Why are they getting such a bad rep?" - I just bought my first pair from JustFab. I bought the Montra Style in black size 10. Originally a 40$ shoe for 15$.
I personally talked to a lady on the phone WHILE ORDERING. They do mention with the VIP membership that it does charge you 39.95 a month unless you skip it. If you're not wanting that and just want the 9.99$ shoe then go for it, and cancel the next day. These people are super duper nice, and they arent running any scams or taking all of your money on purpose. Even if you do end up not skipping the month and having to pay 39.95, you do still get the credit on their website to ANYTHING THERE. From Jeans, to shoes, to jewelry. The only reason they get a bad rep is because people are NOT looking into the VIP membership for what it is. That is not the people at JustFabs mistake so dont blame them for that. You just need to look into what youre purchasing and getting into with it. Do your research ladies.
Other than that, I am not more thrilled to be a part of it. If I dont have the money for the 39.95 ill just skip that month. Easy as pie. I love this website, and I love all their products. So kudos to you JustFab!