2 reviews for AniList are not recommended
These reviews are not recommended because our content quality algorithms have determined them to be less useful for users researching this business. Our content quality algorithm makes decisions based on a number of proprietary evaluation factors, and is constantly updating and improving over time. Even though these reviews are not displayed by default, they still factor into the overall number of reviews and the average rating for the business.
Germany
2 reviews
0 helpful votes

If you are thinking about switching from MAL, don't. Unless you love toxic communities and mods.
November 23, 2025

I was dissatisfied with some technical aspects of MAL, and the completely irresponsive admins who clearly don't give a s... about users and still after so many years didn't bother implementing one of the most requested features (the possibility of setting titles to be displayed in English).
I deleted my account and switched to AniList.
One day only, and I have been group-trolled by ALL mods including the developers for daring supporting a user's request of a lower minimum amount of required characters for a review (they have set a LAUGHABLE minimum of 2200 which causes a lot of unreadable logorrheic reviews).
A request in the freaking SITE FEEDBACK section of the forum! Why tf do they even bother having that section if they have to go all nuclear on a simple feature request?

Then they found some non-existent pretext to ban me.
Not that I care, I already knew I would leave, who needs a place with people like that.
The community is also quite toxic, it's clear that the average mental/emotional age is very low, it's the typical behaviour of teens in 8th grade syndrome or of socially-inept shut-in otaku whose only way to interact with the world is showing off their otaku knowledge in hyper long reviews written in ridiculously try-hard wannabe-Roger-Ebert language even when they are reviewing a stupid generic isekai, and whose idea of "communication" is proving each other wrong. One dude even asked me "then why do you write" when I told him that I have no desire to counter anybody's opinion and I simply prefer to express mine.
He was completely unable to understand that opinions are subjective and NONE is better than another, therefore it's useless arguing about it.
It's a general thing tho, not just this person.
It's really laughable, I couldn't take it seriously, but it's baffling.

I am middle aged, comics and animations are in part an old hobby and in part a professional interest as I work in the industry myself.
So I had my dose of experiences with toxic communities, which most fandoms are, and otaku ones much more (because of the average age I suppose).
I didn't have many expectations, but AniList managed to scrap them all.
Truly one of the worst websites AND communities that I have ever seen since the times of Pac Man on Commodore 64 and dial-up connections.
It's just a better looking but stinkier manure than MAL.
Do not switch, in both places you have annoying technical quirks, in both places you have admins who don't give the LESSER sh! T about what users need, but at least in MAL nobody bothers you if you want to write a review shorter than 2200 freaking characters, and there aren't so many extremely toxic mods.

Date of experience: November 23, 2025
NL
1 review
3 helpful votes

Toxic community and Moderators.
June 29, 2021

The toxicity among users and moderators such as Taluun is extremely disgusting. Avoid this site...

Date of experience: June 29, 2021
Loading...