• Scent Matchers

Scent Matchers

Overview

Scent Matchers has a rating of 2.9 stars from 798 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Scent Matchers most frequently mention credit card, smell anything, and baby powder problems. Scent Matchers ranks 9th among Perfume sites.

  • Returns
    21

Proactively asks for customer feedback

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 0%
Positive
0
Neutral
0
Negative
1
38
See all photos

What reviewers want you to know

Positive highlights

  • They have excellent customer service and quick delivery.

Critical highlights

No critical highlights yet

How would you rate Scent Matchers?
Top Positive Review

“Great choice of perfums”

Kathi L.
1/12/22

Good prices and the choice of perfums is amazing. I would say for any taste. All scents are nice, very nice!

Top Critical Review

“DO NOT USE THIS COMPANY”

Veronica C.
1/18/24

I regret ever making a purchase here. They are not selling what they say They are selling. You will not get a re-created fragrance. The customer service is horrible. Dealing with them has been a complete nightmare.

Reviews (798)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (137)
Thumbnail of user veronicac675
1 review
0 helpful votes
January 18th, 2024

I regret ever making a purchase here. They are not selling what they say They are selling. You will not get a re-created fragrance. The customer service is horrible. Dealing with them has been a complete nightmare.

Products used:
None

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user jenniev19
1 review
0 helpful votes
November 9th, 2022

This smells like rotten grass/soil mixed with lilacs soaked in toilet water. I have been looking for a close ringer for a discontinued perfume for my sister and thought I would give Scent Matchers a try, I don't smell a SINGLE note that was supposed to be in this blend. Bulgarian Rose, Pomegranate Blossom, Dark Chocolate, Jasmine, Bergamot, Patchouli, White Musk, Tea. BUYER BEWARE - they should at least give a more affordable option for you to sample what you may be getting. Because they don't offer that - I think this company is a SCAM. The bottle they sent me is PUTRID, smells nothing like the scent I asked them to make and there is no way to return.

Tip for consumers:
BEWARE - they do not do refunds and you are taking a risk spending $$$ on something that could end up horrible.

Products used:
Perfume - will dispose of it because it's horrible and I would be embarrassed to share with anyone.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user teutav1
1 review
11 helpful votes
January 1st, 2020

I ordered Tokyo Milk Dark Destiny 79, and got a vat of cheap, synthetic musk. The main ingredient in Dark Destiny is honeysuckle. There is zero honeysuckle in the product they sent me. It's a fundamental error, like making chocolate chip cookies and putting no chocolate chips in the batter. Customer service is a one automatic answer email that basically tells you to go get stuffed. It seems we all got the same one. So disappointed. :(

Thumbnail of user nikm24
2 reviews
15 helpful votes
December 26th, 2019

My husband ordered Dream Angels Divine for me for Christmas. He is a sucker for the buy in volume deals so I now have 3 bottles of something that does not smell anything like Divine. The bottles leak so I could smell it before I opened the package. No return policy means a lot of money on a scent I don't recognize. Save your money and continue your search for a new scent since yours is no longer out there, at least you can pick something you might like.

Thumbnail of user joans355
1 review
17 helpful votes
January 13th, 2020

I was so excited to find a place that could match Este Lauder's discontinued White Linen Light Breeze that I ordered two bottles. But the scent was really bad with a chemical tinge, nothing close to the original scent. And Scent Matcher's no refund policy is unethical. It is false advertising with no recourse. I am working with my credit card to challenge the charges.

Thumbnail of user stephanieb452
1 review
4 helpful votes
May 3rd, 2019

As soon as I received my bottle of a match to Safari for men by Ralph Lauren I noticed there was floating debris and a hair floating inside the liquid! They claim to respond to emails within an hour, 24 hours at the most. I have been emailing for days without a response. They also deleted my comments, pictures and videos off their Facebook page. All I wanted was a refund because debris and hair inside a cologne bottle is disgusting. I am disappointed and now angry they wont help me with this problem. There is no quality control in their matching/blending process it seems.

Thumbnail of user lesliep232
1 review
13 helpful votes
July 19th, 2020

The product they sent me smelled like flea market knock offs with that underlying cheap base ingredient. Perhaps they get quantity vats of scent and pick something. No precision mixing for sure! Don't waste your time or money.

Thumbnail of user teresaf142
1 review
12 helpful votes
January 8th, 2020

I received a bottle of the duplicate for Victoria's Secret Dream Angels Divine for Christmas and it was awful! All I could smell was vanilla which is not part of the scent profile. My sister bought this for me and she has filed with BBB. This company says they offer something you want, but they send you whatever they have on the shelf. Don't be suckered by this team of frauds!

Thumbnail of user noellec13
1 review
4 helpful votes
February 26th, 2019

Do not order from this site! The scent I ordered smelled absolutely nothing like the original! Plus it was extremely late & I didn't receive any emails that it was coming until the day before it showed up. Then I find out they don't do refunds & my scent actually came back so I didn't even need to buy this in the first place. What a scam! I'm out $50 & they're going to keep scamming people. DO NOT ORDER ANYTHING from this business!

Thumbnail of user christineg221
1 review
8 helpful votes
March 17th, 2019
• Updated review

Update: my credit card company refunded my money which is nice. The bottles now have chunks of gross sediment floating in them. Horrible that they are scamming people with this disgusting "fragrance".

Scam
December 9th, 2018
• Previous review

Im convinced they send the same baby powder smelling, cheap fragrance to everyone. Didn't come close to matching and everything is poor quality. The two bottles they sent have some sort of gross sediment floating in it (see picture). Dont waste your time and money. Im guessing most of the good reviews are not real.

Thumbnail of user scottm1711
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
April 15th, 2021

What I received was a horrible smell. Not even in the same universe. What I received was what old ladies used to cover their smoking smell back in the 70's. Absolutely vile! Tried to contact company support and never could get a response. Out over 50.00. DO NOT WASTE YOUR MONEY ON THIS SCAM

Products used:
Ordered a duplicate of mistral blackberry perfume. received something absolutely different and horrible.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rosac36
1 review
2 helpful votes
April 29th, 2019

I order in March 23, got my order today April 27... 1 month later... the perfume was suppose to be August by Hollister smells nothing like it, smells so bad! What a waste! So upset. Don't be fooled by these people!

Thumbnail of user timd476
1 review
4 helpful votes
December 26th, 2019

I am extremely disappointed in the fragrance I received for my wife's Christmas gift. $80 is a lot of money in the pastor's household. I was hoping I could surprise my wife with her favorite Royal Apothecary fragrance "Hothouse Peony" that had been discontinued. Sadly the result smells nothing like the original. And with no way to get a refund we are just out the money. My advice unfortunately is it's not worth the risk to do business here.

Thumbnail of user deborahg406
2 reviews
11 helpful votes
December 21st, 2019

I really, really wish I had looked up their reviews - especially on the Better Business Bureau website. Interestingly, the BBB posts a red warning flag that there has been a pattern of complaints that the fragrances do not at all match; and recently - just in the past week - ScentMatchers has taken down their e-commerce website and now only does business with repeat customers who are happy with the fragrances they've done. The company itself admits it has been bombarded with complaints and requests for refunds, even though they do state they don't do returns/refunds. I knew that when I ordered, thinking that if it were a little off it would still be wearable; but I never dreamed it could be this bad.

In terms of my own belatedly regrettable experience - throwing away $81.99 based on their assertion that they can match fragrances (which IS chemically possible, look at all the artificial flavorings in food - in fact for someone with a severe allergy to strawberries, even fake strawberry flavoring will trigger it) I was certainly not expecting what I actually got. I so wish I had read these reviews first. After reading the same thing from so many others, I have to agree that most of the positive reviews have got to be fake. I ordered a match of Chanel No 19, the original fragrance before the "reinterpretation" that happened something like 10 years ago. I don't like the new version. I emailed them and they assured me they could do this. It arrived yesterday. First of all they represent their products as a parfum, and this was so weak it could not possibly be a parfum. But they charge as if it were. Next, I noticed what just about every other (non-fake) reviewer says, that it does not even remotely resemble the fragrance they wanted to match. I sprayed it on my wrist, and the first notes - extremely faint - resembled old-fashioned hair laquer, like my mother used in the 70s. That soon faded to what I can only describe as bar soap. Nothing that I would ever wear as a fragrance, whether or not I was wanting to wear Chanel 19. As everyone else says, they must be making outrageous profits selling water with a few chemicals in it for $70 - $80 a pop.

Thumbnail of user aaronh189
1 review
14 helpful votes
November 29th, 2018

I had ordered a remake of an old bath and body works scent that was discontinued over a decade ago. They sent me a bottle and it smelled like musty old perfume that was sitting on a shelf of an antique store for decades. I emailed to complain and they offered me a re-do. They sent me a lot to give them a sample, (a sample of a scent that I did not have because it was discontinued over a decade ago hence me ordering from them) however I digress, so I had to find the cheapest smallest body wash version of the scent on EBay. I put that in their kit and shipped it off awaiting my re-do bottle. Just got it in the mail, and it's as horrible musty and stinky as the first one. They had originally claimed that this is what their samples smelled like- so clearly their samples are very old and very expired too! I wouldn't recommend ordering from them unless the perfume you're chasing is still available for purchase elsewhere or if it was just recently discontinued- otherwise the scent profile is completely off.

Thumbnail of user toddl113
1 review
6 helpful votes
December 26th, 2019

Horrible product. Order this for my wife and it was not even close to the sent. Smelled like medicine. I will never recommend this company or it's products. $82.00 flushed.

Thumbnail of user rodrigoa26
1 review
2 helpful votes
November 22nd, 2019

Do yourself a favor... save the disappointment and don't buy their product.

It is not that it doesn't resemble the claimed fragrance. It doesn't smell of anything but alcohol. Probably the only online product I have ever seen that can't be returned...

Again... DON'T BUY IT.

Thumbnail of user ginag153
1 review
2 helpful votes
December 26th, 2019

As everyone here has stated these people are con artists and it's pathetic that they do what they do. My son bought me a scent for Christmas he was so excited that he found someone to make my favorite perfume for me. $81 for a bottle of rubbing alcohol and bathroom sanitizer and he has to work three days to make that money at his job. Deplorable people who prey on the innocent hard working class people. Karma is a $#*! I hope all the people you have wronged send enough negative energy your way. How do you look at yourselves in the mirror knowing what you have done.

Tip for consumers:
Stay far away very far away

Products used:
It’s in the donation bag to a pet rescue maybe they can use it

Thumbnail of user bobc330
1 review
3 helpful votes
March 22nd, 2019
Verified purchase

SCAMMERS -- they never even attempted to replicate my cologne when they sent me what smells like skunk urine. DO NOT ORDER FROM THEM!

Thumbnail of user elizabethf339
1 review
3 helpful votes
September 20th, 2019

After failing to match my scent, they will not return your money. They are a total SCAM/RIP OFF company - Don't order from them

Thumbnail of user nicolew258
1 review
0 helpful votes
April 21st, 2019

I placed my order almost 3 weeks ago now and still haven't received it. I have tried tracking the delivery with the tracking number they provided and USPS has no record of it. I have reached out to Scentmatchers by email multiple times, Facebook messenger, and have left 2 voicemails with no response. The customer service is awful! Unfortunately I have filed a complaint with the better business bureau. Please check them out through the BBB before ordering, I should have! I never would have ordered! Multiple complaints have been filed against them within the last month. They sure take your money and don't provide you with the product or customer service they promise and apparently pride themselves on! VERY DISAPPOINTED!

Thumbnail of user ginab160
1 review
2 helpful votes
May 1st, 2019

The fragrance is nothing like the scent I ordered, and the bottle has no spray nozzle or way to access the cologne itself. Numerous email, phone and website form requests have gone unanswered.

Thumbnail of user maryw608
1 review
2 helpful votes
February 17th, 2019
Verified purchase

Ordered Philosophy the Fragrance. 1st shipment smelled like funeral flowers (NOWHERE CLOSE to the lemon, citrus, white musk scent)! Same for the next 2 shipments and they even had a sample of my original perfume to use for matching purposes! All 3 scents were SO bad they went directly into the garbage. Prepare to wait over a month for shipment and delivery each time. Masters?... hardly.

Thumbnail of user heathere69
1 review
8 helpful votes
April 21st, 2019

My husband ordered a discontinued fragrance from them for me for Christmas and it was no where even close to the fragrance. The first time my husband sent them the actual notes from the website where the original scent was made explaining what ingredients were used to make the fragrance and the second time we tried again by sending a sample and it was even worse the second time. The smell reminds me of something very outdated or maybe a bad bathroom spray. Both times we have reordered they sent it in the wrong bottle (you can choose your bottle type). They will not reply. They have deleted my comments and have me blocked from being able to like or comment on their fb page and they refuse to give a refund.

I just want to help others from getting scammed by this company.

UPDATE: So my husband contacted the BBB about this situation and Scentmatchers replied talking about they've been in business for ten years blah blah blah and basically making us out to be just whiny customers instead of apologizing or admitting that they send out horrible fragrances not even resembling the scent you're interested in (even with the ingredients list from the maker and a sample)... and they agreed to give us a full refund.

I HIGHLY recommend that if you've been scammed by this company that you let the BBB know about it asap.

Thumbnail of user jakeb133
1 review
1 helpful vote
January 26th, 2019
Verified purchase

I entered in the scent I'd like matched, paid the fee, which was easy, so I gave it a star. But, after that, no follow up information, limbo. I went to the website to check on order, but there is no way to check that there. "Order" on the website means to make a future order, not check a past order like all other websites. I have tried 4 different online order services, and I have stopped using them because no follow up, no way to contact them, no order checking system, and it took between a month or two to receive product. For a few extra $ I could have drove to a store and got the product and save 2 months of use. Customer service followup, order status, and turn-around time. (I am yet to receive product, so I can not comment on that). :)

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Perfume and fragrance matching.

Business History

Scentmatchers was launched in September 2008 as an offshoot of Scentcrafters.com. It was created by Adam and Angela Schultz. Adam originally launched Scentcrafters, which makes custom perfume and cologne for individuals and businesses.

Shortly after Scentcrafters formed, Adam and Angela also started their life together as husband and wife. Literally a couple months after that, Angela found out she was pregnant with their first child. At that time Scentmatchers was also created. Needless to say, it was a busy period for the Schultz's!

Scentmatchers started after Scentcrafters' customers repeatedly asked if we could also provide a service to bring discontinued fragrances back to life. After enough people asked us this, we eventually woke up to the idea that, "Hey, we should give people what they want."

In 2013 we took the next step as a company and hired our first employees. We now have over 28 years of combined experience producing discontinued fragrances, and to date we have sold over 100,000 individual bottles of discontinued fragrances.

In 2014 we decided to increase our commitment to customer service and we hired our first full time Customer Service Manager, Pravin. We pride ourselves on providing quick and prompt customer service as repeat business becomes the cornerstone of our company.

In June of 2017 we increased the amount of perfume oil we used in fragrances by 50%, which we feel increases the quality of our product by it more potent and longer lasting.

In 2018 we created this new streamlined website on the Shopify platform that we are very excited about. We also added 2 more full time employees as the business continues to grow.

Despite some initial growing pains, we are now considered one of the foremost experts in creating discontinued perfume and cologne. We look forward to recreating your memories as you become part of our story.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user adams81
Susan J.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Scent Matchers?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Scent Matchers?