Thumbnail of user netsujou.serenade

Hae M.

Contributor Level

Total Points
81

1 Review by Hae

  • Horse Isle

5/11/23

I've been playing this game for a little over a year, i think. I'd seen the reviews as well as share a home with someone who used to play but, mostly due to the lack of anything to do in game, no longer does. I was warned to stay away and to definitely not spend my money here, but i wanted to see for myself, and now here we are.

It's important to note, as two people who share a location, that my roommate and i also share an internet connection, but we do not share a computer. Apparently i've now been banned for "multi-accounting" even though this account was my one and only. In any other game like this, i would probably reach out to staff at this point to talk to them about it, see if maybe there was a mixup and they meant to ban someone else with a similar user, or if this has something to do with my roommate and i both having accounts; and if that's truly the issue, then explain the misunderstanding and see if the ban could be reversed. However, knowing how they tend to handle being wrong, i really just don't feel comfortable with initiating that kind of interaction. Some of the confrontations i've seen frankly just turn into bullying on their end, and i'm not at a mental state where i can really handle that right now.

I think i'm mostly concerned about this in particular because the game is aimed towards children. What would happen if, in a family setting, a parent and their child or children all signed up to play together? A good parent might want to play alongside their child, or at least check out the game atmosphere to make sure they feel it's age appropriate, they feel comfortable with their kid in that environment, etc. it's important to note that their game rules DO NOT make exceptions of multiple accounts tied to one household for multiple people, including family members, which in itself doesn't really make this game in any way safe for kids, especially when noting in some other complaints and reviews i've seen that there is blatant evidence of predatory behaviour on this game.

While i'm here, i figured i might as well add in some other things that make me feel this game is worth one star, as listed below.

- the game is advertised as being a sort of open world adventure, but there's no adventure to be had. The landscape is absolutely devoid of life, the ambient soundscape is ear grating and blatantly fake, the music is so annoying that i had to mute it. The only incentives to explore are the ridiculous amount of space you need between each ranch/club, and a handful of features that are neat at first and get old extremely quick as they are reused to death.
- making money is extremely difficult. If you are not in the top 1% your horses will never sell except to the traders at extremely low prices. Collecting any items worth selling is boring, repetitive and very time consuming. Some of the places needed to access for the most desired resources are locked behind a paywall.
- there are no quests. Not even a main story. The only consistent entertainment in the game are the hourly mane events (some you may not be able to participate in as they're player built and sometimes have arbitrary, exclusionary rules), and frequent game events which basically cycle through the same handful of server wide "minigames".
- the chat filter is atrocious. I really appreciate the attempt to block profanity, but i've seen inconsistencies like "boob" is blocked but "boobs" is not; maybe not that specifically, but i'm sure you get the jist. I think "vomit" was also blocked for some reason. There's some i found that are really, really vile, to the point where i can't help thinking they may have been intentionally left unblocked because there's no way the devs didn't know to block them.
- graphics are sub-par. They're so ugly they're charming, but the animations look so robotic and janky they've caused me to have motion sickness. When the changes were made, i noticed many other people complain of the same thing, but were basically told to suck it up because that's how it's going to be now. Can't help but think they're trying to get on the level of starstable or upcoming titles like astride, ranch of rivershine, tales of rein ravine, that horse game, etc. unfortunately, people are leaving because they're bored and changing the animations isn't going to fix that.

All in all, my recommendation would just be to not bother. In the time that i played, i followed the rules, bred some really nice horses, easily spent over 1k on mobia to support the devs, and accepted the flaws for what they were without complaining. I tried to have fun in my own way, never stirred the pot, but was punished for something i didn't do with no explanation at all after playing for over a year. Save your money. Play literally any other game, just don't bother with a barebones sandbox game that will waste your time and money.

Products used:
spent about 1k on mobia in a year.

Service
Value
Quality

Hae Has Earned 1 Vote

Hae M.'s review of Horse Isle earned a Very Helpful vote

Hae hasn’t received any thanks yous.

Hae doesn’t have any fans yet.

Hae isn’t following anybody yet.

Empty.

Similar Reviewers on Sitejabber

Thumbnail of user lucyc365
3/26/24

I was banned within the first 24 hours of creating an account because they claimed I had multiple...

Thumbnail of user camillea17
1/19/24

Utterly boring game that has no soul whatsoever, just like its moderation team. The lack of...