I was skeptical, but my perfume just arrived and it smells exactly like Dolce & Gabbana (red lid). The bottle itself is lovely, heavy glass, very nice quality, and very special as I had it personalized. Great price too! I was so upset when D&G discontinued my favourite fragrance, and am so thrilled to be able to wear it again! Note: D&G was NOT listed on the website, but they were able to recreate it anyway, so don't be afraid to request a scent that isn't listed!