I received my first bag from Purse Valley and will definitely be going back for more. The bag i initially ordered (LV Montana in amarante) was out of stock but they let me switch it to the amarante Alma BB so I didn't have to wait for new Montana stock.
I'm fortunate enough to have a real Alma in my collection so I was able to make a side by side comparison. The PV bag is definitely a high quality replica. The only differences that stood out were a couple of imperfect stitches on the cross-body strap and that the lock is brushed metal instead of polished. So, I don't use the strap and moved my real LV lock to the replica when it's being used. The finish of the replica vernis is perfect.
Yes, it's a little bit of a hassle going through the payment verification process, but let's remember this company is selling goods that put them at high risk. You want to skip the hassle, go to the real LV and spend 10x's as much. Life's a trade-off.