In fairness to this situation I wanted to provide an update. After numerous emails to Wallis and having the facility in Kansas City that provides storage and shipping of their product email also, I did receive a replacement fender. It didn't have the previous defect of missing material but took quite a bit of sanding and contouring to get it fit as well as repositioning mounting holes but now looks good. In fairness also there is a disclaimer on the website that states the fenders are rough and need trimming. More work than I expected or wanted but with that work you can get the desired result.