I placed an order with Instacart last week with two BOGO items, but I chose different varieties of the BOGO. Lo and behold, you HAVE to order the EXACT same item in order to get the BOGO price. So, where does that savings go? Probably right to Instacart! I researched Shipt and found that with BOGO items (or any item, for that matter), you can leave a note. So, in the cart it shows 2 of the same item, but in the note, you can specify what other variety you want. I did this today and got exactly what I wanted. Buh-bye, Instacart!