Great looking rotors, shipping was faster than expected. The reason I gave 4 stars is that when one of the rotors came, it was protruding about 2 inches out of the box. The bigger box was in good shape, however, one of the three individual rotor boxes was torn where the rotor clearly pushed out of the box an inch or two during transit. Not really TireRack's fault, aside from maybe better insulation/more packing paper? But was a slight concern upon receiving, but I didn't see any scratches or damage to the rotor so it was ok.