website thubmnail of City-Data.com
How would you rate City-Data.com?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
Illinois
1 review
24 helpful votes
Follow Kevin S.
Unfollow Kevin S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Fed up with this site. Ibginnie is the head moderator. Might even own the site. Not sure. Definitely petty, banning people for using functions built into the site. I got my account locked for posting a picture of the Dow Jones. Nothing controversial. Nothing crazy. Just, "Here's what the Dow Jones is doing now." The function of linking pictures is a built in feature of the forum, but it's sometimes against the rules when they decide that it is. Ibginnie seems to enjoy going after people who have the wrong political views, but even if I'm just imagining that part, banning people for posting pictures of the Dow Jones in a politics forum? Are you f-ing kidding me? I'm done with that BS!

Date of experience: November 25, 2018
Maryland
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Angela J. S.
Unfollow Angela J. S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Awful!
November 13, 2022

Got banned. No warning or explanation and per their rules they can do this. I hope they go downhill like Twitter and Facebook. Buliies galore and zero done to them, but I get banned. Found out when I tried to sign in today.

No warnings or explanation. Found out when I tried to log in and cannot.
Date of experience: November 13, 2022
Illinois
1 review
24 helpful votes
Follow Jack P.
Unfollow Jack P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I enjoyed using this site to learn about different places to live and hear what people had to say about the communities around my area. Earlier today I meant to respond to a post, but I accidentally made a new Fourm. Keep in mind, I'm new to the site so I didn't know how to work everything perfectly. I logged on about an hour ago and found I had been banned permanently for spam! I also have no way of appealing my ban. All for making an innocent mistake.

Date of experience: October 28, 2020
Georgia
12 reviews
40 helpful votes
Follow Keary W.
Unfollow Keary W.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Moderators are a joke
February 16, 2017

Everything as fine until moderators dont like what you say,
Its really odd because its not clear what policy you have broken other than somebody just does not like what you say.
Especially if its protesting any racial or social injustice.
I was told after I heated debate with multiple facts and sources to back my argument that I was not breaking any rules but to stop speaking my mind.
After asking what rules i was breaking in a polite respectable manor, I was banned after being on for 5 years.
If you speak too much of the truth, they will ban you. Dont get too political as the moderators are not very intelligent and take offense easily.
They will allow many racist statements to go unchecked but delete non offensive statements.
Just not a good or well run site due to moderators.It would be great if not for them. Particularly JMT and YAC. Just horrible

Date of experience: February 16, 2017
Texas
1 review
17 helpful votes
Follow James P.
Unfollow James P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Liberal Utopia Forum
October 13, 2016

I posted a story about a women getting raped by muslim refugees. The liberal trolls came out of every corner and defended the refugees. One poster actually blamed the victim for getting raped because she put herself in the position. I couldn't believe my eyes. The next day I was banned for "trolling"... total garbage forum with no freedom to speak.

Date of experience: October 13, 2016
Pennsylvania
1 review
9 helpful votes
Follow Jay S.
Unfollow Jay S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I agree that realtors are probably on this site as well as those writing books or other articles on the best places to live in a particular state or country.

But what happened to freedom of speech and freedom of the press? You people bashing posters for saying what they want to say have a nerve and are promoting what many Americans and others in non-socialist countries are fighting against. You don't have to agree with the content of those racist or partisan posts you mention. We should be free to say what we want whether it's offensive to some people or not! Period.

Date of experience: November 18, 2019
Florida
1 review
24 helpful votes
Follow Louis P.
Unfollow Louis P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Terrible
December 25, 2013

Terrible. User generated content is wrong most of the time and the general forums are pretty much just a broadcast system for hate speech, racism, antisemitism, etc. It's not helpful and pretty much exists just for low lifes to argue woth each other about who they hate more.

Date of experience: December 25, 2013
Texas
1 review
12 helpful votes
Follow Steffi D.
Unfollow Steffi D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I was banned too
July 19, 2019

Was googling for pickled herring reviews and turned up a thread on this website that I had posted one post to a few years back - did not remember doing so but when I tried to register it said I was already registered!

Okay, logged in. Answered a post that said there was no source of picked herring in this-city. I said this-supermarket in this-city has picked herring in their deli case. Went back the next day to see what was going on to find out I was banned.

Guess they don't like pickled herring. Their loss.

Date of experience: July 19, 2019
New York
3 reviews
33 helpful votes
Follow Educated c.
Unfollow Educated c.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

The New York City Data is populated by real estate and development trolls, anti-rent regulation, "socialism," "red scare(s)!," what-have-you. It is also populated by right-wing trolls. There are very, very few real people. Most of them probably believe that by posting and posting they can sway politicians or "the public." Be that as it may, little of it is worth reading. In fact, there is a great deal of misinformation, likely deliberate.

Be advised, and do not take any of it seriously. There are also more than a few psychos - a great reason never to post anything yourself. Don't engage.

Date of experience: August 16, 2019
GB
1 review
22 helpful votes
Follow Cat v.
Unfollow Cat v.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Everyone just wants to get in a fight, and most of them don't even know what the hell they're talking about. 90% of the advice I saw on there was subjectively bad, objectively false, or very often both. Not a good place to get relocation advice, and the other subforums are even worse -- just wall-to-wall trolls.

Date of experience: July 15, 2017
Texas
1 review
11 helpful votes
Follow Carl R.
Unfollow Carl R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Posts about rape
February 11, 2019

There are very disturbing posts on this site about rape and when I pointed these out, I was banned. The moderators did not give a reason. They also apparently don't delete the disturbing posts of these individuals. This would not be allowed anywhere else on the internet.

Date of experience: February 11, 2019
Florida
1 review
17 helpful votes
Follow Patrick M.
Unfollow Patrick M.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

The site is obviously administered by the more enlightened, tolerant, inclusive, loving-left and will BAN anyone who, no matter how polite and respectful their post, expresses an opinion contrary to liberal narratives.

Date of experience: August 7, 2017
Washington
3 reviews
42 helpful votes
Follow Steele D.
Unfollow Steele D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

You WILL be banned for the most inane reasons. Every post will be monitored apparently and anyone can and will be reported for anything of the mod doesn't catch it first. Yes I am still a member have been one for nearly 10 years and getting ready to go on my second multi year sabbatical from them. I wrote the mods publicly in a thread this morning letting them know they are dismantling their own kingdom with their self righteousness. You cannot say anything there without it being taken wrong. Even when I asked a man who appeared to be contemplating jumping from a bridge near my home,, I just asked to clarify if he were really serious about this or just super upset for the moment and was punished by a mod about it as a personal attack. When I was actually VERY CONCERNED.

Date of experience: December 28, 2016
New York
1 review
18 helpful votes
Follow Ana S.
Unfollow Ana S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

If you arrive as a new user and are not a MAGA person they will virtually destroy you. I posted and 5 minutes later a creep that clearly did not read my post attacked me. Many followed and called me troll, it felt like a gang attack just because my ideas are not pro Trump. The moderator (s) are pro-Trump and should be removed immediately since they are bias and not impartial. My post only lasted 10 hours, as it was deleted because it did not align with the far right. If the poster abandons the thread, it may last a little longer but if you defend your idea, it will be gone very quickly. This site clearly violates the freedom of speech and the proper authorities should get involved and shut it down.

Date of experience: August 29, 2020
Florida
1 review
28 helpful votes
Follow Thomas P.
Unfollow Thomas P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

The right wingers are the only ones who seem to have free speech. Lean left? The moderators will find a reason to suspend you. Ibginnie is one of the worst moderators. Hates any view other than pro Trump. A real scum bag troll.

Date of experience: August 31, 2020
Missouri
1 review
21 helpful votes
Follow Anne R.
Unfollow Anne R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

All you have to do to get banned is say anything remotely conservative and critical of liberal caused and it's not IF but WHEN your account gets out down. You don't have to do anything vicious or mean, just have your own conservative views and not only will you be banned but you have no opportunity for self defense. The moderators are the ones who are rude and derisive. Too bad too because it could be a helpful site.

Date of experience: August 18, 2020
Arizona
1 review
22 helpful votes
Follow Julia D.
Unfollow Julia D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

City-Data is essentially a propaganda/disinformation site for realtors, frequented by a paid content generators and thuggish paid moderators. It tends to be fairly racist, they are looking to steer white buyers to their preferred realtors. Seriously think it should be investigated for discriminatory practices. If you're looking for input on locations, best to use friends and family and actual real people. Most of the frequent posters there are either realtors lying about who they are and what they do for a living, or paid content generators. This is not the place to go to if you're seriously looking to relocate.

Date of experience: November 3, 2019
Colorado
1 review
98 helpful votes
Follow Vicky E.
Unfollow Vicky E.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

This is really just a racist site pretending to be a legit forum. Moderators will censor and shut down any views that don't fall in line with their racist views. Very far right fascist tendencies. I was banned because I called out a member who was posting multiple stories about black on white crime. I asked him why he was so obsessed with stories about black on white crime and was called a communist who supports white genocide. The moderator banned me hours later for "trolling". The member remains active and continues to rant about anti white racism and white genocide.

Date of experience: November 14, 2019
Texas
3 reviews
12 helpful votes
Follow Heather D.
Unfollow Heather D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I spoke out against the EarthQuest billion dollar theme park scam on City-Data. I came to the discussion with piles of mainstream media articles, court records and more about the project and the obvious scammers behind it. Don Allen Holbrook, the brainchild behind the scam that made over 1.2 million dollars, sued newspapers, journalists and all the taxpayers in Texas that dared to speak out against it and little old me, Soapboxmom. Holbrook got his a$$ handed to him in court. The taxpayers in Texas are out 24 million dollars for a theme park that will never get further than a pile of pretty drawings. City-Data is a joke!

+1
Date of experience: January 17, 2021
Illinois
1 review
21 helpful votes
Follow A R.
Unfollow A R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I was banned from City-data after I made a truthful post about working with mental illness. I spoke of my several mental health issues in response to a post by a schizophrenic who has been unemployed for some time. I guess that my life was too much to handle for the mods, as I for banned for being a "TROLL". Oh well. But I did like it that the site had a lot.of features for a message board (blogs, customizable profiles, etc.)

Date of experience: November 3, 2017

Overview

City-Data.com has a rating of 1.2 stars from 285 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with City-Data.com most frequently mention right wing, politics forum and conspiracy theories. City-Data.com ranks 1204th among Real Estate sites.

service
38
value
36
quality
40