We’re in this together! Stay safe with our COVID-19 guide



  • 1 Review
  • 1 Helpful Vote
  • 0 Thank Yous

Member since November 2011

  • Review


  • First Review


  • Thank Yous


  • Fans


  • Profile Views


Review Distribution

1 Review by JW


Nanette Barto claims to have solved the Zodiac Killer case and a host of other infamous crimes by matching the handwriting in these murders to that of her deceased suspect.
More specifically, Ms. Barto says that she matched the handwriting of Jack Tarrance to that of Chicago's Lipstick Killer, even though another man is in jail for those crimes. The Lipstick Killer murders occurred on June 5,1945, December 20,1945, and January 7,1946.
According to Jack Tarrance's Military Discharge Documents, he began active service in the US Navy at a base in San Francisco, CA on December 12,1945. This date is just 8 days before the second Lipstick murder. Clearly, Jack Tarrance would not have been granted Leave from the Navy to travel from California to Chicago, Illinois just 8 days after beginning active service. Nor would he have been able to extend such leave for 3 weeks so that he could also be in Chicago at the time of the 3rd Lipstick Murder on January 7,1946.
If Jack Tarrance could not have been in Chicago at the time the 2nd (Frances Brown) and 3rd (Suzanne Degnan) Lipstick Murders occurred, he could NOT have written the messages left by the Lipstick Killer. This means that Nanette Barto's handwriting match between Jack Tarrance and the Lipstick Killer is WRONG. If her comparisons between Tarrance and the Lipstick Killer are WRONG, this brings into serious question the validity of her match between Tarrance and the Zodiac, Tarrance and the Amerithrax attacker, and Tarrance and the I-45 Killer (which, incidentally, did not even have a handwritten letter, just one with letters cut and pasted).
The proof of Tarrance's innocence in the Lipstick Killings can be found at Ms. Barto's own Photobucket page, where she has posted these military discharge documents. The documents are in the "Jacks Personal Effects 2010" Album. You can visit her page here:


In case Ms. Barto removes this information from her Photobucket account, you can also find it here: http://tinyurl.com/3nnabf9

Ms. Barto also spends an inordinate amount of energy denigrating law enforcement agencies (including the FBI, LAPD, SFPD, Oakland County, Michigan PD and Napa PD), accusing them of lying and egregious breaches in ethics and morality just because they don't support her findings. Why should they when she's been proven to be wrong?
Read almost any thread at the link below and see the venomous things she has to say about hard-working individuals.

JW Has Earned 1 Vote

Jw T.'s review of zodiackillerjacktarrance.com earned a Very Helpful vote

JW hasn’t received any thanks yous.

JW doesn’t have any fans yet.

JW isn’t following anybody yet.