business logo of Plenty of Fish

Plenty of FishReviews 2,010

1.3

On Sitejabber, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Plenty of Fish?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star

Plenty of Fish Reviews Summary

The overall reputation of Plenty of Fish (POF) is largely negative, with customers expressing significant dissatisfaction regarding the quality of profiles and user interactions. Common concerns include a high prevalence of fake profiles, rudeness, and entitlement among users, particularly women, who are perceived as unrealistic in their dating expectations. Many reviews highlight poor customer service, including issues with account management and a lack of effective support. While some users acknowledge the site's potential for connecting singles, the overwhelming sentiment suggests that POF has declined in quality and user experience, leading many to seek alternatives.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
410
value
413
shipping
99
returns
111
quality
445

We monitor reviews for authenticity

Germany
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Joseph S.
Unfollow Joseph S.
Share Review
Report Review

Ripoff.
May 25, 2019

It is a very bad site. First, they will put you on automatic payment, and there are no way to turn it off. Trust me I tried, or they purposefully made it impossible to be found, so they can ripoff more money from you. I called them, and they told me the money they took is not refundable? Where is the law in this country? Where are the FBI and the consumer protectors? If any lawyer would take this case I am all in and there are millions others.
Automatic payments with one option should be illegal because it is super easy to sign in if anyone wants to renew, and it should not be hard for users to sign out from.
Second, I would say from my experience with that site, at least 80% of profiles are fake. Maybe fake profiles get created by pof to gain members, and there are many Nigerian and all other spams and scammers crooks trying to take your money and waste your time.
My advice, almost all sites do this trick because it is a loop hole in the American legal system. I hope you all who get my money to spent it on your kids health.

Date of experience: May 25, 2019
Arizona
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow LIZ L.
Unfollow LIZ L.
Share Review
Report Review

PLENTY OF PHONIES
May 24, 2019

PLENTY OF SCAMMERS, TAKE YOUR CHOICE, NOT ONE REAL PERSON ON THIS SITE IN OVER 2 MONTHS, A TOTAL WASTE OF TIME AND EFFORT, LIARS, THEY LOVE YOU WITH IN 2-3 EMAILS, THEN LATER HIT YOU FOR THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS TO PROVE TO THEM YOU CARE... LOL

Date of experience: May 24, 2019
Minnesota
3 reviews
7 helpful votes
Follow Kim O.
Unfollow Kim O.
Share Review
Report Review

Scammers galore.
May 23, 2019

I'm tired of the scammers preying on women. Men too I hear. Stinks. I can almost tell you by the first message if they are and most definitely the second. Those that make it to three are damn good but I catch them. Such liars, the reasons they need money from you and such.

I swear I should write a book on the ones I've come across. Good laughs. They usually disappear fast when I tell them my son is a deputy sheriff and I have their IP addy. One guy wanted money and after refusing, blocking and such he finally admitted he was in Africa and how else could he get money. One wanted $10,000 not to kill my family and such. He was begging for $50 by the time he quit. One pretended he was his son and needed money to find his dad. Gotta love the I'm working out of country and need to buy a BD gift for son so buy a new iPhone on your account and after I get it I'll attach my CC to your account to pay it off. Hey if you can pay my bill with your CC buy the phone with it also.

The stories are getting bigger andore demanding so ladies keep your backbone. You don't need a man to abuse you that way.

To the men on here who crab about women. What about the men with tats, no clothes, overweight, sagging everywhere, triple necks, etc. You're not perfect either. Men are just as bad when they state how they want a woman to look. I'm doing pretty good and I've had three kids, what's your excuse?

Date of experience: May 23, 2019
Ohio
2 reviews
13 helpful votes
Follow James B.
Unfollow James B.
Share Review
Report Review

Fake accounts
May 20, 2019

The POF profiles are a bunch of spam accounts. Biggest con on men everywhere. You chat with one profile they respond with one liners, and you don't hear from them again. Waste of time and money

Date of experience: May 20, 2019
South Dakota
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Caleb H.
Unfollow Caleb H.
Share Review
Report Review

Scammers and bots
May 16, 2019

Scammers and bots are rife on this site. There are some genuine women, but most of what you get are bots and scammers asking you to go on a different site to meet. They will say it's a safety site. I get 15+ messages from such profiles in less than 6 hours. If you can handle sifting through that filth then go for it. Right now it's a waste of time.

Date of experience: May 16, 2019
Ireland
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Ocean r.
Unfollow Ocean r.
Share Review
Report Review

Pof pure scum. All the woman are professional liars great actor's. No intention of meeting any one. One way to deal with this get POF hacked wiped out. Not POF plenty of $#*!ed up people

Date of experience: May 15, 2019
New York
1 review
4 helpful votes
Follow Robert S.
Unfollow Robert S.
Share Review
Report Review

Desperate men
May 13, 2019

Always wondered why so many unattractive women had such an unpleasant chip on the shoulder
I saw a profile from a female 28 nothing special
She seemed pleasant enough but she said she was getting tired of men telling her she was stunning
She wasn't. At Best she was average
That made me think if desperate men are messaging ordinary women saying they are stunning then how many messages will the actual good looking women get?
This is most definitely a site for women. The numbers not in your favor if you're a man especially not if men are mailing everything on there saying they are stunning
Get some damn self respect guys ffs

Date of experience: May 13, 2019
California
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Jacob Z.
Unfollow Jacob Z.
Share Review
Report Review

Before POF I didnt know there was so many single moms about. I've never seen so many woman on there who have had children out of wedlock and now are looking for someone to bring the children up as their own. They cant all have been divorced so they just seen to have churn children out with no regard
I have no intention of being 2nd in a relationship as they tell you the children will always come 1st. I did laugh how they still think they are a catch when they have this baggage.
I also laugh when they put profession down as mum or yummy mummy. That's not a job its a lifestyle choice.

The rest are either fraudulent profiles wanting you to click for webcam stuff or blatant prostitutes or just really unattractive MUTANTS that other men in the outside world have rejected so they have gone online and set up a profile looking for a dream man who must be tall dark and handsome
The mutant women also seem really obsessed with putting up tattoo photos of the legs arms and rest of the body
They say you must love dogs and if not don't contact them

They come across as picky demanding rude and you see why alot of profiles proudly proclaim they are back again! As if its something to brag about

The fraudulent scammers now message you saying they need your help or they message you saying can I say something?

I dont know if the people running the site cant deal the sheer demand of scammers or whether they dont care but cant be that hard to ban IP addresses

0/10 and thats generous

Date of experience: May 12, 2019
Panama
3 reviews
22 helpful votes
Follow Alberto V.
Unfollow Alberto V.
Share Review
Report Review

Plenty of Fish or POF is not that bad, yes the layout and the script is not as fancy as other websites but still works. I've managed to meet a few ladies from there, just regular ladies, not Miss Universes or something like that. Real people for real times. Yes, there are the picky ones and also the mean ones, like any other website but its free and you can get almost all the benefits without paying (there are a couple of profiles when you are told you have to upgrade to chat with these which I consider somewhat of a scam but these are only a few) therefore you can get something done for you.
POF has potential if you give it a try.

Date of experience: May 11, 2019
New York
3 reviews
6 helpful votes
Follow Anony M.
Unfollow Anony M.
Share Review
Report Review

AKA Plenty of Fail
May 10, 2019

OKC is so much better. There are so many off characters on POF that I've wasted time on. One of them was already in a long term relationship and they were looking to cheat. Another lives with his parents, unemployed and kept making excuses as to why he wasn't going to look for one. After our first and last date he said he only wanted to be friends but not before negging me over how I supposedly look different than I did in my photos (No one has ever told me this before until then) then had the nerve to say that my outfit wasn't flattering for my body type. I'm sorry but what heterosexual man cares about what a woman wears? Anyway, I ended up closing my account and found someone better on OKC :)

Date of experience: May 10, 2019
Canada
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow Drury T.
Unfollow Drury T.
Share Review
Report Review

From looking there are about 3% of females that are worth responding to. The rest are dogs. The problem is the other guys will see the same so you've got 1000s of guys all messaging the same 3% of women.

I thought I'd see how deluded and out of touch some of the other less attractive women on here are so send 30 copy and paste to women I didn't find attractive just to see. Now bare in mind I'm not a bad looking fella and these women should have been grateful that someone like me would message them. Result they all looked at my profile and NONE of them replied HAHAHA. I found it funny. Even the ugly ones & farties don't reply and want a male model

So the fat uglies that nobody would want in the real world think they are divas & princesses on the computer. Let me repeat that a whole website of demanding unattractive women thinking they are better looking than they are! Oh and 95% of them don't drive so they'll want you be their taxi

You would have more chance going into town & handing out your number to random strangers than hoping to get a reply from anyone on this site.

Date of experience: May 8, 2019
GB
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Wayne D.
Unfollow Wayne D.
Share Review
Report Review

I signed up and got 10 messages within 30 minutes sadly all fake. The site seems overrun with them

The women who are real think they're gods gift to men but they're either overweight, very very ordinary looking, using photos from 5 years ago or waffling on about how they are independent, there seems to be a lot of them with degrees too (lies)
I messaged one and she replied you live TWO far away, she had a degree but can't spell correctly
Plenty of profiles in which they are typing in capitals saying if you don't have a photo you won't get a reply or if you are not over 6ft tall you will be ignored etc etc. It's almost as if they are trying their hardest to put you off sending them a message
I messaged them mocking them saying "great profile, lovely attitude" and they didn't realise I was doing it. Let's just say intelligence isn't very high on pof,

I messaged one person who seemed okay but she replied "where are you from" - too lazy or thick to read my profile location

In a perverse way it seems the more unattractive they are on pof the nastier the profile is yet they still want Mr Right to message them.

The women are great, superb and gorgeous in their own minds. In reality they are just deluded picky hasbeens who will end up lonely with their 8 cats

The sad thing after all the above I think men are that desperate for a woman they are messaging these horrible females no matter how rude and fat they are. It wouldn't surprise me if the nasty unattractive women get that much mail they can't reply to all. Get some dignity guys -I would sooner be single forever than date anyone off pof

Date of experience: May 6, 2019
GB
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Jacob d.
Unfollow Jacob d.
Share Review
Report Review

Fake, the other half are low class munters obsessed with dogs and tattoos. Photos of the they own are on most pics and they love to show the tattoos they have. I got bored of reading if you don't love dogs don't message and I have 8 tattoos and plan to have more. You can't buy class

Not sure why people are complaining about getting scammed after paying money. You seriously think you'd have more chance if you upgraded? It's full of the most undateable women I have ever come across in my entire life

Low class women calling themselves princesses demanding stupidity high standards from a guy when they are undateable is the logic you find on pof

The women on pof must think it's Christmas come early because if not for this site they wouldn't get any male attention judging by the looks and attitude of them.

Plenty of munters pouting and gurning
No thank you

Date of experience: May 5, 2019
Canada
1 review
8 helpful votes
Follow Ryan c.
Unfollow Ryan c.
Share Review
Report Review

All I found were drama queens who seem to have issues not right in the head of unbalanced.

If you find someone who appears normal you can virtually guarantee they'll have a 10 point checklist of what you must possess before you can even message them and get a reply
Desperate men must message them I think otherwise how can they get away with the rude behaviour

It reminds me of when you used to be in a bar at 3am before closing and all the best women had long gone and all that was left were the leftovers nobody wanted. Pof is full of those kind. If they were attractive and a good person they wouldn't be on there

But in a funny way they don't see themselves that way. A few messages and they think they are Angelina Jolie

Without being rude there's a reason they are single

Date of experience: May 5, 2019
Daniel P.
GB
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Daniel P.
Unfollow Daniel P.
Share Review
Report Review

Re
May 5, 2019

I get abuse from same women every time this has to change or ill go to another website been on pof 5 year

Date of experience: May 5, 2019
New York
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Harold R.
Unfollow Harold R.
Share Review
Report Review

Biggest piece of crap
April 29, 2019

All fakes or prostitutes full of people trying to scam you if you complain they will ban you for life they tell you your lying even though you show them proof

Date of experience: April 29, 2019
GB
1 review
3 helpful votes
Follow Tom Q.
Unfollow Tom Q.
Share Review
Report Review

Circus freaks
April 28, 2019

Oh my days wow just wow
Its like all the messed up screwed up nasty women are all on one website. It's like a freakshow on there

* 70% of the women I saw on pof were fakes. They message you with hey there:)
If you reply you'll get a dodgy link to click on

When you find the real ones the 30%

* slobby women who don't take care of themselves but want a man who works out

*women ranting about how bad men are in the profiles. That's always a winner isn't it?

*women thinking they are stunning and wanting someone tall dark handsome when they are short and fat

*the likes/dislikes section just generic rubbish. Such as I dislike ignorant rude people and bad drivers

*Pig ignorant weird types who seem to lack any social skills even behind a computer

*women that been single too long and are way too picky but don't get it. They usually are teachers and they say they are very very independent on the profile

*women getting on in years but longest relationship is under a year. Danger danger alert

*women you wouldn't take home to meet your mum. Tattoos everywhere + happy to put up scantily clad wearing virtually nothing in their photos at the same time in capital letters telling men they don't want fun

Date of experience: April 28, 2019
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Dave C.
Unfollow Dave C.
Share Review
Report Review

I am hoping to help others avoid what Plenty of Fish did to me. I subscribed for two months.

They put me on auto renew so my subscription renewed against my wishes.

So even though I agreed to only subscribe for two months they billed me again for two more months i. E. 4 months which is not what I agreed to.

When I requested a refund they said they will not refund me.

Please reconsider doing business with Plenty of Fish.

They are willing to deceive people over such a small amount of money. Can you trust them with your private information and dating life?

Thanks

Date of experience: April 27, 2019
Florida
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Tina A.
Unfollow Tina A.
Share Review
Report Review

DO NOT UPGRADE YOUR ACCOUNT WITH POF! They will charge you for the period of time that you chose to update your account and they will automatically charge you again after that, and if you refuse they will delete your account. I paid for three months to see if I was going to have a better chance to find someone. Terrible error! Upgrading my account just allowed me to see who read my messages and when. It is not worth the money! Once the three months period was over, they automatically charged my credit card. I called my bank and asked for a refund because I never authorized the transaction, then next thing I knew I could not access my account on POF anymore. I called POF customer service to hear them to tell me that they deleted my account because I asked for a refund. I told them that if was wrong to do that because I did not have any contract with them to keep upgrading my account. They did not care! They told me to create a new account. POF is after your money! If you do not pay, they will delete your account to punish you. Horrible experience!

Date of experience: April 26, 2019
Canada
1 review
6 helpful votes
Follow James f.
Unfollow James f.
Share Review
Report Review

Ghastly
April 24, 2019

The women on here have huge stomachs or huge egos. Either way both are a turn off
Of course they don't say they're fat they say prefer not to say or curvy they only show their faces not body shots

There is very little kindness humility and happiness radiating from them but tons of attitude anger and demands

I looked and saw extremely unremarkable women thinking they were extremely remarkable. Most of them looked like they had been round the block a good few times as well. From the profiles they believe they're a much better catch than they really are

Welcome to online dating where social unattractive damaged misfits call the shots.

No thanks

Date of experience: April 24, 2019