Is not a scam! Although it would be helpful if the site told clients upfront that the 'free' reward cost $2.00 shipping/handling. There is a wide variety of magazines to choose from and you do not have to pick 4. Pick 1, 2, 3 or 4. When the time comes to renew at the magazine site you will get a card in the mail well in advance of keeping-canceling the subscription and Nobody bothers you about it one way or the other. Like one reviewer says " it is old fashion customer service" Easy peesy. I have gotten this award a few times over the years and nothing about that has changed. In our world of uncertainty it is good to know somethings are still 'normal' Think about how much a subscription for Readers Digest or Time magazine charges. And you only pay the $2 S&H. It is the best reward out there.