• Godsey Supply

Overview

Godsey Supply has a rating of 4.3 stars from 95 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Godsey Supply most frequently mention customer service. Godsey Supply ranks 6th among Athletic Shoes sites.

  • Service
    8
  • Value
    7
  • Returns
    7
  • Quality
    7
Positive reviews (last 12 months): 100%
Positive
1
Neutral
0
Negative
0
12
See all photos

What reviewers want you to know

Positive highlights

  • Theyre a company with great customer service and they always do everything in their power to satisfy their customers.

Critical highlights

No critical highlights yet

How would you rate Godsey Supply?
Top Positive Review

“Just received my three pairs in the mail.”

Jackson R.
11/6/19

I placed an order with a bit of skepticism a few weeks ago and am very happy to leave a positive review on Godsey Supply. They were in my instagram feed and seemed legit but with really good prices compared to their competitors. Sneakers arrived and they seem to be authentic, I will likely sell one or two pairs and keep one pair for myself. I recommend you give them a try too, better to support a smaller business than a big one.

Top Critical Review

“SCAM ALERT! DO NOT BUY!”

Alex S.
11/12/18

I bought 10 pairs of the Off-White AJ1 UNC in August, only one pair shipped as of now. I sent them several emails to just refund me and cancel my order. I tried to email and Instagram direct message but never got any responses since September! I just want my money back, I am not asking anything more than that! If you want to ruin your business, keep doing that!

Reviews (95)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (22)
Thumbnail of user jacksonr29
7 reviews
36 helpful votes
November 6th, 2019

I placed an order with a bit of skepticism a few weeks ago and am very happy to leave a positive review on Godsey Supply. They were in my instagram feed and seemed legit but with really good prices compared to their competitors. Sneakers arrived and they seem to be authentic, I will likely sell one or two pairs and keep one pair for myself. I recommend you give them a try too, better to support a smaller business than a big one.

Thumbnail of user alexs670
1 review
19 helpful votes
November 12th, 2018

I bought 10 pairs of the Off-White AJ1 UNC in August, only one pair shipped as of now. I sent them several emails to just refund me and cancel my order. I tried to email and Instagram direct message but never got any responses since September! I just want my money back, I am not asking anything more than that! If you want to ruin your business, keep doing that!

Thumbnail of user justing78
Justin G. – Godsey Supply Rep

Hi there Alex. I am so sorry to hear you've had less than a good experience. Upon reviewing your account, I have a confirmation of your refund posting to your account for the canceled order. Please contact your bank if necessary and make sure that your refund has posted properly. You are always free to contact us at: service@godseysupply.us

Thumbnail of user jeffreyc291
4 reviews
20 helpful votes
November 20th, 2019

I would recommend not shopping here if you need your order in a hurry. I have never tried their fast shipping but standard shipping is about 15 days. I think because of the price you may be able to justify that though considering it is ALWAYS lower than anyone else comparatively. Items are authentic. Be careful of other reviews because my experience was entirely different and it seems to be a 50/50. If i make more orders I will update this review.

Fragements pictured below and Fearless 1's Ordered last week

Tip for consumers:
Be patient.

Products used:
Fragment 1's and Fearless 1's

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user soniaf128
1 review
0 helpful votes
April 27th, 2023

Quality materials at a Best price.Awesome place,I've been shopping there for years, very honest and great service.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user amandap289
1 review
5 helpful votes
April 17th, 2019

So often when shopping online you worry if what you are getting is actually what you ordered. With Godsey Supply they guarantee what you are getting and then actually follow through, which let me tell you is RARE! I love to find a good deal on gently used items that may otherwise be hard to find. If Godsey has it that's awesome, but if he doesn't he will go out of his way to find it. You can trust in this company. I love that I am also supporting a local company with a self starter.

Thumbnail of user julianm122
1 review
13 helpful votes
February 20th, 2020

I ordered a pair of turbo greens in December it is now almost March and this company never responds to any of my emails and anytime you try to contact them they don't answer and they obviously don't care about their customers, I had to get PayPal involved and they wouldn't give me my money back so, if you like getting scammed out of your money then this is the company for you

Thumbnail of user freddyb25
1 review
14 helpful votes
November 10th, 2019

Myself and a couple friends placed some bigger orders and we all got it. I do see some bad reviews every now and then, but it's mostly good. I can safely say they are good by my standards.

Thumbnail of user kelw6
1 review
3 helpful votes
January 14th, 2019

The owner of Godsey is a super genuine dude, down to earth and easy to relate to. The quality of the customer service is very much so customizable and Justin (the owner) goes over the board to make sure everything is good and easy for my purchase. Godsey definitely had gone through a bad phase with bad reputation when the owner trusted the crocked crowd, but since the owner is back, I think everyone should give this great brand a second chance.

Thumbnail of user ambers188
1 review
5 helpful votes
April 17th, 2019

Not sure where all thes bad reviews are coming from but godsey supply is wonderful!
Great products & fast delivery!
And awesome customer service!
Many more orders in the future!

Thumbnail of user justing78
Justin G. – Godsey Supply Rep

Thank you kindly for your review Amber. Should you need anything else, feel free to reach out!

Thumbnail of user jessicag175
10 reviews
13 helpful votes
January 24th, 2019

The few bad reviews kinda scared me, but after ordering myself it was an experience no different than ordering something like you do on amazon. Cheers

Thumbnail of user justing78
Justin G. – Godsey Supply Rep

Great to hear, thank you so much Jessica for your business.

Thumbnail of user kendrap23
1 review
4 helpful votes
April 17th, 2019

GREAT quality products, amazing prices and excellent customer service! His prices are so much better than the resell stores I've seen! Keep up the good work Justin!

Thumbnail of user margarets124
8 reviews
9 helpful votes
January 23rd, 2019

Honestly, I was a bit scared with the other reviews, but after I made my purchase they shipped it within 10 days (as expected for what I ordered.) Stayed very communicative with emails, and what arrived was authentic. I purchased a Balenciaga windbreaker and had it checked over. Got it for a steal, and I'm going to leave a review on the site too. Would shop again. I guess they changed management over!

Thumbnail of user tylerh167
1 review
3 helpful votes
February 14th, 2019

Such an easy transaction with a great website. 100% authentic pleas buy with the utmost confidence! The new ownership is doing all of the right things! They are pioneering the sneaker industry by giving shoes at a reasonable cost to help combat the reselling issues we face good prices-better people

Thumbnail of user justing78
Justin G. – Godsey Supply Rep

Thank you Tyler!

Thumbnail of user katherineg86
1 review
5 helpful votes
April 17th, 2019

Literally one of the best companies to order from! Very trust worthy and reliable! Absolutely love them!

Thumbnail of user nicolav8
1 review
12 helpful votes
December 19th, 2019

I have placed 3 orders more than 2 months ago, and haven't received anything. I have sent countless emails and instagram DMs and haven't heard back from them. Even commented in multiple posts, without any response (while every other comment was responded). I am not sure if it is a scam, as it has multiple positive reviews, but note their customer service is terrible and they just hold your money for multiple months, and get anything in return.
Please Godsey Supply, if you read this answer my emails/DMs.

Thumbnail of user kimberlc
2 reviews
1 helpful vote
January 12th, 2019

Ordered three Gucci bags from them. Got all three, sold all there again. Probably don't like resellers but the price was really good. Thanks

Thumbnail of user justing78
Justin G. – Godsey Supply Rep

Thank you so much!

Thumbnail of user johnb3520
2 reviews
6 helpful votes
November 1st, 2019

Shipping was fast. I don't understand a lot of the bad reviews. I made my purchase two weeks ago and got my shoes today. Everything was authentic and packed up super well. Definitely would shop here again, the prices are UNBELIEVABLE compared to other resell platforms.

Thumbnail of user forresth32
1 review
4 helpful votes
April 18th, 2019

Not only did my shoes arrive on time, but you can really tell Godsey Supply cares about helping you find the best fit. Customer service goes above and beyond!

Thumbnail of user bryant87
1 review
6 helpful votes
November 20th, 2019

Personally would not hesitate to do more business with them. Many other people do and seem to be happy but I know you cannot please everyone. Maybe one day.

Thumbnail of user toddb423
1 review
2 helpful votes
December 1st, 2020

Fraudulent charge from this company on bank account. Currently being disputed with bank. Having investigated by local police for a ring of fraud involving stolen accounts and unauthorized transactions for expensive shoes.

Thumbnail of user palmerv1
1 review
16 helpful votes
November 19th, 2019

Purchased a pair of Sean Wotherspoon AM97 from Godsey Supply around a year ago, recently went to sell them at a trusted consignment shop and they were confirmed to be UNAUTHENTIC. After being exposed on Instagram, Andrew from customer service replied and offered me a replacement shoe. It has been over a week and I haven't heard anything regarding the status of the replacement. COMPLETE SCAM STAY AWAY

Thumbnail of user davidp412
6 reviews
1 helpful vote
January 18th, 2019

Always throwing steals. Was skeptical but they proved me wrong by delivering what I ordered and it being real. Godsey is the GOAT.

Thumbnail of user jonc204
1 review
21 helpful votes
April 23rd, 2019

He answered my email once and after that I've emailed him about 5 times no response. Says he's supper busy but is always posting on Instagram and just ignores everyone asking him to check emails. Its been over 2 months since I ordered and I still have nothing. Pretty much just gave this guy a 2 month loan of over 2k he will delete any negative review he sees. Im sure he pays ppl to post positive stuff. Everyone's positive reviews pretty much sound the same how he reply's quick communicates right away and they get orders with in 3 weeks which is a lie. I've notice that on this review site everytime someone post something negative about 6 accounts will comment positive pretty strange wouldn't doubt if godsey is out here making fake accounts and giving himself positive reviews. I've left negative comments on insta and on his actual sales page to make ppl aware and he deletes them he doesn't want customer to see the truth he will only leave what's positive and lie to customers. He will say that we are the liars and he's never done business but I have proof of my purchases. Called my credit card company yesterday to dispute charges since he won't reply for a refund. Also he hit me with my items got held by customs but they had gotten release that was a month ago he tells everyone the same story. I've message ppl that I see asking him to check emails to see what he tells them and it's the same story I also have proof of that.

Thumbnail of user blakec42
1 review
2 helpful votes
January 13th, 2019

I got two pairs of vans from them, because they had a 50$ of off 100$. 100% authentic Yacht club and red vans for only 90$! Would purchase again!

Thumbnail of user gavinr76
4 reviews
1 helpful vote

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

A premium online consignment store offering great style for any budget. A huge selection of 100% Guaranteed authentic styles available. Our goal is to maintain a strong commitment to community while providing a safe and reliable platform to buy and sell sneakers, clothing, and other accessories.

Business History

Our objective is to deliver a large range of 100% authentic goods and maintain the fashion culture that surrounds street-wear with a commitment to our community. We are a premium resell & online consignment marketplace that have the goal of finding the lowest price for (you) our buyers. We offer a selection of verified authentic products that we take pride in by offering competitive market prices. Each pair of shoes and all clothing/accessories are professionally authenticated by our in house professional team in a three step process.

Godsey Supply is a "collectors quality" consignment marketplace, items we carry on this website are provided by independent sellers, and our own personal inventory, then shipped to us for authentication or straight from our team.

*Collectors quality refers to products that have not been used and are still considered to be in new condition.

https://godseysupply.us/

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user justing78
Justin G.
Chief Executive Officer
Proud owner of several medium-small scale businesses. Directly in charge of day-to-day operations with over 4 years in e-commerce ownership and sales as well as 6+ years of experience in luxury fashion houses and private label brands.
Preferred partner with several processors and agencies. Consultation, SEO, and marketing professional.

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Godsey Supply?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Godsey Supply?