• Personalization Mall

Personalization Mall

Overview

Personalization Mall has a rating of 2.69 stars from 523 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Personalization Mall most frequently mention customer service, tracking number, and christmas gifts problems. Personalization Mall ranks 80th among Promotional Products sites.

  • Service
    138
  • Value
    134
  • Shipping
    139
  • Returns
    84
  • Quality
    122

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 31.3%
Positive
10
Neutral
1
Negative
21
141
See all photos

What reviewers want you to know

Positive highlights

  • Have ordered from Personalization Mall several times and love their products.

Critical highlights

  • Customer service didn't care one bit about their mistake and left me screwed.
  • As of 12/27, still no package and no delivery date.
How would you rate Personalization Mall?
Top Positive Review

“Beautiful Wind Chime”

Janine T.
2/24/24

I bought my neighbors a wind chime from Personalization Mall, it was well made, and absolutely gorgeous! They recently had to put their dog to sleep and this was the perfect gift! Thank you so much!

Top Critical Review

“Overpriced. Rip-off shipping rates!”

Michael B.
12/9/23

They charged me $25.00 to ship a 12x16x2 box that weighed 3 pounds! They said it was "heavy" so they had to charge more. Their ads state 20% off "site-wide" with coupon, but since almost everything is "on sale" they coupon doesn't really work! I'll never order from them again and wouldn't have ordered this time but needed it for a special occasion. In my opinion - total rip off.

Reviews (523)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (215) personalization mall (68) delivery date (12)
Thumbnail of user brandyc154
1 review
0 helpful votes
October 23rd, 2021

I ordered a customized photo frame. The print looked terrible (registration was off) and the frame itself was cracked when it arrived. I emailed, got a quick response, submitted a photo and the replacement frame was shipped two days later. The replacement frame looked a million times better. Pleased with customer service but clearly the quality is inconsistent.

Tip for consumers:
Quality is inconsistent.

Products used:
Picture frame

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Thanks for sharing your honest feedback Brandy. We strive to delivery quality products in a timely fashion. When things go wrong we look to go the extra mile and make things right for our customers.

Thumbnail of user rosem859
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 16th, 2021

Reading the reviews, I was a bit nervous about ordering an ornament for my grandsons first Christmas, but they had exactly what I want. I am very happy with the ornament, it came the exact day they said it would. And the ornament is awesome. I would have like the writing to be a bit bigger, but that's not their fault. Very impressed and I will definitely order from this company again

Tip for consumers:
Nothing

Products used:
Christmas ornament

Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Thanks for the review Rose! We are happy to have impressed you and look forward to impressing you with future orders.

Thumbnail of user stephaniet138
5 reviews
12 helpful votes
July 18th, 2022

I order from personalization mall almost every Christmas to get gifts for my kids teachers, my coworkers, second cousins, etc. The gifts are affordable and personalized, but they are not the highest quality. They aren't the lowest quality either, just sort of middle of the road. My only real complaint about personalization mall is one Christmas I ordered $150 in gifts and they never came. I contacted personalization mall two days before Christmas. They were prompt in their reply. They couldn't find it. They apologized and refunded the whole order and said if it ever showed up I could keep it free of charge. They handled it well but I was still left scrambling to get gifts two days before Christmas. The package did end up showing up in March. I saved all the gifts for the next Christmas, so it worked out well for me. I recommend this site for affordable personalized items. However, if it's really important or time sensitive, I would recommend spending the extra money and using a more reliable site, like Shutterfly.

Tip for consumers:
Don't use this site for things that are time sensitive. Shipping can take a long time.

Products used:
I bought personalized doormats, coffee mugs, flower pots, aprons, glassware, and kitchenware.

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user samw490
2 reviews
2 helpful votes
December 21st, 2020

Gift did arrive eventually, it was exactly what I ordered but hopefully they made it clearer since my last review about the wait times

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Hello, Sam. Thanks for reaching out and providing this feedback. It looks like your order is being delivered to Canada which, as stated at checkout, can take up to an additional 12 business days for transit. Please note, we are noticing a higher than normal instance of tracking info not updating in a timely manner on behalf of our carrier partners. Your order should arrive within the stated delivery window given your 12/11 ship date. We appreciate your patience, Sam.

Thumbnail of user pauletteg10
3 reviews
4 helpful votes
May 21st, 2018
• Updated review

To my surprise they called me and said that they would refund one of the charges! They also said they were both charged on PayPal which I know I entered my charge card info so not sure what really happened. Just Happy to receive a call and a REFUND. Thank you!

Be CAREFUL
May 21st, 2018
• Previous review

They do not want to refund... I ordered 2 items and the first time the processing did not complete and I tried to use PayPal so I waited over an hour as it stated not to leave this page So because it didn't complete --- I did not go through with accepted PayPal but They processed the order and I had no way of knowing so I ordered again and paid with CC. I left for my vacation and when I came back there were 2 boxes waiting for me at home! I called and they said there was nothing they could do about it. Finally I will get a store credit if I pay to ship it back. I will not be ordering from them again. I would advise others to go somewhere else

Thumbnail of user heathern179
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 6th, 2020

I found the perfect gift for my husband! I loved the results! I would have liked the option to change the image and font but i am happy with the results!

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

We are so pleased you are enjoying your new personalized gift, Heather! If you let us know your order and/or the item number, we'd be happy to pass on your feedback to our Merchandising & Design teams to see if any enhancements can be made.

Thumbnail of user chellel4
1 review
0 helpful votes
November 18th, 2020

I have ordered several products from Personalization mall and all products have been satisfying or as expected.

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M. – Personalization Mall Rep

Thank you so much. Our goal is always at the very least to satisfy our customers and if possible, to wow them!

Thumbnail of user amyl80
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 23rd, 2015

I ordered a glass ornament for christmas from this company, and it came within days of placing the order, which I was pleasantly surprised about. When it arrived, it came with a couple scratches on the glass, so I emailed their customer service and heard back from them within 48 hours. They shipped out a new ornament to me at no charge, and within days it arrived and it looks great! We've ordered with this company before and its always been a good experience. Thank you!

Thumbnail of user taliaj3
1 review
1 helpful vote
February 14th, 2017

I was 100% satisfied with my order! I ordered a personalized valentine teddy bear with my boyfriends name on the teddy bears shirt. It it perfect. I thought the bear would turn out a cheap like quality but the quality of the bear is actually very good. I was very very unhappy with the customer service I received though. If you ever have an issue with an order or want changes made etc... be prepared to have a representative get anxious and then hang up on you. Again, great quality items but HORRIBLE CUSTOMER SERVICE. I've received better service from a hood corner gas station in New York. Just saying.

Thumbnail of user kayl255
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
April 9th, 2015

I think it's a case by case thing when it comes to shipping time. I live in Canada and this company rushed the products out to me just in time for Christmas - we are talking a very last minute order during the most busy time of the year... and they pulled it off!

One issue that I do have is that some of their products are restricted to US states. They blamed the weight/size restrictions on cross border shipping, but come on, I wanted to buy a teeny tiny light weight piece of jewlery. That's ridiculous. At least make up a better bs reason.

Thumbnail of user lorenw6
1 review
1 helpful vote
July 16th, 2014

I ordered a photo name collage frame for my friends new daughter. I customized it with the options they had and i was so excited! Then I was wondering, "I know almost nothing about this website". So I went looking for reviews, and they were all awful! I was so scared I wasted my money. I got an email 3 days after I had ordered my frame saying it had shipped. From then on I tracked it everyday with UPS. Thankfully, 3 days later I got it. It absolutely beautiful! Maybe I just lucky. But I love it and it will be a great gift. Although the name that I had cut out into it, is just cut out into some type of cardboard? Not the best but not the ugliest either. As long as the front view looks good. I would love to order again, but I am skeptic with how many bad reviews this place got in so many places. But I just wanted to say my 1st product was just fine for anyone thinking about getting what I ordered. As for the size, I'm not sure if it depends on how many letters. But mine with 8 letters could fit perfectly above a twin size bed matress.

Thumbnail of user emilyr13
7 reviews
19 helpful votes
December 6th, 2013

I've ordered several items from Personalization Mall. I ordered 2 wine glasses that fit whole bottles of wine, and written a personal message on them. They arrived exactly how I had asked. I ordered a candle with a personal message for mothers day, and it came like we made it. One downfall about the candle was it kind of looked like something I could have made myself just not as perfect, so that was a bit of a bummer to know I spent money on it. But it still came out nicely. I know I ordered something else but I really can't remember. And just recently, I was looking around for thoughtful Christmas gifts for friends and family and thought of Personalization Mall. I found something cute and thoughtful for a friend of mine: a coffee mug with a cute cartoon photo of a cat on it with the option for a personal message written on the cup. I thought it was just adorable so I ordered one with my own message written on it and as it was shown in the preview, it looked great. It was also pretty cheap considering it was personalized. The price of the other gifts I had received through this site have been reasonable as well. I think the candle was $15 plus $4 shipping, and the wine glasses total were $55 with $5 shipping. I always to standard shipping, but I normally received the items in a reasonable amount of time. Usually 4-5 days, which isn't bad at all.
Overall, I think Personalization Mall is a great site to find gifts for family and friends that are more thoughtful than buying them clothes, electronics or plain jewelry. I'll definitely continue to use Personalization Mall for following events to come.

Thumbnail of user josev6
5 reviews
7 helpful votes
January 19th, 2012

I recently bought some gifts for someone here. Products that came looked great. A little different then i thought they would look but they still looked good

2 ratings were submitted through the Sitejabber Browser Extension or converted from reviews due to lack of content.

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Gift giving made easy! Shop thousands of unique, personalized gifts for men, women & kids - for every occasion. Always free personalization & fast shipping.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user personalizationm
Personalization M.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Personalization Mall?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Personalization Mall?