Everything I have purchased, over the years, has been "as described" and delivered promptly. I see bad reviews, but my experience has been great!
If your goal is to build your own $100 Chinese guitar GuitarFetish will allow you to do so for only three times the cost.
The last time I shopped at Guitar Fetish I received two defective products in the same shipment. Now I know it's common practice to send international buyers B-stock and defective items because it's hard to ship it back, but getting two defective products in one shipment seems a bit too blatant.
One of the products I didn't contact them about because despite the defect it functions okay (it was a stratocaster bridge and it had a trem arm thread that was drilled twice) but the other product I bought (a stratocaster pickguard) simply did not fit.
I contacted them about the fitting issue and all they said was that not all stratocasters are cut equally so it's up to me to modify the pickguard, when the description says that it's replacement that works for all stratocaster bodies. I had a different third party manufacturer pickguard before this one (WD music) and it fit perfectly without any modifications so I know they are lying to me. I've attached some photos. Note that barely any of the screw holes line up correctly and that the routes for the pickups don't line up either. Also the lower bout cutout is too shallow so it protrudes past the bevel of the body.
Not sure how they got something so simple this incorrect, but that's not my main problem. My main problem with Guitar Fetish is that they are simply denying their quality control problems, stating that in such budget products, defects are normal and that it's up to the buyer to make it right.
I've done business with Guitar Fetish a few times and when I was living in the US, I didn't have any problems. Now that I'm living somewhere else, all of a sudden I'm receiving lemons. On top of that, they deny any responsibility.
I would also like to add that apparently international buyers get screwed over often by this company. A quick google search for "guitar fetish defective" yields a top result for a TDPRI forum thread regarding their treatment of international customers. There's your proof that my experience isn't an isolated one.
I will no longer be doing business with Guitar Fetish. You should too, especially if you are an international buyer.
Guitar Fetish flew my product to the nearest city in distribution I ordered on Friday and received my alnico v on Monday
Answer: I find that they are quite good for the price. I have bought 2 telecaster copies that I've used for mods because they give you the foundation for a quality player guitar for less than cost. You're going to get a guitar that sounds like a tele and has decent hardware and wood. They sound very good and are guitars that you can enjoy playing as you mod. 2 drawbacks are they are known to have sloppy footwork. I had 1 that came with a high 4th fret but the other was fine. I've heard others complain about them as well. The other drawback is they have pretty ugly headstocks and dont have rolled edges on the fretboard. Stick to the alder or ash solid body guitars and you'll be pleased. Then after the honeymoon is over and you start noticing defects, upgrade. Both of mine have new necks, guess where I bought the necks?
GuitarFetish has a rating of 1.9 stars from 92 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with GuitarFetish most frequently mention customer service, neck pocket and quality control. GuitarFetish ranks 87th among Guitars sites.