I own two of there holsters and haven't had any issues both have great retention and fit. I believe people are expecting too much from a mass produced holster that cost $60 or less. Not sure what people expect. If you want a custom holster with perfect fit and finish your looking at spending $150-$200 and waiting 3-4 months before you receive it. I purchased holsters at txc and Odin and both were great quality but 3-4 times the cost. Even tier 1 holsters can reach around $150 loaded out..