I purchased 4 items from Thredup, all classified as "excellent" condition, described as "like new, no signs of wear." -- a very generous analysis. All of the items had that smell often found in second-hand clothing, where someone has used some overwhelming fragrance/fabric softener, etc. That I could live with, but BOTH Eileen Fisher sweaters had a significant number of pulls, pilling, and general wear that I would classify as "Fair" condition. The Fabletics hoodie was faded in spots and pilled under the arms. I would not purchase from them again.