Fanatics has a rating of 2.4 stars from 3,941 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with Fanatics most frequently mention customer service, day shipping and business days. Fanatics ranks 1st among Jersey sites.
Originally, before I placed my order, I was told the 2 custom jerseys would be shipped within 10 days. After I placed the order, immediately they changed the shipping time frame to 6-8 weeks. Very much a bait and switch, since they don't allow you to cancel custom orders. Now we won't have our custom jerseys for my wife's first game. I do NOT recommend this site.
I paid extra for fast shipping as this product was a Christmas present for a family member. My bank told me they are a fraudulent company. Do not order from this place! You will also never be able to get a response from these people.
I placed an order on Sept 27 th.
It is now Oct. 6 th. Tracking has not changed in a week. Near impossible to contact anyone in the company. When I log on to check status, no order is showing! The money was taken out of my account, and I have emails with order number and tracking number. Thier online chat is a joke! Very disappointed. Glad I paid with pay pal. Will likely start a claim soon for a refund.
I ordered an NFL shirt back in May 2022. After numerous shipping delays I cancelled my order since it's now August and the most recent ship date was the end of September. I found the exact same shirt on another reputable sports merchandise website for the same price and ordered it. It was shipped the same day I ordered! I had a similar experience with Fanatics when trying to order Super Bowl merchandise. At least I only wasted a couple of weeks waiting for merchandise that was never going to come. I will never attempt to do business with this "company" again.
Ordered two jerseys. One has defective stitching on the big number on the back. Contacted customer service and they offer to let me keep the damaged one and will send me a replacement only if I agree to pay another $25 in shipping! NEVER doing business with Fanatics again and warning everyone I can every chance I get.
Bought jersey on draft day waited 3 months to get a jersey with screen printing. I paid over $100 for a Jersey I could have bought at the flea market. Should have ordered one on EBay ($115) that has sewn lettering and logos. Probably the last real Redskins Jersey I can get and its a dud. Poor products slow shipping. I check today and the same jersey is $59 I'm pissed. Punt don't don't buy from these guys
Hello Anthony. Thank you so much for your feedback! We are sorry that the jersey was not as you expected. We do have several different jerseys available on the site and the "Game" jersey is screen printed. We do have other options if you are interested and in case you would like to return the item we have waived the return fee. If you need any additional assistance, please email us at customerfirst@fanatics.com. Thanks, Cayla
I ordered several items costing well over $100 for Christmas presents. One of the items did not fit so I returned it. I expected a full refund but was informed that I received a $2 refund instead. This is BS! I will NEVER use this site again. Buyer beware if you need to return something to this company.
Hello Sherry. We apologize for any inconvenience regarding your order. We do not offer free returns when using our pre-paid return label. However, as a courtesy on this return, we have issued a refund for your return fees. Please allow 2-7 business days for the refund to post back to your original form of payment. Sincerely, Karmen
I have had nothing but the very best experience with Fanatics. Only once did I have a mailing issue. I called, they were going to send another for free but then I actually got the original product in the mail as we were talking because of an honest person who received my package by accident. I have, not on purpose, sent un-worn items back after a year and got gift card of same price of product, no questions asked (those items were in perfect, unused condition with tags still attached. This has been the greatest business relationship I've had with anyone.
No way of returning anything if you don't have an order number…. Can't speak with a live representative… connects you to a computer… spent hours with no results! I have ordered many times from Fanatics… but this is the last time!
Hello. We are truly sorry to hear about your experience with us. We would love a chance to make this right. We have emailed you a resolution. We apologize again for the inconvenience and hope to hear from you soon. Sincerely, Shanick
This site is a scam. Please don't order from Fanatics. I placed an order several weeks ago and never received the merchandise, unable to send emails, no customer service number to reach someone. Invalid order number was given, order not found.
Good Morning, Simone. I apologize for the inconvenience caused. Upon review of the information, this was placed on FanaticsEdge. This is not our site. I recommend that you contact your financial institution and let them know. Thank you for your patience, Maribell.
I ordered a limited medium eagles legend jersey and received a random xxl team shirt. Extremely frustrated, the jersey I ordered isn't even listed anymore. Was very excited to buy my first jersey in 15 years, only to be extremely let down. Hopefully they can reach out and make this right, because when my girlfriend called(she ordered it on her account) they told her the jersey was sold out(didn't say so on the site) even though when I ordered there was nothing to show that any sizes were sold out. I'm beyond frustrated
Hello Eric, we are happy to take care of this for you! We are terribly sorry that you were sent the wrong item. If you will email us at customerfirst@fanatics.com with your order number, we will be happy to look into and solve this as quickly as possible! We appreciate you reaching out to us and look forward to speaking with you soon! Thanks, David
We ordered a custom Raptors jersey as a gift for a friend, about 6 weeks in advance of his birthday. When it arrived, the letters were peeling off the jersey straight out of the package. We initiated a return, and they promised to send a replacement. When the new package arrived, it was clearly someone else's order - a Blue Jays jerseys with a different name. So we initiated a return again, and asked for the right order to be sent. Instead, Fanatics sent a 30% off coupon for our next purchase, and refunded a portion of our money. Only after complaining to customer service were we given the full refund. In the end they made no attempt to fulfill our order. I've never had such a frustrating online purchasing experience in my life. Their final attempt to appease was another discount coupon code. As if! And by the way, the birthday is long past. Extremely disappointing. Don't bother!
Wish I would have read reviews prior to ordering! I wanted an item for a Christmas gift, order in October since stock/products were going to be difficult to acquire this season. Read the company return policy stating returns accepted 365 days after order date! I did receive the item in a timely manner and product appeared to be nice quality. Gave the gift at Christmas, didn't fit. Initiated return online. Received a message that it was not eligible as returned window closed. Upon further investigation into return policy, manufacturer direct shipments have a 30 day return. Who knew? How do you order a gift, give the gift and return a gift in 30 days? I called customer service and was told exceptions are generally made at Christmas and watch my email for a return label. I received a form letter from Customer Service, Sorry... over 30 days... no returns accepted. This was not a $10 t-shirt! Buyer Beware if you are ordering a gift!
I ordered a t-shirt on Dec 6th for Christmas they said 5 to 7 days
Here it is the 17th and now there saying Jan 16. And they cant give me my money back into I get it and return it. Because it was processed but not shipped
Hello Erin,
Thank you for reaching out. I am reaching out to you in regard to your Site Jabber review. I do apologize for the inconvenience.
I have escalated your request to cancel your order to our order management team. I am not going to make any promises or guarantees that we will be able to cancel your order. You will be notified via email if we are able to cancel your order.
If I have not resolved this matter to your satisfaction, please let me know how I can be of further assistance.
David | Fan Relations
Fanatics | https://www.fanatics.com
Ordered a shirt on 1/2/20, received shipment notification on 1/3/20 and tracking number. It is now 1/15/20 and my package is still sitting at Fanatics. The tracking shows only a label was created, then hasn't moved since. They were quick to charge my card though. They offered no explanation, nor a remedy to the issue. Do not buy from Fanatics.
Hello Jodi, thank you for your feedback! I am very sorry that the package was not received. Our number one concern is customer satisfaction. Upon review, the package was shipped on 1/3/2020. Unfortunately, when the label was created it may have either been damaged or wasn't scanned in at the sorting facility with the shipping carrier. However, you were refunded back to the method of payment. Please allow two to seven business days to reflect on your financial statement. Once again, I apologize for any frustration this may have caused you. Sincerely, Julian
I ordered a Dallas Cowboy's sweatshirt for Big and Tall. It took 2 weeks to arrive. The color quality was so poor. The sleeves were purple and no way matched the logo. Now I have to pay to return. $10. Will not order again.
We received an order of 6 items. I washed all screen printed shirts together after one wearing. One shirt began to peel so I immediately contacted Fanatics for a refund. I was told I would only receive a 50% refund because I do not have the original tags. The screen print is of poor quality. I believe Fanatics should stand behind the products they sell.
Hello Linda, thank you for your feedback! I am very sorry that the shirts were defective. Our number one concern is customer satisfaction. As an exception, the item can be returned for a refund. I have waived the return label fee. You can drop the items off at any local post office. Please allow 10 business days for our warehouse to receive your return. Once again, I apologize for any frustration this may have caused you. Sincerely, Julian
This company takes money, does not ship merchandise. Customer service is no help at all. There is not even an attempt to help customers. Filed dispute on credit card. Save your money and buy anywhere else.
Hello Ted, Thank you for reaching out. We are terribly sorry for the inconvenience. We have passed your experience along to the appropriate department, and it is being looked into. We wanted to reach out to you and apologize immensely for the troubles you have encountered. Please feel free to reach out to us if we can help you further in any way. Thanks, David
I recently had a custom Packers t-shirt made and the miss spelled my name. Called customer service and because it's a custom shirt and their mess up they won't fix it. I mean how do you miss spell Bright really. I have always wanted a shirt made this way now I'm stuck with one that isn't even right. All I got from customer service was it's custom order nothing we can do.
Hello Karen, thank you for your feedback! I am very sorry that the shirt was incorrectly sent to you. Our number one concern is customer satisfaction. I have requested to have a new shirt shipped to you with the correct spelling. Once the label has been created and shipped, you will receive a separate shipping confirmation email. Once again, I apologize for the frustration this may have caused you. Sincerely, Julian
Paid for shipping, delayed twice and hasn't even been shipped, won't get item for over a month. Spoke with rep and they offered to give me a 30% discount on my next order... their promotion on the entire site is 30% off your order. Rep tried to game me and had no other solution. Unbelievably poor experience.
Hello Shawn, thank you for your feedback! I am very sorry that the item Was delayed. Our number one concern is customer satisfaction. The order was revised to ship on 12/10/2020. You wil receive a shipping confirmation email. Once again, I apologize for Frustration this may have caused you Sincerely, Julian
Answer: I have no experience ordering from Australia so I'm afraid I will be of no help. I do agree that the holiday will add a little extra time but I don't believe it's as bad as everyone is saying. I don't know why I had such a good experience with them when it sounds like everyone else is angry with them. I'm curious to see how it goes for you.
Answer: Good luck. I just kept getting stupid answers until I filed a BBB complaint. Then I got instant satisfaction.
Answer: Hello Timo, Thank you for your feedback. We appreciate your business! Mike, Shannon, and Brad -- We would love to have an opportunity to work with you each regarding your less-than stellar experiences. Please provide your order numbers so that we may research and work on resolving your poor experiences! We value each of you and hope you will give us an opportunity to make this right.
Answer: No kidding. These fools are liars and thieves. They literally have fulltime dedicated employees who monitor sites like SiteJabber to provide responses to all the well deserved, nasty Fanatics reviews. It is entirely likely that any and all positive reviews touting their customer service are internally generated by their own employees. Write letters to your licensing body whether it be NFL or MLB and let them know about Fanatics and their FRAUDULENT and DECEPTIVE business practices. Fanatics should be glossed as Fraudnatics. BUYER BEWARE!
Answer: Hello, Thank you for reaching out to us. When an item is found to be out of stock the money is refunded back to the original form of payment. In addition, we issue a store credit on top of this for the inconvenience.
Answer: I would not worry to much about the negative feedback. You should get your items delivered to you with no problem. It might take a little time to be delivered but I had no problems with fanatics.
Answer: Please provide us with the contact information we can best reach you with so that we can pass this along. Julia.
Answer: Thank you for your correspondence. I am very sorry that you had this issue with the item. If you could please private message me your order number so I can take a further look?
Answer: Hello, thank you for reaching out. Upon reviewing your orders should arrive no later than December 13,2017.
Answer: Thank you for reaching out Michael. Refunds can take 2-7 business days for the refund to reflect back on the form of payment that was used at checkout. Thanks, Cayla
Hello Laura. We are very sorry for the inconvenience regarding your order. In tracking, it appears to have been lost in transit to you. We have issued a full and complete refund for your order that will post back to your original form of payment within 2-7 business days. Please let us know if you should need anything further. Sincerely, Karmen