• Maybelline New York

Maybelline New York

Is this your business?

Is this your business?

Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and manage your listing.

Claim Your Business
Is this your business?

Overview

Maybelline New York has a rating of 4.29 stars from 42 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Maybelline New York ranks 23rd among Cosmetics sites.

  • Service
    8
  • Value
    9
  • Shipping
    8
  • Returns
    8
  • Quality
    9
Positive reviews (last 12 months): 75%
Positive
3
Neutral
0
Negative
1
2
See all photos
How would you rate Maybelline New York?
Top Positive Review

“My Favorite For So Many Years Now”

Marcia B.
5/16/23

If you've ever over-tweezed your eyebrows like I did years ago, you'll appreciate the beveled tip of this pencil. It effortlessly creates the appearance of thicker brows. However, it's not ideal for drawing fine, wispy lines to mimic individual brow hairs. If that's what you're looking for, this pencil may not meet your expectations. On the bright side, it lasts a long time if you don't twist it up too far, as excessive exposure can cause it to snap off. I used to buy it from various stores that stocked Maybelline cosmetics, but it suddenly became unavailable everywhere. Thankfully, I found it on Amazon, where I've been purchasing it for many years.

Top Critical Review

“Nasty”

Christina Z.
6/10/23

How is that dumb commercial supposed to make us want to buy Mabeline? You guys need to get it together, This is so stupid.

Reviews (42)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Thumbnail of user marciab472
4 reviews
2 helpful votes
May 16th, 2023

If you've ever over-tweezed your eyebrows like I did years ago, you'll appreciate the beveled tip of this pencil. It effortlessly creates the appearance of thicker brows. However, it's not ideal for drawing fine, wispy lines to mimic individual brow hairs. If that's what you're looking for, this pencil may not meet your expectations. On the bright side, it lasts a long time if you don't twist it up too far, as excessive exposure can cause it to snap off. I used to buy it from various stores that stocked Maybelline cosmetics, but it suddenly became unavailable everywhere. Thankfully, I found it on Amazon, where I've been purchasing it for many years.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user audrianah
5 reviews
0 helpful votes
February 2nd, 2022
Verified purchase

MAYBELLINE NEW YORK FIT me Matte + Poreless Normal to oily liquid foundation with clay. Great foundation that mattifies and refines your pores. Matches your natural tone, and Natural seamless finish. I like how smooth the foundation glides onto my face. It really blurs my pores and has a smooth finish.

Thumbnail of user christinazimmerman4141
1 review
0 helpful votes
June 10th, 2023

How is that dumb commercial supposed to make us want to buy Mabeline? You guys need to get it together, This is so stupid.

Thumbnail of user gracel177
1 review
0 helpful votes
August 22nd, 2020

One of the favorite brands. Recently bought a palette from Maybelline New York. This palette is amazing. High pigmentation, natural shades, odorless.

Thumbnail of user renayab
1 review
18 helpful votes
May 11th, 2020

Best choice brand. I adore their mascaras for they are very practical. I wear it everyday and I have never had any problems with my skin or some allergies. Recommend it to everyone.

Thumbnail of user phoebed29
5 reviews
2 helpful votes
September 26th, 2022

Maybelline is a good brand of quality cosmetics. Maybelline products are considered one of the expensive brands, but I would not say so. The products are quality and worth their money. Each product is well thought out from the design of the container to the composition of the product, which is very good.

Thumbnail of user sofiaj28
1 review
1 helpful vote
August 5th, 2020

I had a mascara "Lash sensational" in a pink tube. It was rather good. Though the very stick looks strange at first sight, it was rather convenient in use. But for me, loreal is better.

Thumbnail of user courteneyc4
7 reviews
2 helpful votes
November 27th, 2020

For several years, I have been using Maybelline's original mascara! I tried other brands, various brushes for eye lashes, etc. I still go back to my Maybelline, the original. It's smooth, there are no clumps, and you can put on a little or a tonne, and it still looks amazing.

Thumbnail of user brendag1603
1 review
2 helpful votes
April 24th, 2023

Its sickening as a woman to know you are using Dylan Mulvaney the trans to promote maybeline products. Absolutely sickening you cant use a REAL woman.
I always use your products, well NOT ANYMORE. And neither will anyone i know.
Goodbye Maybeline

Thumbnail of user pennyg153
1 review
12 helpful votes
June 26th, 2020

The brand I use everytime I put on make up. However, my favorite product is mascara. It is always fresh and looks great on eyelashes.

Thumbnail of user douniek
1 review
0 helpful votes
October 20th, 2021

Their lip glosses are fantastic. The range of colours is so broad that it is sometimes hard rto make the right choice. Remarkable brand!

Products used:
lip gloss

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user steffia2
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
January 21st, 2022

Excellent cosmetics. I like it for its quality, price and colours. The delivery is always fast. Thanks

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user alandras1
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
October 2nd, 2020

Superstay matte ink liquid lipstick makeup, coffee edition is my choice. This is so cool, I recommend all girls to try it. It is truly superstay.

Thumbnail of user makhpiyaheinnsbsr
1 review
0 helpful votes
April 18th, 2024

The eyeliner is good, but there are some issues. Color rich black, felt tip. Not very durable. No smell, no cracking.

Tip for consumers:
not for everyone

Products used:
maybelline HIPER Precise all Day

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user kayaj9
2 reviews
9 helpful votes
January 10th, 2022

LASH SENSATIONAL SKY HIGH WASHABLE MASCARA MAKEUP - I tried this one, and I can say it's definitely my choice.

Products used:
Mascara

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user ronana7
7 reviews
1 helpful vote
October 2nd, 2020

Maybelline New York is my favorite brand for cosmetics and I am using since 1 year. I love all the products of this brand. Quality is excellent and stays for a longer time. Quantity is superb and worth the money. Recommended.

Thumbnail of user olivias324
1 review
0 helpful votes
June 4th, 2021

I used several of their mascaras. Generally, all were good. They make teh lashes look thick and beautiful.

Products used:
different mascaras

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user nocola
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
May 20th, 2020

I buy cosmetics of this brand quite frequently. I like lipsticks and mascara and some bb-creams. My skin feels good with these cosmetics.

Thumbnail of user maryw1737
1 review
0 helpful votes
January 28th, 2021

Hi! I already tried baby skin pore eraser and when I used this I literally have a baby skin because it made my skin poreless! And it works just fine for me!

Thumbnail of user dulced19
18 reviews
271 helpful votes
November 29th, 2023

I bought a foundation Fit Me! In a nearby store. In general, I was satisfied, the texture is good. But by the end of the day, it drops a bit. Plus, there were no testers in the store so I could try it on my skin, so I had to choose approx. But this is the store's problem, not the brand's. As an cheaper tonal foundation, quite a good option.

Thumbnail of user karenl2562
1 review
0 helpful votes
June 16th, 2021

The mascara collosal in a grey glossy tube is so great. Besides, it includes some sparkles that shine on my eyelashes.

Products used:
mascara collosal

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user valeriag6
39 reviews
47 helpful votes
April 19th, 2019

HOY EN DIA LOS PRODUCTOS SON DECENTES, NO EXCELENTES Y CON LA LLEGADA DE PRODUCTOS CHINOS MUY BARATOS Y DE CALIDAD DECENTE, NO ES NECESARIO PAGAR LOS PRECIOS EXCESIVOS QUE LA MARCA COMERCIALIZA. DEBE TRATAR DE MEJORAR LA CALIDAD PARA PODER CONTINUAR SIENDO UNA MARCA RECONOCIDA O VA A TERMINAR SIENDO OLVIDADA COMO OTRAS TANTAS

Thumbnail of user lunaa10
1 review
0 helpful votes
August 17th, 2020

I tried Superstay crayon lipstick, matte longwear lipstick makeup. I like matte lipsticks more than lip glosses. It is indeed superstay. I used it just twice during teh day to renew the color.

Thumbnail of user chantouk
1 review
0 helpful votes
October 13th, 2020

I like to use their products. Especially, I like their lip glosses. Recently, I've bought "LIFTER GLOSS LIP GLOSS MAKEUP WITH HYALURONIC ACID". It is affordable. Was delivered quickly.

Thumbnail of user leannh1
1 review
12 helpful votes
December 19th, 2013

I cannot find a retractable eyebrow pencil in Medium Brown. I can in a regular pencil, but I don't like it. A woman working with makeup supplies said a lot of colors are be-ing discontinued for the younger generation. It is not right. Not everyone likes to walk around with black eyes!

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

About the business

Makeup and cosmetics for women. Makeup tips, makeup looks, how to videos and tutorials featuring best makeup foundation, eyeshadow, mascara, eyeliner, lipstick, blush & brushes.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Maybelline New York?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Maybelline New York?

Is this your business?

Claim your listing for free to respond to reviews, update your profile and manage your listing.

Claim Your Business

Related forum posts

I haven't had much luck ordering blindly online, especially foundation. I'd like to be...

Why are cruelty-free products important to you?

Can you share why cruelty-free products are important to you?

Which brands have eco-friendly packaging?

Would love to help out the environment while I shop