Top Custom Jewelry Sites

Custom Jewelry Sites: 150 businesses
Filter by:
Star rating
Service rating
Value rating
Shipping rating
Returns rating
Quality rating
Price
Clear All
Star rating
Service rating
Value rating
Shipping rating
Returns rating
Quality rating
Price
See All Reviews
5,471 reviews
ross-simons.com
Some items match the photos. Others don't. You need to see it in person by taking a chance. Return process is...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
654
Value
42
Shipping
41
Returns
25
Quality
5224
See details Hide details

Ross-Simons

See All Reviews
3,117 reviews
joancee.com
Love your rings. I have had my ring for 3 yrs and it has never lost the shine or turned my finger green. Worth every...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
1191
Value
218
Shipping
225
Returns
206
Quality
2517
See details Hide details

Joancee

See All Reviews
1,243 reviews
diamondere.com
Very pleased with Diamondere. Customized an engagement ring and it arrived on time with no issues. Ring was...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
87
Value
51
Shipping
51
Returns
16
Quality
51
See details Hide details

Diamondere

See All Reviews
6,627 reviews
jeulia.com
I was sucked into purchasing some rings from this website on Feb 1st, 2024. It came in smaller than my actual ring...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
270
Value
257
Shipping
270
Returns
164
Quality
253
See details Hide details

Jeulia

See All Reviews
1,161 reviews
jewlr.com
When I ordered I got immediate response, great price, received in 2 days & the presentation was exceptional. The free...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
56
Value
57
Shipping
59
Returns
28
Quality
50
See details Hide details

Jewlr

See All Reviews
847 reviews
kingice.com
I've been a fan of King Ice's products since 2020 when I first heard of them. Bought two chains and was very happy...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
17
Value
19
Shipping
19
Returns
13
Quality
18
See details Hide details

King Ice

See All Reviews
390 reviews
edwinnoveljewelrydesign.com
Edwin Novel is the epitome of professionalism. I was buying my girlfriend a pair of diamond earrings and wanted to...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
33
Value
29
Shipping
30
Returns
28
Quality
30
See details Hide details

Edwin Novel Jewelry Design

See All Reviews
245 reviews
betterjewelry.com
These bracelets are really cute. Even if you don't take them off and put them in water daily. Use your sterling...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
10
Value
11
Shipping
11
Returns
4
Quality
10
See details Hide details

Betterjewelry

See All Reviews
135 reviews
distinctivegem.com
I have worked with Jonathan before, so I knew what to expect of his products, exacting standards, and level of...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
8
Value
7
Shipping
7
Returns
1
Quality
7
See details Hide details

Distinctive Gem

See All Reviews
156 reviews
bestbrilliance.com
Best Brilliance provides a competitive bundle of services. They know people are reticent to buy jewelry online, so...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
33
Value
34
Shipping
19
Returns
20
Quality
29
See details Hide details

Best Brilliance

See All Reviews
188 reviews
wandererbracelets.com
Great quality product and had a great customer service experience when I did not receive all items I purchased last...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
27
Value
140
Shipping
140
Returns
1
Quality
186
See details Hide details

Wanderer Bracelets

See All Reviews
128 reviews
scorejewelry.com
"Received the ring extremely fast! It came much quicker then I thought (less then two weeks) and it's absolutely...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
112
Value
107
Shipping
109
Returns
105
Quality
107
See details Hide details

Score Jewelry

See All Reviews
229 reviews
homebello.com
I ordered the 4x6 snake print Addison Ross picture frame from Home Bello and everything from the ordering of my frame...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
58
Value
54
Shipping
53
Returns
35
Quality
52
See details Hide details

HomeBello

See All Reviews
72 reviews
thepinkpigs.com
It's so great being able to shop and knowing the money is going to help animals. Even better that this seller has...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
1
Quality
2
See details Hide details

The Pink Pigs, Jewelry, Apparel & Gifts for People who Love Animals!

See All Reviews
87 reviews
cleanseandco.com.au
I just wanted to say a massive thank you to the Cleanse&Co team, especially Hayley. I had an issue with my order so I...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
13
Value
14
Shipping
13
Returns
12
Quality
14
See details Hide details

Cleanse & Co.

See All Reviews
58 reviews
columbiajewelers.net
Wonderful owner. Bracelet is perfect. Could not be happier or more satisfied with the quality and design of the bracelet

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

Columbia Jewelers, Fall River, Massachusetts, USA

See All Reviews
62 reviews
joyamojewelry.com
It's perfect and we love giving personalized gifts so will be using them in future! They do really good work and fast...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
37
Value
36
Shipping
37
Returns
16
Quality
35
See details Hide details

JoyAmo

See All Reviews
39 reviews
watangems.com
Fantastic through the whole process! Great transaction system and they are very helpful. Sitejabber helps consumers...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
2
Quality
2
See details Hide details

watangems

See All Reviews
60 reviews
joseod.com
The website is OK. Products are just nice quality. People complain of shipping so I used express shipping and item...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
2
Quality
2
See details Hide details

Joseod LLC

See All Reviews
53 reviews
myjewelleryshop.com.au
Great experience. Would happily purchase from My Jewellery Shop again. I prefer to support small Australian owned...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
7
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
1
Quality
3
See details Hide details

My Jewellery Shop

See All Reviews
74 reviews
silviax.com
Silvia's is the greatest for shipping for custom jewelry! Everyone loves the name chain, my niece is always asking me...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
35
Value
32
Shipping
33
Returns
19
Quality
30
See details Hide details

Silviax

See All Reviews
58 reviews
norsespirit.com
I completely understand the shipping problems because of the holidays and the weather. Actually it had perfect...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
16
Value
16
Shipping
16
Returns
7
Quality
15
See details Hide details

Norse Spirit

See All Reviews
34 reviews
classrings.com
Super happy with the purchase of my honor society ring. Excellent quality and wrapped like a gift. It was as much fun...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
1
Quality
2
See details Hide details

ClassRings

See All Reviews
36 reviews
roscejewelers.com
I just love this store! Great collections, wonderful service, really good prices! Me myself am an owner of my first...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
25
Value
24
Shipping
22
Returns
12
Quality
25
See details Hide details

Rosce Jewelers

See All Reviews
25 reviews
cattlecait.com
Everything I've ever bought from Cait--from tooled leather sidesaddle earrings to scarves to a belt knife--has been...
See details Hide details

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
1
See details Hide details

Cattle Cait

Select up to five businesses to compare

(1/5)