website thubmnail of Gotham Steel
How would you rate Gotham Steel?
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
grey star
South Carolina
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jackie W.
Unfollow Jackie W.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Frying pans scrape up after continuous use. The Baking dishes are awesome. On the frying pans it's as if the coating comes off scratch's really easy any you have to use oil.

Date of experience: November 10, 2023
New York
3 reviews
16 helpful votes
Follow Luigi C.
Unfollow Luigi C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Looks great but...
March 6, 2018

Bought a frying pan, I was very impressed by the quality material used. Six months later the pan still looks like new but the food sticks like crazy. 2 stars for looks.

Date of experience: March 5, 2018
Illinois
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Jackie S.
Unfollow Jackie S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Not happy
December 27, 2022

My husband bought me Gotham pans a couple years ago for Christmas they say they could take metal I did mashed potatoes with my beaters messed up the pan my pans stick after a couple uses I'm not happy I think you are misadvertising your pans

Date of experience: December 27, 2022
Maine
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Norma D.
Unfollow Norma D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Warps
October 16, 2022

So disappointed in my Gotham Steel nonstick 12-inch frying pan. It warped after a year of using it and I paid a lot for the pan. I never misused the pan. Will not buy another and don't recommend it.

Date of experience: October 16, 2022
Missouri
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Brenda R.
Unfollow Brenda R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Non stick
July 28, 2022

It is not true that you can cook eggs and they don't stick! I wasted eggs because I needed them " not scrambled" they stuck so bad I had to throw them away!

Date of experience: July 28, 2022
Arizona
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Gary C.
Unfollow Gary C.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Not as ADVERTISED
August 15, 2021

Everything and I do mean everything sticks. Pans bottom are concaved. You open egg on center and it falls to the sides. Oil in center goes to sides. Bottom is not flat at all.

Date of experience: August 15, 2021
Oregon
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Joan S.
Unfollow Joan S.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Save Your Money
January 28, 2023

These pans I have used daily on low heat & they are discoloring & are no longer non-stick. I have them less than one year and would like to give them to Goodwill but I spent too much money on them!

Date of experience: January 28, 2023
Ohio
8 reviews
0 helpful votes
Follow Allen J.
Unfollow Allen J.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

They are the worst pans I have ever bought, there guarantee they don't back at all. They claim I have the heat to high which if I had it any lower I wouldn't be cooking.

Date of experience: June 9, 2023
Washington
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Ken g.
Unfollow Ken g.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I feel so screwed that I believed the Commeracals all lies this is for sure the worse Cookware ever for 40 Dollars I was so disappointed it sticks and burns everything not to mention it scratches and forget Coustemer service no one cares AHAME ON U GOTHAM STELL ly

Date of experience: October 1, 2023
Canada
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Donna B.
Unfollow Donna B.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Worst Pan
April 14, 2021

Less than a year old and it went out in the trash today. Scratches, food sticks and very hard to clean. Would not recommend.

Date of experience: April 14, 2021
Kentucky
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Barbara H.
Unfollow Barbara H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Not happy
June 14, 2023

Everything sticks plus thehandles get got slow cook time the cleanup is ok but it's a waste because so much sticks to pan

Date of experience: June 14, 2023
Florida
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow Olivia H.
Unfollow Olivia H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Disappointing
January 5, 2023

Food sticks, pots and pans chip and scratch. These are very disappointing. You'd be better off buying from Walmart.

Date of experience: January 5, 2023
Washington
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Patrick P.
Unfollow Patrick P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Bad pan
August 18, 2023

Bought a set of 2 cookies sheets a year ago and one of them is stain fish was sticking to it. Beware when buying

Date of experience: August 18, 2023
New York
1 review
5 helpful votes
Follow Jeannie R.
Unfollow Jeannie R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Not good
January 21, 2023

My pan does not come clean even on low settings even if I scrub with a wash cloth. I would not tell people buy these pans. I am so disappointed.

Date of experience: January 21, 2023
North Carolina
1 review
2 helpful votes
Follow sheila H.
Unfollow sheila H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

The pan does stick
May 24, 2022

They say the cookware doesn't stick. I bought a pan and it does stick. It's not worth the money. Keep your money!

Date of experience: May 24, 2022
New Jersey
1 review
1 helpful vote
Follow Rosanne P.
Unfollow Rosanne P.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

I sent it back to Amazon.
Terrible product if this happens. If someone swallowed this while eating it could of been serious.

Date of experience: August 4, 2021
Washington
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Judith G.
Unfollow Judith G.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Warped
October 31, 2021

I have a glass topped stove and all the pans are warped. You still have to use butter to fry a good egg that isn`t hard cooked

Date of experience: October 31, 2021
Canada
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Karen H.
Unfollow Karen H.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Do not buy
July 14, 2021

My daughter got me the 2 pan sets for my birthday all they do is stick do not recommend I'm goin back to tfal

Date of experience: July 14, 2021
California
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Frances D.
Unfollow Frances D.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Wish I can get my money back. I have thrown them out. Eggs stick. Anything you try to cook sticks to pan and you can't get it off.

Date of experience: October 30, 2022
Texas
1 review
0 helpful votes
Follow Bertis R.
Unfollow Bertis R.
Send Message
Share Review
Report Review

Non stick my butt
April 3, 2024

The coating comes off. It is not hard at all plastic utensils scratch it off. Plum sorry don't buy.

Date of experience: April 3, 2024

Overview

Gotham Steel has a rating of 1.6 stars from 127 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers dissatisfied with Gotham Steel most frequently mention non stick, customer service and frying pan. Gotham Steel ranks 291st among Kitchen sites.

service
39
value
56
shipping
35
returns
28
quality
53
+94