First thing to know is this site is part of the Conscious Dating Network pool. They do explain that up front if you want to read it so its hard to hold it against them. It basically groups a bunch of niche sites together.
Even though this may seem contrary to the whole idea of signing up for a niche site, believe me its necessary. There just arent enough people on each individual site in any area to make them work separately. And thats hardly the owners fault. If anything, I think they were smart to evolve. And the other sites are similar in that they are people not being shallow - lots of vegetarian and earth conscious people in addition to the spiritual and they all tend to have some sort of spiritual belief even if not the main focus.
I really like the profile section - there is plenty of room to really elaborate and not be limited by a few hundred characters if you want to put more. There are decent bonus questions as well and the options to change or remove or hide your answers are helpful.
As far as people - you will need to have a bit wider range than a larger site. There are the same inactivity issues as anywhere but to be fair, it does feel like a bit of a lower %. But anything is lower than the 95% inactivity on the big ones. Maybe 70% inactive? I have had more profile views than I have had on eHarmony with a similar response rate. But again, a much smaller pool which is both good and bad. But the people you meet are also looking for a stronger connection so the further distance is not necessarily as damning as on other sites. Lots of International - but if you are looking to just chat with a few distant people in the meantime they are typically all open to it.
The main reason I like this network of sites though is the lack of scammers and fake accounts. I have had zero issue here and its worth the smaller pool in a way to not have it being infested with parasites you need to sort through. They might exist, but I have not come across any myself that I know of.
As far as matches and searches - same problems as everywhere. Inactive accounts. Outside parameters. No worse, but no better.
All in all, if you are in any way focused on spirituality, earth, dietary preference, any sexual preference (including poly) etc. and have some more patience and flexibility, it is worth a shot. It doesn't feel like a scam anyway and that alone is refreshing.
*Edit: I forgot to add that this site DOES have an activity feature. I have seen "last few days" which applies to someone who just logged off as well; "last month"; "last 3 months"; "last 6 months" and "last year". As with all, the first one is really what you want but still, its nice that they are not afraid to have this and you have a decent idea of how much time you might be wasting by reaching out to someone.
Thank you for your thorough review, much appreciated. We grow every month and our members are amazing!
Spiritual Singles is the flagship site of the Conscious Dating Network, which is comprised of several spiritual and green dating sites. The two niches dovetail so nicely, that we decided to put them all in one big database which gives members way more members to meet than if the sites were all individual (as you mentioned). Thank you for recognizing the brilliance! We agree! :) We are smaller than the humungous mainstream sites, but everyone on Spiritual Singles (and the network) joined because they have a high life priority of their spirituality and/or their eco-consciousness. So there is no trying to find the needle in the haystack, we've already done that part for you by providing a quality pool of eligible, conscious singles!
And yes, we do keep the site free of scammers as much a possible, so thanks for mentioning that too.
We wish you the BEST! Much love.