I've been a member of Shoedazzle for about 3 months now. The reviews previous that are all surprised that they are not 'exclusive' shoes, that a selection of 5 shoes sucks and that they didn't know there was a $39.95 charge every month are just foolish. Who signs up for something on the internet, provides a credit card number and doesn't read what it's all about?
Shoedazzle does carry many different brands of shoes. So far I've seen Bebe, Nyla, Chinese Laundry, Michael Antonio and now casual shoes such as Converse and Sketchers. Most often if you comparison shop the shoes you are interested in at SD you'll see that they sell for twice, sometimes more, than what SD charges!
As for the monthly charge, there is a 'skip the month' button on your main showroom that you can select between the 1st and 5th of each month. Personally, I select it every month whether I'm going to buy shoes or not. Just to be safe. You can skip as many months as you like, for as long as you like. But the option is always there to purchase, even if you've skipped.
Now, the point of there not being much selection... there is a fanpage on Facebook where other customers post pictures of their purchases. This is excellent as not only do you get a different look at the shoes, which most often look nicer than the model pictures, but you get to see ALL the Shoedazzle selections. If you know the name of the shoe you can then look it up by typing the url in.
The customer service is AMAZING. That fanpage I mentioned is staffed! You go on there, post your question, complaint or concern, along with your client number and customer service will be phoning YOU moments after you've posted it! (During business hours of course) I'm in Canada and have had a defective shoe delivered... with the thousand of shoes they ship out daily it's bound to happen... customer service phoned me immediately. Because shipping back from Canada is so expensive they said 'Keep the shoes and we'll send you a new pair!' I got the other pair fixed at the cobblers! In the States you get free shipping, even for returns! And you can returns for whatever reason, defective, doesn't fit or you just plain and simple don't like!
I am very happy with Shoedazzle and would recommend it to anyone. But as with anywhere you're going to provide your credit card information... do your homework!