website thubmnail of Gotham Steel
How would you rate Gotham Steel?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
Canada
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Derrick B.
Unfollow Derrick B.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Received damaged
June 17, 2023

Received as a Christmas gift, with no receipt. Opened package and the 3 piece fry pan set did not have separators between each pan so the because they are piled on top of each other, the rim of each pan for damaged and all roughed up from the handle of the pan on top of it, and the two lower pans received damage in the surface if the pan. Sent pictures, never even used, as you could tell in pictures. Contacted gotham and they said sorry no receipt no return. Unfortunately don't have receipts because person who bought for us now has medical issue and unable to provide receipt. Can't use these pans because i think the damage done because of bad packing will cause them to stick.

Warning: if purchasing these from a store check the packaging to make sure packed correctly, and make sure you have receipt or else no assistance can be provided.

+1
Date of experience: June 17, 2023
Colorado
1 review
10 helpful votes
Follow Chantira D.
Unfollow Chantira D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I bought these pans in January we are only in May and literally everything sticks to them. I called customer service about it sent them pictures and my receipt. I purchased a 20 pc $399 set. They expect me to pay the shipping to send them the defective pans and then they will send me new ones. What kind of company makes a customer pay for shipping to return a defective product. Absolutely worst pans I've ever used literally Food Network pans work better than them. Don't waste your money.

Date of experience: May 14, 2021
Texas
2 reviews
5 helpful votes
Follow Carla P.
Unfollow Carla P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Not as advertised!
June 23, 2022

These pans are pretty, but the claim that food doesn't stick is so false. You also cannot use metal utensils. I used beaters for potatoes once, like the commercial shows, and it ruined the pan. They cost too much for all this.

Date of experience: June 23, 2022
Texas
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow John C.
Unfollow John C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Scam site
October 3, 2021

The tv ad is nothing like advertised they don't give u extra pan for saying u saw it on tv. Once u get in touch they consistently bomb you with trying to buy more pans. Would not recommend these scammers

Date of experience: October 3, 2021
Idaho
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Amy R.
Unfollow Amy R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

DO NOT BUY
November 20, 2022

I bought the entire set plus the large fry pan in March. They are beautiful and worked well the first month. By month two good was sticking and by month four I can't put anything in them that it doesn't immediately stick and will not come clean. I'm almost 50 years old so I've owned a pan or two and in half a century these are hands down the worst. What a waste of money. It really just makes me sick

Date of experience: November 20, 2022
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Shannon M.
Unfollow Shannon M.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

We are satisfied with our set of Gotham steel pans. Only issue we have encountered so far In the 2+yrs owning them Is that the pans dry out very quickly no matter how much butter or liquid you add to it somehow it absorbs it all rather quickly. Other than that we haven't had any issues with the pans

Date of experience: July 27, 2022
Iowa
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Jeri C.
Unfollow Jeri C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Love the frying pans
March 13, 2022

I purchased 2 of the small frying pans 2 years ago. Use them all the time for over easy eggs and they still look like new. Even though they say you don't need to oil the pans, I always use the nonstick spray. They clean up easy and there are no scratches or discoloration like I got with cheaper cookware.

Date of experience: March 12, 2022
Nevada
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Herm I.
Unfollow Herm I.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Bought one of the frying pans with get one and free small egg frying pan. One has held up okay while the other pan, although not used to much and never with metal utensils, showed nicks shortly thereafter (see 1st pic); with that said the small egg frying pan has performed well. Was finally able to get the nicked pan replaced (see 2nd pic), but it did take more effort than should have been required; thus the customer service side does have a lot to be desired. Maybe because of mass production, it could be a crapshoot whether you get a pan that holds up to the hype or not. Nevertheless, based on the pricing I guess it's worth a roll of the dice. To that end though, you will have to keep your patience when deal with their customer service and hold their feet to the fire.

Date of experience: July 30, 2023
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Bonnie C.
Unfollow Bonnie C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Disappointed
September 5, 2022

I am not pleased with the fact that both skillets I have spin on top of my cooktop instead of just sitting flat. And, that creates a problem bc nobody wants to use those skillets bc of this. We end up using the chicken fryer... ughhhhh

Date of experience: September 3, 2022
GB
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Gillian W.
Unfollow Gillian W.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Disappointed
November 7, 2021

Given as gift, look lovely but I think I'd rather have cheap ones from asda. The frying pans, you can't even cook an egg on them as they stick, the oven try looks terrible as it's not good either. I'm most disappointed. Only good thing is they look nice.

Date of experience: November 7, 2021
Virginia
3 reviews
12 helpful votes
Follow Irene K.
Unfollow Irene K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Garbage
September 1, 2022

I got a Gotham Steel Pro set for my birthday in April. It's been five months and one of the pots cracked. Didn't just develop a chip, but CRACKED all the way through. The only thing that was in there was macaroni. There's no way to contact customer service on their site that I can see. I wound up just tossing the pot.

Date of experience: September 1, 2022
Kansas
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Herbert G.
Unfollow Herbert G.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I purchased this set for Christmas 2023. Gotham Steel Diamond Pots and Pans Set Nonstick Cookware Set Includes Skillets Fry Pans Stock Pots, Dishwasher, and Oven Safe12 Pcs. It says it has a 10-year warranty. Stove top and oven safe. Compatible with gas, electric, glass tops, and oven safe up to a sizzling 500 degrees. After 6 months of use, every pan now sticks and gets worse with every use.

Date of experience: January 26, 2024
GB
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Robert L.
Unfollow Robert L.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

20cm Frying Pan - Useless
February 20, 2022

We bought a Gotham pan set, all I can say is never again, don't touch this product. It's supposed to be non-stick, it should be called 100% stick.
When I looked at the guarantee I have to send it to America... seriously

Date of experience: February 20, 2022
Indiana
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow Casey V.
Unfollow Casey V.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

We put these pans on our wedding registry because my wife was so excited for them. Little did we know they would'nt hold up longer than a few months. Unlike advertised everything sticks to them. They'll cook your food but nothing close to advertised. Save your hard earned money!

Date of experience: October 17, 2022
Colorado
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Frank K.
Unfollow Frank K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

The pans scratch and the coating comes off with ease. The customer service department never gets back to you to warranty out their products. So just stuck with stuck on foods scratched and chipping ceramic coating. I only used the pan 3 times. This pan is fragile like an egg.

Date of experience: March 27, 2022
Texas
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Tory K.
Unfollow Tory K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

TERRIBLE TERRIBLE RIP OFF
November 28, 2023

Pans lasted just at 90 days now everything sticks to them such a scam such a rip off got them for my wife for mothers day and she is extremely disappointed. They do what they do to get you to buy them with the commercials etc.yeah of course they work when brand new then after that CRAP worst pans ive every purchased.90 money back guarantee...if you stand behind your product offer a lifetime...if they really are what you say they are...wish i could get my money back! STAY FAR AWAY from this product

Date of experience: November 28, 2023
Tennessee
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Laverne C.
Unfollow Laverne C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Over rated cookware
November 1, 2022

The cookware is beautiful, but not what it's being demonstrated to be. It sticks and chips badly. My husband I a person of pretty in place, things have to look perfect whether it be food or cookware. If it looks good to him he attempts to justify the end results, and his what is grabbing so many people. The sad thing about my situation is he ordered not one but two set. Yes, there is a difference in the quality of the sets. I am not at all impressed or happy with either set. I will never recommend this product a of now to ANYONE.

Date of experience: November 1, 2022
Ohio
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Kelly W.
Unfollow Kelly W.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

They stick scratch and stain the rivets are coming out of the handles. The pans are alight but the scillets are garbage. I received them as a Christmas gift.

Loading...
Date of experience: January 20, 2024
Pennsylvania
2 reviews
3 helpful votes
Follow Sharon K.
Unfollow Sharon K.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I received my order for 20 pc. Cookware and a pot is chipped. I have been trying for a month to get this replaced and no one is answering me back. I would never order from them or order their cookware again. Beware if you get a bad piece of merchandise...no returns. You are out of luck like I am.

Date of experience: January 24, 2023
Georgia
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Bill T.
Unfollow Bill T.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Food sticks to these pans and is hard to remove even after soaking. The photo shows stuck food after several hours of soaking. Had to scrub hard to get it off. Never used anything other than a blue sponge/scrubber so this cannot be from abuse. Never had this issue with PTFE coated pans. Bought this set of two pans from Costco and both perform the same.

Date of experience: November 7, 2021

Overview

Gotham Steel has a rating of 1.6 stars from 127 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with Gotham Steel most frequently mention non stick, customer service and frying pan. Gotham Steel ranks 293rd among Kitchen sites.

service
39
value
56
shipping
35
returns
28
quality
53
+94