I have an annual subscription directly with Paramount Plus and have never subscribed to Paramount through Apple. But Apple is charging me a monthly subscription fee for Paramount +. I have requested a refund for at least 12 payments of 9.99. They have refunded one payment of 9.99 and refuse to refund the rest. Be sure to check what Apple charges you for. It is first of all my mistake for not auditing my payments and charges but Apple should care more for their loyal customers than the care they have shown me. We have three apple phones, two Mac books and an iMac. Never again will I purchase another APPLE PRODUCT.