Moon Magic has a rating of 3.8 stars from 511 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Moon Magic most frequently mention customer service, wrong size, and beautiful jewelry. Moon Magic ranks 9th among Custom Jewelry sites.
Seriously obsessed! My first ring from Moon Magic was Moonstone Flourish, and I just recently tried their new floating design, the invisible band gives it this cool, magical vibe. Beautiful craftsmanship and the energy of these stones is simply amazing!
Purchased a lovely ring - "rose gold" rubbed away within 3 months of normal wear. When I messaged about this, they said it was normal wear and tear and outside of their return window so nothing to be done. Very disappointed and will never shop these products again. I would expect $20 for these rings, not $120.
After I threatened to bring the matter of my very tarnished ring to the BBB and/or file a chargeback with my credit card, the company finally responded and said they would send me a new ring. The ring I received was much, much nicer than the original that I received. Not only was it the right colour (and not tarnished to a very dark brown), but the stone was also much shinier and cleaner. I am a lot happier with the new ring. However, I would still not recommend this company to anyone. Their quality control is clearly lacking and their customer service could use some work. You could buy better quality costume jewellery at a fraction of the price too. I shouldn't have to threaten a chargeback for them to replace a defective and unwearable ring. I am still blocked from all their social media because I posted my displeasure on it (the comment was also removed or hidden).
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
The worst customer service I have ever received from a company. When I ordered a set of rings and they arrived, they weren't as beautiful as the images but I was fairly satisfied. However after just 3-4 wears, one of the rings turned completely brown. The other ring was fine and made of the same material, so I assumed either their quality control was lacking or the very tarnished ring was defective. When I contacted the company, they stated it was over the 30 day return window. They offered 50% off a new ring, which I rejected because I didn't want to pay around $60+ to replace the defective ring. After this, the company refused to do anything about the issue and offer a replacement/refund. I even offered to resend the very tarnished ring. For something that is pricier but the quality of costume jewellery (or worse!) I am very displeased. I will be filing a chargeback with my credit card and a case with the BBB. Many people have issues with this company and I will tell anyone I can not to do business with them. Very shady, unprofessional company.
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
I paid extra for 2 day shipping. Originally it was suppose to arrive on the 16th, it didn't arrive until the 23rd. By coincidence, my partner purchased from Moon Magic the same night I placed my order (for our anniversary) her package arrived the next day and she didn't pay extra for shipping. I reached out on the 19th asking for some assistance on the whereabouts of my package. Customer support replies by email the tracking number in which I already had access to, that was my reply back to customer support. After waiting more than 24 hours for a response on the 21st I emailed customer support to begin the process for a return, to no avail. On the 23rd, I emailed customer support again to start the process of returning the 4 rings. I had to pay for shipping to send back the unwanted items. It is the 27th and I am still waiting for a response to see if I will actually be refunded.
I purchase the bundle of Nymph ring and Sovereign band. Gorgeous set! I didn't know moonstone in person and it looks like a relative of opal, gorgeous stone! I'm super happy with my purchase, and even with the wait, it worth it, it took about a month since I made my purchase to finally get the right size with me.
First I ordered size 5 and I'm 5.5, sadly it was too small, so I had to return them and wait another 2 weeks to get them back here in Canada. They exchange them with no hassles at all, super quick response and amazing customer service. Be aware you need to pay your shipping back to them and they will send them to you for free again.
SIZING: If you're in between sizes go up, at least in my case, there was no way I could wear size 5, size 6 it's a tiny bit loose, but nothing that breaks the deal. They won't come off.
The bad: the same risk purchasing anything to wear on internet, it may fit it may not. Just be aware you need to pay the shipping to them, they send back to you for free even when it's a exchange. And yes, waiting times, specially if you're not in the States, they send through DHL, but customs and processing is not up to Moonmagic. Just be realistic and patient, trust me it worth it. I love my pieces and I will purchase again soon.
The good! They worth it, they're very well made, beautiful designs, classy and NOT look cheap at all. They drag attention because they're very pretty.
Great customer service, they answered back very quickly, no hassles at all!
I will add some pieces in the future.
Area of opportunity for Moonmagic: Half sizes, that would be ideal.
Hello Eloisa,
We are incredibly grateful that you took the time out to leave us this note and your beautiful picture. We are very happy that you like our services. We are here to help and always making sure that we meet all the customer's requirements.
Thank you very much for your suggestion and we are looking into eventually stocking smaller, larger and half sizes in the future.
All the best.
Moon Magic
I ordered a ring and I am very pleased with it, I loved it even more when I recieved it than in pictures. I selected an international shippment and the costumer service was very helpful. Will buy again!
Products used:
Jewelry
I love my ring so was gutted when I lost a stone from it. I contacted the team and they immediately arranged for a replacement. The service wad impeccable. You won't be disappointed with this brand
Hello Katie,
We are incredibly grateful that you took the time out to leave us this note. We are very happy that you like our services. We are here to help and always making sure that we meet all the customer's requirements.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
I can't thank enough to Moon Magic, they definitely know how to beat expectations, postal service in Mexico can be a total nightmare and they really made everything in their power to get mu product out to me and made my experience perfect. And the rings and earrings are just PERFECT, in loved!, THANK YOU!
Products used:
Rings and earrings
Hello Yvonne,
We are incredibly grateful for the 5-stars! Moon Magic put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the hard work we put in every day!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
Excellent response time and very helpful with fixing my order. Will be back to buy more of there amazing products my partner loves the style and uniqueness of Moon Magic's jewellery
Hello Jake,
We are thrilled to have you as part of the Moon Magic family! Thank you for sharing your kind words with us. It means the world to us and to our entire team!
Best regards,
Moon Magic
My moonstone looks fake! It looks like a crystal that has been painted on by a sheer blue nail polish. I am so upset! They wont give you your money back but If they do its only 20 percent. DO NOT ORDER FROM THEM. I AM A REAL CUSTOMER, MAKING A REAL REVIEW. WE SHOULD MAKE A YELP SO THEY CAN NOT DELETE YOUR REVIEW ON THEIR WEBSITE. MY RING WAS 62 DOLLARS
Hello Krest,
Thank you for your feedback. Please note that no two rings look the same thanks to its natural gemstone beauty and unusual, untreated shape. Also, we are using only Authentic Rainbow Moonstones. If you don't like your ring you can return it for a full refund, however, a 20% refund is one of the options if you decide to keep the ring. We are very sorry for any inconvenience.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
All products are rated very highly on their website but it's hard to find reviews outside of theirs until I hit the Better Business Bureau website
JUST A WARNING: ALL SIGNS POINT TO A DISHONEST BUSINESS WITH INFERIOR PRODUCT.
Hello Donna,
As a company, we appreciate all the feedback that we receive from our customers, whether it's good or bad. We truly take all feedback into consideration and do our very best to make our customers overall Moon Magic experience better.
All our reviews on our website are real as well as the ones from the other websites. We are doing our best to satisfy every customer. Thank you for understanding.
All the best,
Moon Magic
A month ago I have purchased "Moonstone Ring - Harlow" as a surprise gift for a very special friend of mine. The ring was beautiful and it looked very similar to the images online. Unfortunately, the ring size was a little too small. So I reached out to customer service, and Anna from their team reached out to me to assist me with my exchange. I have been working in the customer service industry for over 14 years, and I have to say Anna was nothing less than AMAZING! She was very prompt with my emails and made sure that I had all the information that I need in order to make the exchange quickly and without any hassle. After about two weeks of me shipping the original ring back, I received my exchange, and it even looked more beautiful than the original one. My friend loves it, and I am beyond pleased with the assistance that I have received. Because of representatives like Anna, I will definitely be back to purchase more items from this website. Thank you very much Moon Magic team for the amazing ring, and keep up the great customer service that you have.
Hello Amin,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience. We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the hard work we put in every day.
Best regards,
Moon Magic
Horrible customer service. I have been trying to return my product for weeks due to poor quality. My numerous emails have gone unanswered. Purchase elsewhere or you will regret it.
Tip for consumers:
Since posting this complaint, I was assisted by customer service.
Hello Rochelle,
Thank you for taking the time to write us a review. We are truly happy to hear that you have been assisted as we are working around a clock to meet all our customers' expectations.
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I was super excited to see my moon magic package had arrived today. I ordered a raw aquamarine ring, an opal ring with 3 small opal stones, and a square cut moonstone ring. I was the most excited for the raw aquamarine ring. I was less than thrilled when I saw it however. It doesn't look raw, it has a smooth feel to it like it could have been tumbled. It doesn't even look real, it looks man made. My guess is that it was made with some sort of resin or something into a mold? On closer inspection of the ring I saw an air bubble in the stone. So I'm pretty mad honestly, I'm contacting the company to see if I can get my money back and send the rings back because after a guarantee that all gemstones are genuine real stones on the website they sent me a fake stone... for $60.00 soooo yeah. I'm not sure about the moonstone, that does look real to me. However the opal stones do not, I have seen plenty of real opal and plenty of fake opal and it looks off. I'm hoping that I can return these and get my money back, or get some reasonable explanation for why my aquamarine stone has an air bubble? But I don't know how else you would get a bubble inside of a rock
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
The customer service is perfect. They quickly respond to my inquiries and are patient to address the delivery problem I met. Nice purchase experience.
Hello Luna,
Thanks for leaving us such a wonderful review. We are thrilled that you loved your experience!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
Unfortunately as much as I love my ring for it's significance I have to say it does not wear well. My husband purchased this as my engagement ring after I picked it out in March 2019 and now December 2020 the Opal is so yellow and doesn't reflect the light like it once used to. So I'm not sure this ring is meant for everyday wear as advertised and I rarely even wear it anymore and haven't constantly for months. I don't shower with it on or let it get wet besides to clean it following the only cleaning instructions that were on the website back when I first got it, there are now instructions to not get the opal wet on the product website. The FAQ page cleaning instructions that I followed do not say this and don't mention anything about opal cleaning instructions. The diamonds are still beautiful (but have heard they lie about them being real diamonds so do your review), but unfortunately my husband is already talking about buying me an update not even two years later of inconstant wear because of how much the opal has changed to be so dull and yellow. I didn't want a traditional diamond ring and loved the opal and I'm really sad this didn't work. My band is from Noemie and is still so beautiful and sparkly so I'll probably just upgrade that instead.
This is the Soulmate ring which is one of their higher priced products.
I'm posting this here because they don't allow reviews on their FaceBook and it looks like they censor reviews on their website. Also it would not let me post pictures on their website. Very sketchy
Tip for consumers:
Don't believe the reviews on the website. They are censored which is illegal.
Products used:
Soulmate rose gold opal ring
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
Hello Sarah,
Thank you for sharing your feedback with us. We love to hear from happy fans, but listening to less than perfect reviews is critical for us to learn and grow. We value the perspective of EVERY Moon Magic shopper, and continually use your feedback to improve. We are truly sorry to hear that your beautiful Opal changed its color!
Please, reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
Bought a ring for my GF, had a slight blemish Jana was super awesome and helped me in the swapping process. GF 100% satisfied. Thank you Jana for your help.
Hello Ivan,
Thank you so much for the 5-stars. We are very happy that you like our services!
Kind Regards,
Moon Magic
Ordered earings, took 10 weeks, there was gum in the package not earrings. When complained they actually dared to tell me that they had no clue... cheaters and liars!
Tip for consumers:
do not ever purchase this $#*!
Products used:
none as it never arrived (at least not what i ordered)but gum
* Moon Magic attempted to help this customer through the Sitejabber Resolution Center, but the customer did not respond
I couldn't be happier with their service. They helped me choose my mother's ring and she absolutely loved it. My emails were answered in a timely manner and the package was delivered on time.
Hello Mery,
We are glad to hear that you are happy with our services. Thank you very much for your recommendation and your feedback.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Bought a necklace in memory of my mother. Spent days going back and forth beetween what company to buy from. I chose moon magic. I ordered the "14k" November birthstone necklace. When I received it the chain was diffrent then the one online. I sent a message and got told they had the wrong picture online... and sorry for the confusion they offered me 20% back. I said no thats not okay. As a company its up to them to be honest about their product. They then blamed it on the supplier and offered me 60% back... which I will get in 30 days. Still dosnt fix the problem. The same photo is on the site. And the description of the chain is still the same picture. So instead of being honest about their product they place the blame else where. Very unfair. I've never delt with a company that lies about their product to save money.
Don't order from this company.
Tip for consumers:
Don't buy. It's not as shown on the website and they will not hold them selves accountable. Instead you will be at fault and when you call them out on it they will then blame someone else.
Products used:
Necklace
Hello Kayla,
We always aim to deliver a great experience, and we are gutted when we don’t meet expectations. Thanks for taking the time to bring this to our attention. We will use the feedback to make us better and to ensure this doesn’t happen again.
We are working on updating images for this necklace, the issue will be fixed soon. Hope for your patience and understanding!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
If MOONMAGIC is really genuine- then I'm deeply sorry that someone in their team is STEALING and SWAPPING their genuine products for fake ones but I AM NOT going to allow myself to be CHEATED. I am extremely disappointed with the quality. This is all plastic- epoxy at its best. And the metal is RUSTY. How is this good vermile and how on earth are these gems. Most of all- HOW DID THIS COST ME 146 euros + 45 euros tax that's practically 200 euros for PLASTIC?!
I HAVE A NICKEL ALLERGY and you lot said you offer GENUINE PRODUCTS. So kindly let me SEE THEM.!
Tip for consumers:
BEWARE!!!! It is a scam!!!! Just look at these pictures !!!!!
Products used:
FAKE EARRINGS
Hello Maria,
Thank you for sharing your honest insights with the Moon Magic community. We take every review seriously, and continuously work to improve. Unfortunately, your issues with our jewelry surprise us as well. We stand behind our products and strive to make every bad situation right. Please accept our apologies for any disappointment your Moon Magic experience may have caused. We work hard to meet and exceed our customers’ expectations and bring a little bit of magic into their daily lives!
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution.
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic
I ordered a ring for my daughter's birthday and it arrived one week later in Ireland. Very impressed all round with the quality of the jewellery in person and the speed of shipping.
Tip for consumers:
Great value fast shipping overseas
Products used:
Lania Ring and Twinkling Band
I purchased the moonstone supernal necklace for my girlfriend 6 months ago. While sitting in bed it simply falls out of the necklace without warning. There is nothing bent or broken by warranty it's a defective item and should be replaced. Moon magic instead denies responsibility saying it's natural wear and tear. If you don't want the companies self admitted cheap jewelry don't buy moon magic as it will magically fall apart and they will just claim it's because their products are cheap or imply it's the paying customers fault for damaging the product they paid for. They won't even ask for pictures to show who is really at fault. This really does show moon magic doesn't care about customers or honoring their warranty but only for your money. They've also removed their contact phone number so they don't have to hear from you. Don't buy moon magic if you don't want to waste your money and have a quality product to show for it that will actually stand the test of time because you won't find it with moon magic and they don't care as long as you pay up!
Hello Jimmy,
We appreciate you taking the time to leave us a review and we are truly sorry to hear that you have experienced such an issue with your item. At Moon Magic we highly value customer satisfaction and please be confident that your feedback has been passed over to the quality control team․ We are checking every single complaint even if it's outside warranty. To further clarify, warranty covers all manufacturer defects in material or workmanship but does not cover natural wear and tear or stone loss. Our jewelry is designed to withstand the normal rigors of modern life, but keep in mind that they are still made from precious metals and delicate stones so we strongly recommend following the jewelry care guides we provide to make your items last years.
Please reconnect with our customer service for any questions you might have. Hope for your patience and understanding!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
I purchased one of their necklaces as a gift for my girlfriend.
I have to say the necklace is nowhere near the quality Moon Magic made us expect.
I am not a jewlery person. However, I am an avid watch collector focusing on the restoration of vintage pieces.
I can proudly say through years of handling watches, I gained quite some knowledge on precious metals.
The silver necklace itself is of low quality.
The surface finishing is not uniform on areas where it clearly should be.
The clasp does not use enough silver on a few pressure points, which adds to the poor quality overall.
Also the Moonstone, which is the main gem; is not as clear and transparent as the pictures they showed.
Considering the value of a moonstone is largely decided by those two aspects, all I can say is that they used a top quality stone for the presentation piece, and a worse stone for the actual product.
Some say Moon Magic is a scam. I don't think so.
They used real silver, and the Moonstone; apart from the quality is genuine.
However, they seem to lack the kind of craftsmanship required. And only see their jewelry as just a source of profit.
Products used:
'Supernal' necklace, sterling silver chain, moonstone pendant held by sterling silver holder, holder decorated with miniature topaz stones.
Hello Earl,
Thank you for sharing your honest insights with the Moon Magic community. We take every review seriously, and continuously work to improve.
We are truly sorry to hear that you are not happy with your purchase.
Please reconnect with our customer service department to discuss your options for a smooth and equitable solution!
Best Regards,
Moon Magic
10/10 Would shop here again
10/10 Would recommend to family and friends
10/10 Customer service & product quality
-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-~-
Moon Magic has exceeded my expectations in all ways! I ordered the Moon Shell Necklace in Silver, Flora Necklace in Gold then the Gloss Necklace in Rose gold (fell in love with these products as soon as I saw them). When I received my oder, I noticed that there was a slight defect, so I emailed customer service right away - I explained my problem and provided pictures. They were super quick to respond and their customer service was exceptional! I had the pleasure of talking to Marijana, who was very friendly and understanding. Within moments of our emails, she rectified my order. I received my package and I am MORE than happy with my products! It is refreshing to speak to a company that values their customers. :) P.s. I think it is super great that they plant 1 tree for each piece of jewelry sold (good to know my purchase made a difference) :)
Tip for consumers:
They're legitimate and you get exactly what you order! I am very happy purchasing from them and I would definitely do it again for personal or gift shopping! :)
Products used:
Moon Shell Necklace in Silver
Flora Necklace in Gold
Gloss Necklace in Rose gold
Hello Angela,
Thanks for being part of the Moon Magic community. We are incredibly grateful that you took the time out to leave us this note and share your lovely picture. We're very glad to see that you are in love with our services. We put customer experience and satisfaction as our priority, and your review reaffirms the hard work we put in every day.
All the best,
Moon Magic
Ordered a ring, now 2 of them. It came fast and its very very beautiful! The customer service is beyond amazing as well! Very happy customer here and highly recommend this pretty jewelry!
Tip for consumers:
I'm a new buyer so I hadn't done much yet. The best for me was the fast delivery and the customer service. The shipping did catch me off guard however. After I placed my order it was tracked until a certain point, was told to urgently send shipping $ to have the package cross the line. It wasn't expected but its okay, was about 30 for shipping. My ring also came damaged but with the great customer service they cleared that up VERY promptly. I'm very happy with my purchase! Thank you all!
Products used:
Ring
7 days and 27 emails later and nothing is resolved and they have terrible communication with multiple typos. I've never been so frustrated with a customer service rep before. Offers me 50% off for a new ring in my price range of $100 and it can't be anything on sale. EVERYTHING IN MY PRICE RANGE WAS ON SALE! Then I brought this up to them and she told me I could use it on sale items THEN I send her a ring I liked THEN she tells me she messed up and you CAN'T
Hello Melanie,
Please accept our apologies for any disappointment your Moon Magic experience may have caused. We work hard to meet and exceed our customers’ expectations and bring a little bit of magic into their daily lives. Unfortunately, items worn beyond 30 days are not eligible for return or exchange, as outlined in our warranty.
I saw that our agent offered you two options 50% off a new item or your personal code of 15% off. Those are the best options we can give when the order is out of warranty. I am very sorry for any confusion.
Kind regards,
Moon Magic
Since 2016, our mission has been to design jewelry that is as powerful and meaningful as the ones who wear it.
We believe that everyone deserves jewelry that goes beyond the surface. That’s why we handpick each gemstone not just for its beautiful gleam, but for its unique energy and potential for self-expression and healing.
✓ We use 100% authentic, ethically sourced gemstones that are independently tested by GIA (Gemological Institute Of America)
✓ Each piece is designed right here in-house, ensuring nothing but originality in every piece
✓ When it comes to quality, we don't compromise - we use the finest premium metals & have a strict quality control in place
✓ 1.8+ million followers across socials & 500k customers and counting...
✓ Beautiful, gift-ready packaging
Note from our founder - Laura:
Since 2016, Moon Magic has been creating beautiful, high-quality, and affordable jewelry that taps into the powerful energies of gems. Our pieces are not just accessories, but soulful companions designed to resonate with your inner spirit while having a modern style.
Whether you're seeking enhanced intuition, greater self-love, or a confidence boost - our jewelry is created to help you flourish. Consciously handpicked and carefully crafted, each gem offers energizing properties to enrich and beautify your daily life.
We hope the radiant glow of our gems serves you as a reminder of the incredible magic around and especially within you.
Sent with love, from our hands and hearts to yours.
With Love & Magic,
Laura
Hello Sarah,
We know that buzz and social media followers are only part of building a trustworthy, reliable brand. We’re grateful to have grown so quickly and to be supported by such a wonderful community of loyal fans. We also know that trust is the foundation of any business. That’s why we use Yopto, a respected third-party service to verify every review before we share it with the world.
Also, we would like to thank you for your Moon Magic purchase and honest feedback. We strive to ensure every item meets your expectations, and acknowledge that sometimes we fall short. Our 30-day warranty is designed to cover manufacturer defects. If a piece is worn beyond that timeframe, signs of use may prevent it from being eligible for return or exchange.
We are happy to see that a replacement has been sent and hope that you are happy with your new, beautiful Mm piece!
Warm Regards,
Moon Magic