I honestly thought it was a mistake that the seller had 'new with tags' on her listing once I received the boots. I took a few quick pictures and 'opened a case' for return expecting Ebay or Amazon type professionalism and service. What I received instead was the seller demeaning me, insisting that the boots may have had dust on them but I only needed to wipe them off, calling me a liar, etc. I was horrified. I didn't acknowledge her insults but posted more pictures after reading these reviews, hoping to prove my point. Haven't heard anything from PM yet but the seller told me to never buy from her again. I'll stick with Ebay and never ever ever again will I risk being scammed by dishonest people at Poshmark. $101.00 of my hard earned money in the hands of a thief. Sickening. (photo is different shots of the marks... many of them, most noticable are worn and dirty soles) This was supposed to be a gift.