I, like many others apparently, had never ordered from Nastygal but had previously heard that the quality of their clothes was good. So, when I got an email on black Friday that the whole site was 60% off, I was a little blown away. I ended up placing two orders (some items for myself, some as gifts for my roommate) and it was a little slow. When I got the shipping notifications, the shipper was "royal mail" or something and when I clicked the tracking links the royal mail site said they couldn't find my package at that time, and it couldn't find it even after it was delivered to me. I ordered a shirt, a shirt dress (both very boxy and unflattering on me, but these were gifts so I didn't return them), earrings that were decent enough, a bodysuit (cheap plastic clasps at the crotch kept coming undone and there were strings everywhere showing how cheap the sowing was but didn't look too bad on) and a sherpa-esque jacket which wasn't that bad.
The quality wasn't poor enough to scare me away given the "60% off" pricing and the pictures and styles are appealing, but I don't think I will be ordering from them again.