business logo of Firstleaf

FirstleafReviews 11

1.6

On Sitejabber, businesses may not offer incentives or pay to remove reviews. Learn more about our Review Guidelines.

How would you rate Firstleaf?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star

Firstleaf Reviews Summary

The company has garnered a largely negative reputation, primarily due to deceptive subscription practices and poor customer service. Customers frequently express frustration over unexpected charges and difficulties in canceling subscriptions, often feeling misled by the initial promotional offers. While some reviews highlight prompt shipping and satisfactory initial experiences with wine quality, these positives are overshadowed by complaints about mediocre product offerings and inadequate support when issues arise. Overall, the sentiment reflects a significant disconnect between customer expectations and the company's service delivery, indicating a pressing need for improved transparency and customer care.

This summary is generated by AI, based on text from customer reviews

service
17
value
16
shipping
16
returns
15
quality
15
This company does not typically respond to reviews

We monitor reviews for authenticity

New Jersey
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Mike B.
Unfollow Mike B.
Share Review
Report Review

Worst customer service
August 18, 2025

I Never had notification of order or followup as specified by there customer service. Order contained sweet wines which we do not drink. Notified them on Aug. 10th order did not ship until late Aug 11th. Even though it was thier error they still went and charged me a $25 restocking fee for a glitch in their system.

Date of experience: August 12, 2025
Pennsylvania
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow James D.
Unfollow James D.
Share Review
Report Review

I reached out to the customer service with a concern and was immediately met with blame and insult. The customer service rep Ella J has been of no assistance and should be relieved from her position.

Date of experience: May 26, 2024
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi James, we are so sorry to hear about your experience with customer service! We want to make this right ASAP. Would you be able to reach out to us at service@firstleaf.com so we can get more information and find a solution that works for you?

Colorado
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Alicia C.
Unfollow Alicia C.
Share Review
Report Review

Not flexible
February 20, 2024

This site is not flexible in accounting for conflicting work schedules and has the audacity to charge you for a refund if your work schedule happens to collide with the delivery times and dates. Absolutely horrible and not working class or student friendly.

Date of experience: February 20, 2024
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

While we’re required by law to make sure someone 21+ signs for the wine, we completely understand that it’s difficult to always be around when the carrier comes. That said, if you won't be home to receive it, we can certainly send your order to your local hold location or a business address if that works better for you. You can also sign up for FedEx delivery manager to request a weekend delivery. If you would like to give us another shot we'd be happy to help with any of these options!

South Carolina
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow June P.
Unfollow June P.
Share Review
Report Review

I canceled twice on the website and then sent an email stating I had canceled twice before but they were sending me emails stating they are sending me a new order. I stated I would not pay for any further deliveries, a delivery was left on my doorway without me signing and I was charged $215 on my credit card. I called when I received the bill and was told yes they saw I tried to cancel but it is not official, because I did not receive an email from them stating they closed the account. Total FRAUD

Date of experience: August 18, 2023
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Apologies for the confusion regarding the cancellation process. It does seem you logged on to your account and attempted to cancel however the updates to your account were never confirmed. In order to make changes to your account we do ask that you save changes in order for them to take effect. Your account has been closed as of August 2023 and you will not be receiving any future shipments unless you reinstate your account with us.

California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Laura K.
Unfollow Laura K.
Share Review
Report Review

I placed an order at 9pm on a Monday using an first-time customer promo code that offered 12 bottles for $69.90. I woke up at 7:30am the next morning to find that the company had send me another order confirmation email for an order that was supposedly placed in the wee hours of Tuesday morning, this time in the amount of $198.32. I never placed or authorized this order, even though the order page shays, "you checked out on 5/9/23." When I called the company to have them cancel this order, they said that the order was already fulfilled, which means it would have to have happened between 1am and 7am, and that there would be a $25 restocking fee to cancel it. I immediately canceled by membership on the 9th of May, and the membership cancellation page stated that the membership wouldn't be completely cancelled until July. I've never heard of a company that refuses to cancel your membership the very month you initiate the cancellation. This is how the company makes their money, through predatory practices like these.

Date of experience: May 9, 2023
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi Laura, we're so sorry to hear about your frustration with the restocking fee! It looks like while changing the date of your order there was some confusion regarding which order you were changing. We've gone ahead and waived the restocking fee for you and have completely canceled your second order as it seems it was a mistake. You should see a refund in full within 5-7 business days. We also want to let you know that once you cancel your account it is canceled immediately. Your account was closed as of 12:01:55 PM on 5/9/23. You should have received a confirmation email shortly after cancelling. If you have any other questions please do not hesitate to reach out at service@firstleaf.club.

California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Ben R.
Unfollow Ben R.
Share Review
Report Review

Trial is a scam
November 3, 2022

They lure you in with a discounted trial box. Try the wide for $40. We shipped the box to friends so they could try the wine. They opened 3 bottles. Said 2 were not good but the third was ok.

We tried one, took the first sip and couldn't drink the rest. Wine was not good.

Less than a month I see a charge for $109 on my credit card, then next day I get an email saying my next box has been delivered.

As far as I was aware, I didn't want any more wine from this company.

I called and emailed and said I didn't know it was a club and I want to cancel and return the wine. They don't take returns from what customer service said.

I told them "wouldn't you want to take the wine back and have a happy customer rather than them writing you a bad review" and they didn't seem to care.

" I apologize that we cannot meet your request.

We can no longer give refunds if an order is marked as delivered in the tracking information.

We take your feedback seriously as it is our most valuable tool, and I will be sure to share it with our team.

Please let us know if you have any additional concerns.
Cheers,

Cyril"

So basically, don't order any wine if you don't want to be a member of the club. If you want 6 bottles of below average wine for $109 then sign up. Or just go anywhere and buy 6 bottles of wine for $10 each and BOOM! $49 for something else.

I would not recommend them to anyone.

Date of experience: November 3, 2022
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi Ben we apologize for any confusion! We do have the option for customers to purchase wine without signing up for the subscription, however you specifically signed up with our introductory order to the club. We believe in transparency and communication with our members and always let you know the subscription is recurring before checkout. In order to ensure members see the selection for each delivery (and have time to cancel if needed), we send a “rate and preview” email 10 days prior to each shipment. We also send a second email before the wine is in route confirming the shipment as well. Once the order has been delivered it is too late to cancel the order for a full refund. We're so sorry to hear you didn't like the wine you tried in the first shipment, that isn't the experience we wanted you to have. At Firstleaf we offer a store credit for any wine a member dislikes. We can confirm your subscription was canceled as of 10/31/22. Please let us know if you have any other questions.

Pennsylvania
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow April M.
Unfollow April M.
Share Review
Report Review

Ordered trial box. Waited 3 weeks for my box to be delivered. Finally called to see where my order was and it wasn't until then, that they informed me that it was broken in transit. No one bothered to communicate that to me proactively while I waited patiently and loyally to give company a chance. Upon communication. Eunice the customer service representative was very apologetic, agreed to refund me, and even replace my box for my inconvenience. I confirmed my address with her, but then this Ella J. Denied a shipment of a new box at no charge and proceeded to tell me to wait for my "next shipment" of wine that I wouldnt get to choose and double the cost of introductory price. I sent screenshots of the previous reps satisfactory resolution to Ella J. She said she would move the date back for next shipment but would not make up for lack of communication from FirstLeaf on my delivery, adhere to previous reps satisfactory agreement with me, and did not give the list of my wine I originally wanted and was still going to charge me for them after all this back and forth and waiting being said and done. I would not recommend this company's customer service if anything doesn't go perfect. They will not help you.

Date of experience: July 27, 2022
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi April, we apologize for the miscommunication here! We've updated your account email to the email address that works best for you. We can also confirm you have been refunded in full for your original order and a second order has been sent out free of cost. We are so glad we were able to find a solution that works for you. If you have any questions going forward feel free to reach out at service@firstleaf.club!

New Jersey
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Roman C.
Unfollow Roman C.
Share Review
Report Review

This business is scamming retired peoples.( all customers)
If customer decide it return item ( Wine)
This business will not accept return

Date of experience: January 3, 2022
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi Roman we apologize for any confusion! We always send a reminder a week before just in case you have to cancel a shipment, if it's in transit we can request a return to sender and process a refund once it's returned. Unfortunately, once an order has been delivered we are unable to process a refund. We try to be as transparent as possible and send you several emails ahead of time just in case you do have to cancel, or even return the order before delivery. As always, we are more than happy to offer a store credit for any wines you dislike once you've tried them. You can view our full refund policy on our website here: https://help.firstleaf.club/hc/en-us/articles/115011925068-Refund-Policy

Massachusetts
4 reviews
6 helpful votes
Follow Jase H.
Unfollow Jase H.
Share Review
Report Review

Soon after I signed up for this club I realized it didn't make sense for me to belong to clubs with life matters making it difficult. I only made a couple orders. I can say my short experience with them was positive. They shipped very promptly. I've enjoyed most of the wines, but have really only had two that I'd buy again. They cancelled without question or delay when I requested they end my membership. All in all, a totally fine experience.

Date of experience: February 23, 2020
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi Jase, thanks for taking the time to write this review! We're glad you liked the overall experience. Since your review we've updated our wine concierge service. We now have a larger team trained to go over your wines and help you narrow down your tastes. This service along with our algorithm can help improve recommendations and make sure you receive the wines you really love!

California
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
Follow Eve E.
Unfollow Eve E.
Share Review
Report Review

I live in California and usually stay with California wine. The first leaf subscription includes some imported wine. I thought it doesn't hurt to try because the first subscription is cheap. Then the bottle of wine from Spain blew my mind. Instead of staying with Cab and Merlot, I'm going to try more red blend now. I brought a bottle with similar profile to share with family and they loved it too! So happy about it and I'm gonna order a case of it.

Date of experience: December 9, 2019
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Hi Eve, we are so glad we were able to help you discover some new wines! That's what we're all about here at Firstleaf. We are so glad you like our service and hope you love future shipments just as much!

California
3 reviews
2 helpful votes
Follow Manny O.
Unfollow Manny O.
Share Review
Report Review

Got an email about receiving a few bottles of wine for free if I paid shipping and handling, so I did. A few weeks later I was enjoying 7 bottles of Import and like clock work I get a few more every 3 months with a minimal payment. No complaints, all Imports and I get to add a review for every bottle.

Date of experience: August 5, 2018
Firstleaf -. Firstleaf Rep
over a year old

Thanks for the 5 stars Manny! We're glad you enjoyed the wine. Don't forget to rate the wines in your account. After rating just 3 bottles, our recommendations are at a 96% accuracy rate!