• Candle Collection

Candle Collection

Overview

Candle Collection has a rating of 2.1 stars from 14 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Candle Collection most frequently mention customer service problems. Candle Collection ranks 3rd among Candles sites.

  • Service
    2
  • Value
    2
  • Shipping
    2
  • Returns
    1
  • Quality
    2
Positive reviews (last 12 months): 0%
Positive
0
Neutral
0
Negative
1
See all photos
How would you rate Candle Collection?
Top Positive Review

“Wonderful”

Bailey E.
12/14/20

I picked up 2 of the colonial candles at a discount store (I believe maybe they were donated or were discontinued and donated.) I tried to look them up and they're not on the website. I have a simply vanilla (which smells just like vanilla frosting!) I haven't gotten around to burning that one yet, but I'm currently burning a cinnamon chai one which has a cinnamon hots (like the hot candy cinnamon) smell to it! I'll update this review after I see how they burn but so far the cinnamon is burning great and the lid is perfect for distinguishing the wick. I may buy some more from the website as well.

Top Critical Review

“Colonial Candles have very little fragrance and they burn horribly. The wax chokes out the flame.”

Elin B.
9/17/21

I can't return them because I'm disabled and sick. They don't offer me any other compensation. I just threw away four full candles. I'm sticking with Goose Creek. They're tried and true.

Reviews (14)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Thumbnail of user elinb10
1 review
1 helpful vote
September 17th, 2021

I can't return them because I'm disabled and sick. They don't offer me any other compensation. I just threw away four full candles. I'm sticking with Goose Creek. They're tried and true.

Thumbnail of user kittyk70
1 review
6 helpful votes
July 13th, 2020

The lavender candles I ordered smelled like insecticide. When I wanted to return them I was forced to pay $31.00 with FedEx (the post office would not take them) and Colonial Candle now owes me a credit of about $75. They would not pay for the return shipping because according to them the candles were not damaged. I will never buy from them again.

Thumbnail of user karlas204
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
October 25th, 2021
Verified purchase

I recently ordered 6 candles from Colonial Candles directly. The holiday four pack and two full sized candles ( Cozy Cashmere and Sugar Plum). I received three candles in the holiday four pack, and the Cozy Cashmere. However, the Sugar Plum and the Sparkling seasonal from the four pack were not in the shipment. So I called customer service and was told that those two were damaged during shipping, but that they would be sending me those two candles out immediately. She also told me she would send me a confirmation email for that order. I never received the candles or the email. Today I called again, after ten days, and was assured I would receive the two candles as they would be sent out today. I guess we will wait and see, but I will not be buying Colonial Candles ever again, and I have been a customer for almost 30 years.

Tip for consumers:
If there is an issue with your order, do not expect good customer service.

Products used:
The four candles that actually arrived

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user donnal1066
1 review
0 helpful votes
May 4th, 2021

If you read the E-mail I sent to Colonial Candle Customer Service you'll understand my complaint. So you know I never did get an explanation...
Hello...
I just went onto your web site to purchase MORE candles. Actually more of the same I just purchased about 2 weeks ago... Can someone please tell me how the price of an item that was on sale increases?! The same candles I purchased last now cost $1 or $2 more! I thought the vendors on Amazon were the only ones that did that!
I'm so disappointed... I finally find a candle company that I was so impressed with. The look, the collections, the scents, the perfect burn, an awesome throw...
That OTHER candle company used to be my favorite but for years they've been failing in the throw department. Significantly... But I don't ever remember them raising the prices on items that were already on sale!
C'mon people!
So disappointed!

Thumbnail of user lisap1171
1 review
3 helpful votes
October 13th, 2020

THIS COMPANY IS must be having serious issues. They have absolutely no customer support. Do not purchase from this at all!

Thumbnail of user aimeel42
1 review
5 helpful votes
November 13th, 2019

This is my first time ordering from them. I order eight candles and the way they packaged my candles were not right, so one of them broke. I called the company this morning to get my candle replaced. The lady was so rude. She did not even apologize to me as a customer. She is very unprofessional. Never Again.

Thumbnail of user baileye23
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 14th, 2020

I picked up 2 of the colonial candles at a discount store (I believe maybe they were donated or were discontinued and donated.) I tried to look them up and they're not on the website. I have a simply vanilla (which smells just like vanilla frosting!) I haven't gotten around to burning that one yet, but I'm currently burning a cinnamon chai one which has a cinnamon hots (like the hot candy cinnamon) smell to it! I'll update this review after I see how they burn but so far the cinnamon is burning great and the lid is perfect for distinguishing the wick. I may buy some more from the website as well.

Thumbnail of user quincieb
3 reviews
9 helpful votes
October 6th, 2023

I have now learned my lesson, and will stick to Bath & Body Works or Goose Creek for my candle needs. I made my first purchase from Colonial Candles a few weeks ago, and the experience was awful from start to finish. It took a full week for the candles to actually get shipped. The candles were finally delivered, and immediately I could tell that they were used candles that had been repurposed/resold. There was wax up and down the sides of the glass jars, and ABSOLUTELY NO SCENT to any of the candles. NONE. These candles are literally mood lighting and nothing more. To say I was disappointed would be an understatement. I contacted customer service, only to be met with the most rude and uncaring employees ever. Long story short, if you receive bad candles that you'd like to return or if you want to return ANY of Colonial Candles products, you'll pay the return shipping cost. Regardless of if the candles arrived damaged. Colonial Candles WILL NOT cover the cost of shipping and will instead force you to make a choice to either keep the candles, or pay even more money out of pocket to return their terrible product. While I was placing my order, I thought to myself, "why isn't Colonial Candles more popular, they have a great candle selection." After this experience, I now understand why no one talks about Colonial Candles. They have shady business practices and should not be in the business of selling anything to anyone, let alone attempting to sell "scented candles." Run away from this company, because they are trash and the product that they peddle is not the least bit worth it.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user dianaf33
4 reviews
3 helpful votes
November 26th, 2019

I ordered two candles on 11/10/19 and as of today 11/26/19 no emails have been answered, or phone calls have been returned. No communication except a confirmation of the order. The phone number listed on my c/c statement just rings and rings. I'm going to have to file a dispute with my c/c company to get my money back. Never again.

Thumbnail of user terenceb16
5 reviews
25 helpful votes
December 20th, 2020

Have placed several orders - each with 10 or more candles in them. They have been shipped quickly and packaged well. If you catch them during one opf the frequent sales, the prices are better than anyplace else online and the shipping is free.

I especailly love the Manly Indulgence and the Oak Room collections, but have tried and enjoyed many others. This is my go to place for candles. Give them a try.

Tip for consumers:
Catch one of the frequent 20% off sales w/ free shipping

Products used:
Manly Indulgence, Oak Room

Thumbnail of user marilyng427
1 review
0 helpful votes
February 16th, 2021

I love, love, love colonial oval candles! They burn better than any of the hundreds of other candles I have tried. My favorite is the 22 ounce oval.

Thumbnail of user reidf10
1 review
2 helpful votes
November 27th, 2019

Ordered two candles and one was received shattered. I've tried reaching to support twice now for a replacement but it would seem my money was wasted.

Thumbnail of user anniem33
2 reviews
11 helpful votes
February 6th, 2014

I've ordered from colonialcandle.com several times over the last 5 years. The first two-three times, they were a mess. I think they didn't really have the online shipping situation figured out yet. The first time I ordered, the order was never shipped. I did finally get it. A person who actually worked in the store where the flagship store is located put together my order and shipped it for me. She said that the warehouse was just not working.
The second order went about the same, received candles but it took 3 weeks and everything came separately in padded store bought envelopes. Odd.
Now we are moving on into the last two years. I had a Visa Card with a low credit line, which I used for online purchases only. I made a purchase of four colonial candles which cost $81.00 with shipping and handling after coupon they sent in an email.
I waited, and waited, and waited. Finally after 7 days of "order processing", I called. The customer service rep. Said the charge was declined. I asked her to hold on and called my credit card company. They said there was one charge for $81.00 and it dropped off. They never charged the order, just got a pre-authorization.

So I get back on the phone & tell this to the woman. She then informs me that Colonial Candle charges your credit card twice, and did I have sufficient funds ($162.00) on the card to cover this? What? I said no, I don't. I had $150.00 on a card with a $300.00 limit. I explained that this is a low limit credit card used only for online purchases. She said that they always double charge. First the preauth. And second time when ready to ship. She informed me that then they only put through one charge. Seriously? Is this even legal? Two charges for the same order? Incredible.
I really wanted the candles so I went online and paid down my card to zero balance and got the candles. Yes, they double charged me, yes the second charge dropped off after about 5 days from shipping.
By the way, there was nothing on the website about this happening. Now, two years later, there is a small print note on checkout page letting customers know this is how they roll... still.
Ordered 2 candles in December 2013 and my card was charged thirty dollars, twice. I can't believe they are still doing this. It makes no sense. The first charge is enough. The funds are being held back for them with the pre authorization. And these account for "real" charges. If you have a $50.00 available amount and buy some stuff for $26.00, you are out of luck. So, with a word of warning, make sure you have the funds X 2 to cover an order.
On a final note, as for the selection and quality of the candles, I have really been disappointed lately with the scents they are putting out.
I do not know if they revamped everything or just their simmer snaps. They are also following Yankee Candle into the "retired" scents arena and then they bring them back later (ex. Autumn Fig, Gold Frankincens & Myrrh) and call them customer favorites, but Colonial Candle actually only brings back an 8oz. Candle and overcharges for the item. If it is a customer favorite or bestseller, why would you retire it in the first place? Oh Look what candles are back, creating a buzz? Really? So shady. So yeah, I hope I don't sound to bitter, but for me, the scents are either bad, or just not for me. However, I did find a nice smelling candle recently in a store which carries Colonial Candle, unfortunately, it was a "special line" and the candle was thirty dollars, and so small. I even went to the website and it was the same price. In closing, Colonial Candle rarely, if every really, has promo codes, two for one deals, semi-anual sales. I have had an email with them for almost 10 years and I have received one coupon for 20 percent off. They send lots of emails telling me to check out their new scents or the overpriced "returning customer favorites". Yeah, I guess I'm a little bitter. I just wish they would decide what they are. In the game? Half in?
Cheers,
Annie

Thumbnail of user ericab57
Erica B. – Candle Collection Rep

Hi Annie, the Colonial Candle family really wants to make this right, can you please call Khristina (Customer Service Manager) 866-445-9993

Sorry for the delayed response - we had never seen this sight before and are now well aware of your situation.

Thumbnail of user yvetteb5
3 reviews
23 helpful votes
December 7th, 2015

I rec'd a gift of 2 pine scented Colonial candles several few years ago. They were the most wonderful, strongly scented candles I've ever had! Because I burned them only at Christmas time, they lasted years & every year, when I burned them again, they smelled just as good!

This year I finally needed to replace them, so I went online to the Colonial Candle site. They didn't list a Pine scent but had an Evergreen scent. After so many years, I figured it had been discontinued & I ordered 2 - 3"X4" column candles, Evergreen scent. Then I found they chg. Your cr. Card as soon you click on "order", NOT when it ships, as most reputable companies do.

I didn't like that, but let it go. I waited a few days for a ship confirmation, that didn't arrive. I called & was told "It just left today" (it didn't). In another day or two I got a ship confirmation that said it had just been shipped THAT day. It gave a a tracking # & said it shipped by "ground", but NO name of WHO the carrier was. I knew it wasn't UPS because UPS tracking #'s start with 1Z and this one didn't.

So I had to call AGAIN to find out WHO the carrier was so I could actually track the order. A man ans. Said he'd go check, he came back & said it went via Fed Ex Ground. I told him tracking #s are of NO help when they don't mention WHO the carrier is!

The candles finally arrived a few days later & had NO scent - none, nada, zip! These are UNSCENTED candles, but they're charging for SCENTED candles - $11.50 each +they chg. Plenty for shipping.

BTW, one UNSCENTED candle had a label that said "Evergreen", they didn't even bother to put a label on the other one!

By then I was so fed up with them & busy w/work, Christmas shopping & preparing for a party, I didn't bother to return them. I'll use the overpriced UNSCENTED candles & NEVER, EVER do business with this unprofessional, Mickey Mouse outfit again. You shouldn't either, unless you enjoy being ripped off!

Thumbnail of user ericab57
Erica B. – Candle Collection Rep

Hi Yvette, the Colonial Candle family is so sad to read your review. With the entire team being only 11 people, we strive to communicate with each other and relay any and all communication to our cherished customers.

We have completely revamped our website and the email system that relays tracking information in the past year. We continually update our new website to keep it as stream lined as possible. Please take a second to browse the new platform.

Yes, it is true. We have discontinued making our scented pillars. We are happy to send you a jar candle from our holiday collection, if you are interested.

Please contact Stephanie or Shaz in our customer service department - 866-445-9993

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Beautiful scented & unscented American Made candles. Signature Oval Scented Jar Candles, Pillars, Tapers, Votives, Tealights & Simmer Snaps. Brighten your world. Light a Candle. A Colonial Candle.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user ericab57
Erica B.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Candle Collection?

  • Sitejabber’s mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Candle Collection?