4 Red Flags of Fake Reviews (and How to Find the Real Ones)

4 Red Flags of Fake Reviews (and How to Find the Real Ones) article cover

Shopping online can be a treasure hunt, but it’s also a minefield of misleading information. One wrong turn through a glittery trail of five-star reviews can leave you with buyer’s remorse… and a gaping hole in your wallet. 

Fake reviews are very real (ha) – studies estimate that a whopping 30 to 40% of online reviews are based on fabricated experiences. Meaning more than one in three glowing praises or scathing critiques you read could be a carefully crafted lie. 

To fight back against fake reviews, we first need to identify them. Here are four red flags to look out for: 

Red Flag #1: Over-enthusiastic Perfection

A string of perfect scores accompanied by hyperbolic testimonials that sound like lines from a cheesy infomercial? Cue your skepticism. Real users, while happy with a good product, rarely resort to overblown language. Look for reviews that delve into both pros and cons with a healthy dose of reality. Truth thrives in the nuanced, not the overly rosy.

Red Flag #2: Vague Language

Of course, there very well may be customers who had the most amazing (or awful) experience with a company or product. Such situations, though, will typically come with some real-life context and honest, human storytelling. A five-star review that reads like a fortune cookie message (“This product brought me joy!”) should bring you pause. Details are the currency of authenticity.

Red Flag #3: Repetitive Copycats

Ever get the feeling you’ve read the same review multiple times? You’re not imagining things. Fake review factories often churn out recycled text, sprinkling them with minor tweaks across various listings. AI-generated reviews will largely sound the same, too. Watch out for suspiciously similar phrasing, especially if the reviews lack specific details about the product itself.

Red Flag #4: Grammar Goofs

Spelling errors, major typos, nonsensical sentences – these are the spectral fingerprints of hastily assembled fake reviews. While real people make typos (we all do!), a pattern of reviews riddled with grammatical errors can indicate a non-native speaker rushing to meet a quota. Keep your eyes peeled for these linguistic clues.

Where and How to Find Real Reviews

The answer in one catchphrase? Trust the tribe, and seek the verified. As a consumer, you’re not alone in your hunt for the best bang for your buck. Here’s how to find reliable voices you can trust to help guide your purchasing decisions:

  • Verification Indicators: These include verified buyer badges, and reviews from reviewers with a history of feedback written in a consistent voice. 
  • Third-party Review Sites: Sites like Sitejabber, where real users share their honest experiences, are gold mines of authentic insights. They also have features like upvoting and Q&As to help you gain a deeper understanding of a brand or product experience.
  • Specialized Review Sites, Forums, and Communities: Look for sites dedicated to specific products or industries, like consumer electronics or outdoor gear. These sites often attract passionate communities who offer in-depth reviews and comparisons. Communities like Reddit, with focused subreddits, can also be helpful.
  • Social Media: While some influencer reviews can be sponsored, platforms like Instagram, YouTube, and TikTok can offer real-world demonstrations and honest opinions from everyday users.

Remember, a healthy dose of skepticism, thorough research, and cross-referencing are your best friends when making purchases. So, arm yourself with these tips, trust the collective wisdom of your fellow buyers, and go shop with confidence!

Now, if you’ll excuse us, we have a date with a toaster that claims to make perfect avocado toast…