Marc P.

My initial feeling was that Starcitygames offered great prices for your cards. I was excited to be offered nearly $5,000 for my collection of cards, which I felt was a fair price. My first complaint is that in the first ~2-3 days my cards were in the cart, nearly all of them went down in price. I suspect they used my cart/cookies to see which ones I wanted to sell to them, and in turn they reduced the value ~$250. Okay, fine. Not happy about it, but fine. Sent them out, service was friendly, I was exuberant. Upon grading my cards and receiving an approval email I found that they marked down my cards $1,200! Nearly 25%! When I was expecting at most 5-7%. As if they weren't already going to make thousands of dollars off the exchange, they felt the need to sap me out of more. I have been playing MTG for over 10 years and have knowledge of the guidelines people use to grade cards. That being said, their grading was unacceptably strict and the official price they offered me was laughable. THERE WERE NUMEROUS CARDS THAT I EITHER OPENED IN A PACK OR BOUGHT NM, NEVER PLAYED WITH, AND THEY MARKED AS EITHER LIGHTLY OR HEAVILY PLAYED. Now I have to pay for shipping AGAIN to get my cards back. Please do yourself a favor and DO NOT sell your cards here.