We’re in this together! Stay safe with our COVID-19 guide

Developed in part with a grant from
the National Science Foundation

George B.

  • 2 Reviews
  • 7 Helpful Votes
  • 0 Thank Yous

Experience: Finance

Member since September 2013

  • Reviews


  • First Review


  • Thank Yous


  • Fans


  • Profile Views


Review Distribution

2 Reviews by George

I have been trading for many years. I came across Clayburg's website and was quite impressed with all the automated strategy results he posted. It's quite easy to become mesmerized by the results thinking you can make hundreds of thousands a year. And to find out a Doctor actually programmed the strategies... wow, even more impressive (until you find out he's a vet)

After buying into his Automated Strategies (which are very costly) I found a very harsh reality. I spent many many hours setting everything up properly, studying all materials. I was obsessed with figuring out the ins and outs of the system.

The actual results proved to be extremely disappointing. Not only did I lose my money on Clayburg's systems. I was losing money every day running his systems... and believe me I did everything to set it up right. Finally after running his systems for over a month and losing a lot of money I stopped. The kicker was that he would post gains on his site while in reality the days would end up as losers. I would ask him why and he claimed slippage.

You see, what he posts are results from the TradeStation or Multicharts automations... or simulations... they are not ACTUAL results. In the meantime, I learned the ACTUAL results myself and I could post a whole new set of numbers... all in red.

In addition, he claims you can call him or email him anytime. Yes you can do this but he will NOT return phone calls... his emails are one word answers. If you DO get him on the phone he barely speaks giving one word answers. He has got to be the most unfriendly person I have came across. Talk about not caring about your customers.

I'm ashamed and embarrassed I ever got involved with him. Yes you can call me stupid because I was taken by him, big time. However, maybe I can help out some fellow traders and you that you should stay away from John Clayburg. He is a scam... or perhaps more professionally put... a fraud.
I was a part TradeStocksAmerica for quite some time. Since I left I joined a "real" trading room. Now I am profitable... at Trade Stocks America it was nothing but losing money day after day with very little help. Mitch would use general statements about stocks saying "ABC looks toppy". Half the time it seemed like he did not even pay attention.

Then when you try to chat to Mitch or ask questions he barely answers. If you are lucky you get a word or two. Mitch King is very rude and I think he only cares about his own interests. He does not care about any of his members.

Save yourself some money and keep away.

George Has Earned 7 Votes

George B.'s review of TradeStocksAmerica earned 4 Very Helpful votes

George B.'s review of Clayburg earned 3 Very Helpful votes

George hasn’t received any thanks yous.

George doesn’t have any fans yet.

George isn’t following anybody yet.

Similar Reviewers on Sitejabber


I have to agree with a number of the other reviews here. Tradestocksamerica is not a very good...


Caveat Emptor > Let there be NO Question - this is a scam - with ZERO Training after you get in...