I am having the same issue as others with the sketchy collegeprojewelry seller. I bought several charms and there is no way they are real. They look like horrible knock offs and the color on them turns green. They say no plastic, LIE. They say sterling silver, LIE. They say they are real, LIE. Tried to contact chris moshinskie and got no response. My sister wants me to return them but i cant get a response