: August 6, 2014
Michigan
0 reviews
11 helpful votes
Follow Harry b.
Unfollow Harry b.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Yeah These guys suck! I should have know this, 12,000 auctions and 6 bidders All gunbroker emails now go to forever spam. My beef with Gunbroker is VERY rude! St responce from cus. Serv. Then every E-mail from GB when opened went to a malware page. Almost locked up my pc 3 times, and the 3rd time was right after I read responce from Cust. Serv. I went to go back in to GB and again a Malware Page. I was done! Made 2 purchases all went well. Then started reading reviews, And thought, Yes I could see GB doing all that was said in negative reviews. And GB sellers Many are like GB and assume people are stupid. Thanks for lookin!

Date of experience: June 8, 2015
Minnesota
0 reviews
5 helpful votes
Follow Damon K.
Unfollow Damon K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I had problems with a seller on Gun Broker. After I sent the money he wanted to charge me $25 per day until he received all the information from the FFL I used. I had pruchased 3 other guns on Gun Broker using the same FFL and had no problems. I will NEVER use Gun Broker again. They have no customer service to address the seller's scam. I still haven't received the firearm and don't know if I will. Gun Broker hasn't done jack. The seller is from FL and I'm in MN so I guess I'm "F'd".

Date of experience: May 31, 2013
Virginia
3 reviews
6 helpful votes
Follow Mikial M.
Unfollow Mikial M.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I'm sorry, but I just had to comment on some of the bad reviews I'm reading here. People complain because they have to pay $1 to verify their account? That's called preventing scams. People complain because they had to pay the "Buy it Now" price on a Buy it Now only listing instead of being able to place a lower bid? What do they think 'Buy it now' means? People complain because they didn't read the description and got something they didn't want" C'mon people, show a little responsibility. One person even complained because he decided he didn't want something after he won the auction and didn't pay for it, so Gunbroker shut his account down? That's called being a non-paying bidder and any site will shut you down for that because they want to keep things honest. You know, sellers DO have to pay for listings and if you are a non-paying bidder, you are essentially ripping them off.

You know, we're all supposed to be responsible adult gun owners, not a bunch of whiny Liberals who always try to blame everyone else for their own mistakes. If you don't like Gunbroker, that's fine, then don't use it. I have only had 20 transactions on there so far, but I have never given or received a single bit of negative feedback.

Date of experience: October 7, 2015
Texas
0 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Dick P.
Unfollow Dick P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I purchased a $1,250.00 rifle that was advertised as new but when it arrived it was scratched and scuffed in many places. I reported this to GUNBROKER and they said they could not compel a seller to do anything. They could only recommend. They said the "Fraudulent Misrepresentation" the seller made was not Fraud under their guidelines. I spent weeks sending pics, emailing and replying. They said they escalated the case and instructed the seller to contact me for return. No one ever contacted me and GUNBROKER became slower and slower in their emails to me. They denied my FRAUD claim and said it was a CONDITION issue not fraud. I sent them the definition of Fraudulent Misrepresentation and they did not reply. They have no desire to kill the golden goose (seller) in favor of there buyer customers (sheep). If you buy a gun through them, remember YOU ARE ON YOUR ON. You can not compel a non-reputable seller from half way across the country to do ANYTHING.

Date of experience: April 21, 2017
Georgia
0 reviews
14 helpful votes
Follow Jake S.
Unfollow Jake S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

High volume dealer, I've sold close to 2k in guns. Do not expect a courteous reply if you need help or have an issue, stay away they're unethical and downright obnoxious to deal with.

Date of experience: September 25, 2015
New York
1 review
15 helpful votes
Follow Anthony L.
Unfollow Anthony L.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Just like with ANY e-tailer there is a level of due-diligence you must do for each sale. IF you do not and have a bad experience than you have no one to blame but yourself. I have bought and sold on gunbroker for YEARS without a single problem. If accurate and transparent expectation levels are established & met along with good communication BOTH ways you should NEVER have a single problem.

Date of experience: October 12, 2013

Overview

GunBroker has a rating of 1.3 stars from 231 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with GunBroker most frequently mention customer service, credit card and phone number. GunBroker ranks 315th among Sporting Goods sites.

service
51
value
45
shipping
38
returns
38
quality
41