I have received my subscription for two months now. The first box had hair products that I tried that were then thrown out. The last box received yesterday also contained items I had to throw out. For example, a lip pencil that was so hard it could not be applied. How old was it? The second was a bronzer that once opened, the product fell out of the tube and was ruined. I may give it one more month but right now would not recommend Ipsy.